- Joined
- Mar 1, 2011
- Posts
- 4,174
- Likes
- 3,664
- Location
- Perth
- AFL Club
- West Coast
- Other Teams
- Leeds United
Thread starter
#1
Based mainly on output this year (form, consistency, durability, skill), which of our players do you think would walk into any club's best 22?
I can think of only one definite - Shannon Hurn.
Coming very close would be Lecras and McKenzie, but I couldn't say either of them with 100% confidence. Lecras has dropped off a touch recently, certainly he has had better seasons, and it's slightly harder for EMac due to the limited number of available spots in any given side for a KPD (for example, the Hawks wouldn't take him if Gibson, Lake and Schoenmakers were all fit and firing).
If this were 2012 I might have included Nicnat, but he is too inconsistent this season and can't take a grab to save himself (a ruckman averaging 1.4 marks a game? Even with everything else he contributes, come on).
Am I missing anyone? Please tell me I am.
I can think of only one definite - Shannon Hurn.
Coming very close would be Lecras and McKenzie, but I couldn't say either of them with 100% confidence. Lecras has dropped off a touch recently, certainly he has had better seasons, and it's slightly harder for EMac due to the limited number of available spots in any given side for a KPD (for example, the Hawks wouldn't take him if Gibson, Lake and Schoenmakers were all fit and firing).
If this were 2012 I might have included Nicnat, but he is too inconsistent this season and can't take a grab to save himself (a ruckman averaging 1.4 marks a game? Even with everything else he contributes, come on).
Am I missing anyone? Please tell me I am.

