who is the better team

[HARKER]

Carlton are, but there not legitimate. Even if they win a flag it will be looked on as a cheated premiership.

We've paid for our crime well and truly.
You can't convict a man for the same crime twice, can you?

As for the better team:

a. Nice Answer: Carlton has the better crop of players and are primed to make the eight at worst this year. Collingwood has been playing above themselves and will dip before any possible rise back to the eight.

b. Honest Answer: Carlton of course. Are you all ****ing mad?

 

[HARKER]

lol what a ridiculous thread!

Colling has lost Buckleys, Clement, Licuria, Holland & wakelin to retirement, but yet played in the last 3 finals series & won finals for that matter too!

This year the pies lost Rocca, Rusling, Reid & Presti.. Yet still played finals with Dawes & Anthony as there go to forwards.. On top of that Didak & Shaw missed the last 5 games & finals!

The pies have a very young list, that will only get better...

Carlton havent played finals since 2001 & have had 3 number 1 picks injected & Chris Judd/Stevens & still cant play finals.

They rely on Fev way too much & there so lucky he is durable because if he got injured they would finish last without a doubt! There second goal kicker was Fisher & that is saying something!!

They have no backline & simply put are not in the same league.. If they get some key injuries then they will be bottom 4 for sure!

And that is why Carlton beat you twice last year.
More potential in the Carlton group than Collingwoods.

 

[Tigeritis]

It comes down to the coach. I would much prefer an experienced coach like Malthouse to handle potential than a novice like Ratten. Collingwood are a solid unit that play excellent team football. Carlton still rely on too few to get their wins. Collingwood are the better 'team', easily.

 

[Palmer Stoat]

In Carlton vs Collingwood we all know who is more superior recently between them.

That'd be the team that's played finals the last three years.

 

[pieman123]

besides kreuzer,murphy,gibbs and yarran there isnt much else to be excited about with collingwood we have thomas,pendlebury,mccarthy,sidebottom,anthony,cloke,rusling,dawes,reid,obrien,brown,clarke,shaw,wellingham,beams,wood,goldsack,dick,cox,macaffer,reed,keefe

 

[Themi#9]

Carlton by a long way.