It's a hard one to judge.Really surprised by the result of the poll.
I would have had Shuey last of the 3.
Maybe people are remembering his last game (which was obviously sensational), but he had a bit of a downer in 2018 imo.
Yeo has been a lot better than him over the last two years. Gaff as well.
I mean last year you guys gave Yeo 48.29 votes, compared to Shuey 22.84. Gaff finished with 33.08. It's pretty self evident that week to week people think Yeo is better. That's why I'm surprised by the results.
The poll was for "best player" as well, not "most important". I could see an argument that Shuey is more important, but Yeo has clearly been the best player.
If Gaff hits last season's form I'd have him as our best but I didn't want to weight everything on 2018 so I guess I sort of read it as: Who do I think will be our best midfielder this year.
Shueys attributes make for the best package. Yeo could be anything he just isn't as good a ball user.