Who from...

[moses]

Who from the 1997 Grand Final team (not at their current age ofcourse), would you place in our current best 22.

Adelaide
B: 44 Peter Caven 35 Rod Jameson 34 Ben Hart
HB: 23 Andrew McLeod 15 David Pittman 36 Simon Goodwin
C: 14 Matthew Connell 3 Darren Jarman 5 Kym Koster
HF: 24 Clay Sampson 10 Matthew Robran 7 Nigel Smart
F: 42 Chad Rintoul 13 Shane Ellen 18 Troy Bond
Foll: 52 Shaun Rehn 28 Kane Johnson 26 Mark Bickley (Capt)
Int: 9 Tyson Edwards 11 Brett James 20 Aaron Keating
Coach: Malcolm Blight

I would have the following:
Rehn
McLeod
Jarman
Pittman
Edwards
Goodwin
Hart
Smart
Bickley

 

[JPetro83]

Rehn
McLeod
Jarman
Cavan
Edwards
Goodwin
Hart
Smart
Johnson

 

[weekend at bernies]

Who are they replacing??

 

[CrowsB4hoes]

Blight

 

[Rory Walkerfield]

Who from the 1997 Grand Final team (not at their current age ofcourse), would you place in our current best 22.

Adelaide
B: 44 Peter Caven 35 Rod Jameson 34 Ben Hart
HB: 23 Andrew McLeod 15 David Pittman 36 Simon Goodwin
C: 14 Matthew Connell 3 Darren Jarman 5 Kym Koster
HF: 24 Clay Sampson 10 Matthew Robran 7 Nigel Smart
F: 42 Chad Rintoul 13 Shane Ellen 18 Troy Bond
Foll: 52 Shaun Rehn 28 Kane Johnson 26 Mark Bickley (Capt)
Int: 9 Tyson Edwards 11 Brett James 20 Aaron Keating
Coach: Malcolm Blight

I would have the following:
Rehn
McLeod
Jarman
Pittman
Edwards
Goodwin
Hart
Smart
Bickley

Also:
Jameson >>> hartigan
Robran >=? Jenkins
Johnson >>> most of our side

 

[JPetro83]

Imagine the team!
Hart Talia Laird
Smith Cavan Smart
Johnson Thompson Sloane
Lynch Walker Menzel
Betts Jarman Cameron
Rehn Mcleod Goodwin
int: Jacobs, Edwards, Brad Crouch & Douglas

Emg:
Brown
Lever
Seedsman
Jenkins

 

[dogs105]

Rehn
McLeod
Jarman
Cavan
Edwards
Goodwin
Hart
Smart
Johnson

Love Caven, but no. Not IMO.

I'd have Robran too.

Edwards Talia Hart
McLeod Pittman Smith
Koster Thompson Sloane
Betts Robran Lynch
Smart Walker Bond

Rehn
Goodwin
Jarman

Int: Jacobs, Goodwin, Laird, Crouch
E: Douglas brown lever

 

[dogs105]

From 98 I'd find room for Roo, Stevo and Vardy (at their peak, not necessarily 98)

 

[1990crow]

Hart to replace Hartigan. Rehn to combine with Sauce. Johnson, McLeod, Edwards, Goodwin, McLeod, Jarman, Smart, Bickley, Jameson all in.

Edwards - Talia - Jameson
Laird - Hart - Goodwin
Smith - Thompson - Sloane
Rehn - McLeod - B.Crouch
Jarman - Walker - Smart
Betts - Jenkins - Lynch
Jacobs - Johnson - Bickley - Douglas

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

B: Laird, Talia, Hart
HB: Smart, Caven, Smith
C: Johnson, McLeod, Sloane
HF: Lynch, Robran, Douglas
F: Betts, Walker, Jarman
R: Rehn, Goodwin, Edwards
I: Jacobs, Thompson, Bickley, Jameson
Coach: Blight

 

[baldandbroke]

Cmon people - Brett James - get him in there !!

I loved his footy brain - and his skills.

 

[Pugsley]

Who from the 1997 Grand Final team (not at their current age ofcourse), would you place in our current best 22.

Adelaide
B: 44 Peter Caven 35 Rod Jameson 34 Ben Hart
HB: 23 Andrew McLeod 15 David Pittman 36 Simon Goodwin
C: 14 Matthew Connell 3 Darren Jarman 5 Kym Koster
HF: 24 Clay Sampson 10 Matthew Robran 7 Nigel Smart
F: 42 Chad Rintoul 13 Shane Ellen 18 Troy Bond
Foll: 52 Shaun Rehn 28 Kane Johnson 26 Mark Bickley (Capt)
Int: 9 Tyson Edwards 11 Brett James 20 Aaron Keating
Coach: Malcolm Blight

I would have the following:
Rehn
McLeod
Jarman
Pittman
Edwards
Goodwin
Hart
Smart
Bickley

I'm with you

 

[VSTone]

Cmon people - Brett James - get him in there !!

I loved his footy brain - and his skills.

yep thinking the same thing myself... and would seriously hurt 95% of our current team...harder than nails and a fair dinkum animal in both GF's.

 

[moses]

yep thinking the same thing myself... and would seriously hurt 95% of our current team...harder than nails and a fair dinkum animal in both GF's.

Thought about James, very underatted. Oh and VB out, Ellen in

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Cmon people - Brett James - get him in there !!

I loved his footy brain - and his skills.

Would love to, but I couldn't even squeeze in b crouch!

 

[Slippery Pete]

I noticed some people had Jenkins ahead of Robran.

All I have to say to those people is, I hope you're enjoying school holidays.

 

[Grenville]

Who from the 1997 Grand Final team (not at their current age ofcourse), would you place in our current best 22.

Adelaide
B: 44 Peter Caven 35 Rod Jameson 34 Ben Hart
HB: 23 Andrew McLeod 15 David Pittman 36 Simon Goodwin
C: 14 Matthew Connell 3 Darren Jarman 5 Kym Koster
HF: 24 Clay Sampson 10 Matthew Robran 7 Nigel Smart
F: 42 Chad Rintoul 13 Shane Ellen 18 Troy Bond
Foll: 52 Shaun Rehn 28 Kane Johnson 26 Mark Bickley (Capt)
Int: 9 Tyson Edwards 11 Brett James 20 Aaron Keating
Coach: Malcolm Blight

I would have the following:
Rehn
McLeod
Jarman
Pittman
Edwards
Goodwin
Hart
Smart
Bickley

If you're looking at the players as they were in 97, rather than the players they'd go on to become then Kane Johnson was head and sholders above Edwards and Goodwin in my opinion.