Carlton Spine:
Thornton
Waite
Murphy
Kennedy
Fevola
Murphy could be switched with any other gun midfileder like Simpson or Stevens. Setanta could replace a backman if needed. Lance could play CHB or CHF.
Absolutely craps on:
Dawson (Sorry but you couldn't lure Thornton)
Croad (If he ever plays again)
Mitchell
Buddy (I realise CHF's should be able to mark overhead)
Williams (I realise FF's should be over 5 foot 10)
Not even a contest!
Thornton
Waite
Murphy
Kennedy
Fevola
Murphy could be switched with any other gun midfileder like Simpson or Stevens. Setanta could replace a backman if needed. Lance could play CHB or CHF.
Absolutely craps on:
Dawson (Sorry but you couldn't lure Thornton)
Croad (If he ever plays again)
Mitchell
Buddy (I realise CHF's should be able to mark overhead)
Williams (I realise FF's should be over 5 foot 10)
Not even a contest!
Thornton / Dawson- better then dawson but thats saying alot now isnt it?
Waite / Croad - Croad is only 27 y/o... if he ever plays again?
Murphy / Mitchell - Mitchell any day of any week
Kennedy / Franklin - Your joking right? ... not even going to respond to this.... Goals>>>>Overhead Marks
Williams / Fev - The 1 major upside of your spine.... yet it doesnt really do you no good if the rest of the spine is subpar and cant get the ball to him
And FWIW, Mitchell could be swapped with Hodge/Lewis who >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Simpson/Stevens
And even though our spine is not the best, yours is still nearly if not just as bad as ours.

