Just for reference this is what Madden looked like in 2010, on a Playstation 3:
AFL Evo is a flaming pile of garbage, made by a studio that refuses to be remotely creative with their budget.
They're about 12-15 years behind their competitors, and are a joke in the context of modern game development.
They're a small development team with probably 5% the budget / audience of those games so I wouldn't expect the graphics to be on the same level.
I don't really give a rats about graphics anyway, gameplay is what's important and from most reports on Bigfooty AFL Evo 2 launch thread, it's markedly improved from the first game (which admittedly it needed to be.) We'll wait and see how the dust settles with patches etc over the next couple of weeks but it's certainly got some promise as people are reporting it actually plays like footy now.
Anyways, I won't say any more on this here as it's probably not the place and I don't want to derail your thread too much.