Who will be the better player when it's all said and done? Daicos vs Reid vs Horne-Francis

[MadMundy]

All 3 have bright futures in the AFL and all of them have shown they have the elite standard to be the best in the competition, however, if you had to choose, which of these 3 will be the best one? And why?

 

[MF]

Reid for mine. He has it all.

 

[blackshadow]

Harry Sheezel

 

[g_TRAIN]

Reid

 

[Elite Master]

Reid & Horne-Francis are, or will be, far more damaging and explosive with ball in hand.

 

[greening22]

Reid & Horne-Francis are, or will be, far more damaging and explosive with ball in hand.

How good was Horne-Francis tonight in the game against Geelong? He simply could not handle the pressure & went missing. So go back & compare that with Nick's performances in both the 2022 & 23 Finals series, respectively. And remember he came into the 2023 Finals Series after being out injured in the 2023 home & season having missed the final 6 games due to a leg injury. OK. I think far too many individuals on this site will vote against Nick simply because he wears black & white stripes as opposed to looking at the relevant data & performances. Goodnight & good luck.

 

[Cursed Cat]

Max Holmes.

 

[SC_Power]

How good was Horne-Francis tonight in the game against Geelong? He simply could not handle the pressure & went missing. So go back & compare that with Nick's performances in both the 2022 & 23 Finals series, respectively. And remember he came into the 2023 Finals Series after being out injured in the 2023 home & season having missed the final 6 games due to a leg injury. OK. I think far too many individuals on this site will vote against Nick simply because he wears black & white stripes as opposed to looking at the relevant data & performances. Goodnight & good luck.

Well I guess that settles this discussion forever more.
No further correspondence or opinions shall be entered into.

 

[Matrix10]

Harry Sheezel

Jet. Love watching this kid play

 

[Matrix10]

Reid for mine. He has it all.

Of course he does , and with a black and white jumper on he wouldn’t enter top 5 calculatotions. Dipstick

 

[Saints4ever]

Also in the Sheezel camp.

Makes things happen.

No surprise the Roos got absolutely belted in the last 2 games and the Sheez was out injured.

 

[MF]

Of course he does , and with a black and white jumper on he wouldn’t enter top 5 calculatotions. Dipstick

Wow imagine getting so upset you resort to name calling just because someone doesn't choose your player. What a snowflake.

 

[Corn Cobbers]

Poll needed, huge thread

 

[My Tilly]

Reid.

 

[Handsuper47]

No idea, they aren't even in their prime years yet.

 

[TheUnicorn]

Tsatas

 

[dmark]

Reid for mine, daicos is a bit a accumulator, Reid will be raw power and explosive from stoppage

 

[Piggy Smalls]

Its about time people started asking these questions about Murphy Reid. I think he just pips the other two once it's all said and done.

 

[dmark]

Its about time people started asking these questions about Murphy Reid. I think he just pips the other two once it's all said and done.

If we are going to throw randoms in the mix, Nic Watson would have to get a mention!

 

[Obeanie1]

Well Daicos is a mile in front ATM.

Likely wins a Brownlow this season and is already a premiership player, AA and Best and Fairest.

Is older.

Only time will tell.