Who steps up and cements a spot?

[barrackers]

Nat Fyfe actually got lots of the ball and was an elite mark... I wish Tyler was half as good as that.

Elite mark? Ok, it’s only one highlight but...

 

[barrackers]

I reckon it might take another year of development for Tyler Brown. He's shown some flashes and had some good games. But he's still a skinny inconsistent beanpole. Only averages 15 disposals which is light on for a prospective midfielder.

Low disposal numbers is probably the main knock on him currently. Prioritising midfield development over cheap kicks in the backline impacts that. Even though that midfield move was ahead of time it was a good decision.

Really like his work in close and movement around the contest including his want to engage and bounce off his direct opponent. A bit more size will help.

 

[BEEG]

IQ with a big preseason

 

[No SPIN]

I would like to see Shaz move into Mayne's role and cement his spot longterm accordingly.

 

[rand corp]

I am expecting T Brown, IQ and Noble to have big years in terms of the new kids.
I am hoping Langdon gets back better and stronger than ever, same with Beams.
Keanne, Wilson could be smokies.

 

[Fratbrat]

Elite mark? Ok, it’s only one highlight but...

And managed to injure himself too, he is ready for the seniors!

 

[Anzacday]

Low disposal numbers is probably the main knock on him currently. Prioritising midfield development over cheap kicks in the backline impacts that. Even though that midfield move was ahead of time it was a good decision.

Really like his work in close and movement around the contest including his want to engage and bounce off his direct opponent. A bit more size will help.

He's been compared to Fyfe, I liken him more to Rory Sloane.

 

[Horaceg]

Even if you're right, there's no way he is de-listed before the end of 2021.

.....or until we replace him with another Daicos

 

[cityslick1]

Murphy and Sier if they can stay uninjured. I think both have the capacity to be best 22 locks by midseason.

Quaynor, T Brown and Keane will be in the "showing something" category but not cement.

I think Kelly will have another injury ruined year. Atu is still a project.

I dont think Daicos will make it.

This... except Josh has one more chance. When on song, he looks like a sidey replacement. Lateral movement exquisite, kicking good... just has no height or obvious weapons

 

[Apples]

Nathan Murphy, Isaac Quaynor, Tyler Brown.......and Sier if he gets smart and sends flowers to his ditched gf. She may have moved on of course.

 

[Soups]

I wouldn’t be surprised if Murphy played round 1 next year if fit. They will look to fast track him imo.

 

[magpies42]

most likely hopefully Murphy and Sier if they can stay fit.

I would like to see Daicos and Brown perform better and genuinely push the 22, not just on account of injuries

 

[slugger01]

Tom Wilson !!!

Will debut round 1.
Will be promoted to the leadership group during the mid season bye.
Will be elevated to co-captain with Pendles at the start of the finals series.
Will be installed as captain for the Grand Final, and be the Collingwood premiership captain in 2020.

What a guy.

 

[Johno9911]

Shaz, murphy and Sier for mine, certainly aren't dark-horses by ant stretch seeing as we have seen all 3 at senior level but feel like we could see a big jump from all 3 this year.

Shaz I feel will come down to role and health. A move up the ground to replace Mayne (a more defensive minded mid to offset our attack heavy midfield), we could see the best of his elite kicking and defensive capabilities.

Murphy I feel like could be the big bolter into the 22. Can be used at either HB or HF flank and moves well and has good hands.

Sier - if bear can get back to doing bear things for a whole season, we will be much better placed.

 

[HenrikLundqvist]

Tom Wilson !!!

Will debut round 1.
Will be promoted to the leadership group during the mid season bye.
Will be elevated to co-captain with Pendles at the start of the finals series.
Will be installed as captain for the Grand Final, and be the Collingwood premiership captain in 2020.

What a guy.

Just play him!!!!

 

[Finnishpie]

Question is, who is going to make way?

Aish, Mayne, Varcoe,” and C Brown - all a touch vulnerable.

So, in their positions:

Quaynor/Noble/Murphy/Sharenberg or Daicos/Sharenberg/T Brown/Broomhead, and Daicos/Broomhead.

Will depend a lot on our injuries of course.

 

[ThePhantom777]

The Bear

 

[Go Pies!!!!!]

Bear, Sharenberg & Murphy would be the 3 for me, we need players performing in the VFL putting pressure on the AFL players.

 

[iGNITER]

Quaynor will lock down his spot in the backline.

 

[manicpie]

Callum Brown for me, He will be bigger and stronger, his goal average will increase as he keeps playing his role and his pressure is already elite. I think he will become one of our best midfielders in the next 2 or 3 years

 

[Leviathan Pie]

Reality is our stocks in this conversation are thin.

C.Brown & J.Daicos are exposed, and very average. T.Brown shows flashes of excitement, but still looks off the pace, W.Kelly is a walking injury, he'll need a solid 24 months at it before we can pass judgement.

Only one who really might make some sort of progression is I.Quaynor or N.Murphy, but still both very speculative - latter might have 'it', but body again needs to hold up.

 

[LarryKinn]

Question is, who is going to make way?

Aish, Mayne, Varcoe,” and C Brown - all a touch vulnerable.

So, in their positions:

Quaynor/Noble/Murphy/Sharenberg or Daicos/Sharenberg/T Brown/Broomhead, and Daicos/Broomhead.

Will depend a lot on our injuries of course.

Add Greenwood, who wont be back till the back end of the season.
Reckon Callum, JT & Varco ( & to a lesser extent Daicos & Broomhead ) are all fighting for 1 spot

 

[Go Woods]

Murphy & Quaynor my big tips....Noble and T Brown should get regular senior games. Daicos needs a big 2020...

 

[ClaytonM]

Tom Wilson !!!

Will debut round 1.
Will be promoted to the leadership group during the mid season bye.
Will be elevated to co-captain with Pendles at the start of the finals series.
Will be installed as captain for the Grand Final, and be the Collingwood premiership captain in 2020.

What a guy.

Piss weak effort really. No Brownlow.

 

[neilk]

Piss weak effort really. No Brownlow.

Nor Norm Smith