Banter Who will be better in 2024? Carlton or Collingwood? Part 2

[adammania9]

So has nothing to do with the amount of time but the celebrations? Surely you jest

I know it's been a long time in between drinks for the Blues, but premierships tend to be celebrated for a while

 

[carlton_99]

I know it's been a long time in between drinks for the Blues, but premierships tend to be celebrated for a while

6 months long? Yikes

 

[Fadge]

Fly whipped out the magic wand and did an "Accio spuddus!" to get this year's team?

Jeepers.

Where does that leave Carlton if a team of spuds beat them twice?

 

[CarmenSandiego]

• Collingwood have dropped off in 2024 because of their celebrations in September 2023.

tbf im still recovering from my ressies flag 11 years ago. was a big week.

 

[Worm4]

Short pre-season following incredible premiership celebrations. I fear for the league next season with a proper Collingwood pre-season

Short preseason ? Jesus.
Doesn't seem to have affected Brisbane too much
As for a proper pre season, agreed , pies will have an extra 5 weeks up their sleeve to nurse the oldies through the summer

 

[Worm4]

Collingwood's current list isn't the result of 20 years of building and rebuilding.

It must have been awful to wake up to the realisation on Sunday morning that I was right all along, and Carlton are nothing more than a middle of the road team, at a time when their list is in their prime.

Oh no.

No , you had us at 16th.
You are way off.
You had pies at top 4.
You are way off again
You had Saints top 4
Again .....way off

 

[CarmenSandiego]

can we take a moment and explore why tf anyone would have saints top 4 this year?

Fadge you need to explain yourself on this one, this is absurd. the collingwood/carlton predictions - fine, bit of banter mixed in with hatred & passion, but your saints prediction?

elaborate.

 

[Robertio]

So did Collingwood win?

Read what you're replying to.

 

[adammania9]

Short preseason ? Jesus.
Doesn't seem to have affected Brisbane too much
As for a proper pre season, agreed , pies will have an extra 5 weeks up their sleeve to nurse the oldies through the summer

The third Carlton fan in 10 minutes with appalling comprehension skills

 

[adammania9]

Read what you're replying to.

You've gone both ways, so I'm trying to clear up what you're trying to say

 

[Worm4]

The third Carlton fan in 10 minutes with appalling comprehension skills

What part of short pre season did I miscomprehend ?

 

[Robertio]

Jeepers.

Where does that leave Carlton if a team of spuds beat them twice?

That's about your best post out of your thousands.

 

[adammania9]

What part of short pre season did I miscomprehend ?

Short pre-season following incredible premiership celebrations. I fear for the league next season with a proper Collingwood pre-season

Can any of you three remind me what premiership the Lions celebrated last year?

 

[Worm4]

Can any of you three remind me what premiership the Lions celebrated last year?

So Collingwood started pre season later than Brisbane ? Can you confirm this ?
Celebrations or not ...

 

[Madblue]

Oh well done.

Your team has peaked at challenging for the top 8 after building and rebuilding for more than two decades, whilst my team is the reigning premier.

Who cant make the 8 this year Pathetic GF defence

 

[Madblue]

The unfortunate truth is that Carlton seem to spend a lot of games playing their worst football....

And yet still in the 8 and your rabble arent

 

[adammania9]

So Collingwood started pre season later than Brisbane ? Can you confirm this ?
Celebrations or not ...

Plenty of beers and more went around. Takes a bit of time to work off

 

[Forward Press]

Who cant make the 8 this year Pathetic GF defence

Better a pathetic premiership defence, than having no premiership to defend.

Carlton may very well win a flag with this list - good luck to them, despite some on here I think long-suffering Blues fans that stuck through the 2000s deserve it - but until they do, trolling Collingwood for being out of finals after a flag is a bold strategy.

 

[Worm4]

Better a pathetic premiership defence, than having no premiership to defend.

Carlton may very well win a flag with this list - good luck to them, despite some on here I think long-suffering Blues fans that stuck through the 2000s deserve it - but until they do, trolling Collingwood for being out of finals after a flag is a bold strategy.

Its a strategy nonetheless
Look at the glass half full side - pies sitting in double digits hanging shit on Carlton who are in the top 8.
They should be embarrassed their club has let them down this year. Pre season flag favourites and all.....

 

[Arr0w]

Just pointing out hypocrisy.

Coming from you is rich

More original material in just 48 hours than your entire posting history Mr Broken Record

You keep playing the poster, I'll return serve

Found any evidence? Wouldn't want to be known as a liar

 

[Forward Press]

Its a strategy nonetheless
Look at the glass half full side - pies sitting in double digits hanging shit on Carlton who are in the top 8.
They should be embarrassed their club has let them down this year. Pre season flag favourites and all.....

If Carlton win the flag, then sure.

But they haven't, yet.

Not even the worst flag defence in the past handful of years, there's a side that won a flag three seasons ago and have not won a final since (and look like continuing with that this year).

 

[Corn Cobbers]

And yet still in the 8 and your rabble arent

Imagine being the only side to lose to our rabble TWICE

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Coming from you is rich



You keep playing the poster, I'll return serve

Found any evidence? Wouldn't want to be known as a liar

That's it... keep name-calling and playing the poster, it's all you've got

Found that all-time table yet with Collingwood not on top ?

 

[Arr0w]

Found that all-time table yet with Collingwood not on top ?

Show me where I said Pies weren't joint leaders?

Keep struggling

 

[adammania9]

Its a strategy nonetheless
Look at the glass half full side - pies sitting in double digits hanging shit on Carlton who are in the top 8.
They should be embarrassed their club has let them down this year. Pre season flag favourites and all.....

You're getting emotional. Eat a Snickers

981 posts in this edition of the thread alone and what will you have to show for it? A losing elimination final but it's a win since the Pies missed the 8 after winning a flag?