Who will Collingwood trade?

[kretchy]

How will it be this year that Collingwood will trade to Sydney to win the swans best and fairest.

Andrew Schuable in 2000
Paul Williams in 2001
Nick Davis? in 2002

Altougth Paul Licuria came from Sydney didn't he so they have got one back.

 

[mandy]

Originally posted by kretchy
How will it be this year that Collingwood will trade to Sydney to win the swans best and fairest.

Andrew Schuable in 2000
Paul Williams in 2001
Nick Davis? in 2002

Altougth Paul Licuria came from Sydney didn't he so they have got one back.

Tyson Lane?

 

[NICK THE PIE MAN]

Steve McKee?

 

[JLC]

Betheras to WCE

Scotland to Essenscum

Prestigiacomo to the Bulldogs


I dont think we will trade anyone else. I thought Brent Tuckey was gone but by the sounds of things i coaching staff think highly of him. McKee is safe as it does not appear that we will get another quality ruckman

JLC

 

[mandy]

Won't ANYONE take Tyson?????? PLEEEEEEEEEEASE!

 

[JLC]

Originally posted by mandy5
Won't ANYONE take Tyson?????? PLEEEEEEEEEEASE!

Mandy

Tyson Lane is not our worst player. I would hold onto Tyson as he has good foot disposal and knows how to kick a goal. I would get rid of Dimmatina but i doubt whether any club would pick him up.

I believe next year Licuria and Carl Steinfort will be the two taggers that Malthouse employs. Potentially Licuria will be the most effective due to his endurance and the ability he has to win the ball.

JLC

 

[WCE2000]

Originally posted by JLC
Betheras to WCE

I wouldnt mind having Betheras in our club

 

[hawkfan5]

Originally posted by WCE2000


I wouldnt mind having Betheras in our club

Betheras will be a good player I think, hasn't really been given enough opportunity with the Pies

 

[JLC]

Betheras is a very very good player. He lost his way under Malthouse as we played Rupert as a defender. Betheras is a midfileder who can rack up possessions and makes the most of them.

The only thing stopping Rupert from going to WCE is the fact that WCE hate dealing with Collingwood as they are still hung up over Mick Malthouse.

If a deal cannot be arranged i would keep Rupert as he loves Collingwood and is one of the most popular players at the club.

APA

 

[WCE2000]

JLC,
what do you think Collingwood would accept in a trade for Betheras??

 

[JUBJUB]

Originally posted by WCE2000
JLC,
what do you think Collingwood would accept in a trade for Betheras??

Chad Morrison

 

[JLC]

I think Chad Morrison for sure would be a good deal. Morrison is a more proven player but is coming of a knee injury. I believe Morrison will go to StKilda as WCE refuse to trade with Collingwood,

I would trade Bethera and a draft pick for Andrew Williams. I rate Andrew Williams very highly as he has a great pair of hands and is versatile. I dont watch WCE that much but from what i have seen of him , i like him a lot.

APA

 

[hawkeye]

Hmmmm...A trade for Betheras................what about 4 new tyres!!!!!!

 

[JLC]

Originally posted by hawkeye
Hmmmm...A trade for Betheras................what about 4 new tyres!!!!!!

Nah thats the deal we r saving Aaron Lord. Although really tyres are a little overrated.

 

[hawkeye]

I would be rapt to get just a spare tyre for Lordy!!!!.....Although Lordy wouldnt go anywhere unless a full size mirror was thrown in to sweeten the deal!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[Bucks]

Originally posted by hawkfan5


Betheras will be a good player I think, hasn't really been given enough opportunity with the Pies

Havern't given enough chances?? he played more than half the season.. and collingwood put him in many positions.. remember when Clint Bizzell kicked 6 to beat the pies??? guess who was on him... BBEEETTTHHHEERRAASSS... he was heaps better last year and the year before!.
if WC wants him, they can have him.. we'll trade Betheras for Morrison.

 

[walshy1993]

Originally posted by JLC

Scotland to Essenscum

JLC

ill take him
cant believe this guy isnt playing senior footy at your club
he can run, and has good skills, exactly what we need

would add a lot to our midfield
no matter who we gave collingwood for him, it would be collingwoods loss

 

[Mr Eagle]

Originally posted by Bucks
we'll trade Betheras for Morrison.

Not a hope. How about Greg Harding instead?

 

[GoEagles]

Originally posted by Mr Eagle


Not a hope. How about Greg Harding instead?

What can I say about Greg Harding? How this boy didn't end up as the #1 draft pick, Rising Star winner, Brownlow medalist is beyond me! Instead of trying to trade him for players, we'll give him away PLUS a draft pick for a club to take him off our hands. I think he must be related to Nick Stone somehow.

 

[JLC]

Scotland is a gun player. I will be very very sad to see him go. You have no arguments with me there.


APA

 

[Carltonboy56]

Originally posted by kretchy
How will it be this year that Collingwood will trade to Sydney to win the swans best and fairest.

Andrew Schuable in 2000
Paul Williams in 2001
Nick Davis? in 2002

Altougth Paul Licuria came from Sydney didn't he so they have got one back.

There whole team!

 

[Joel]

Re: Re: Who will Collingwood trade?

Originally posted by Carltonboy56


There whole team!

hahah...NOT!!! That wasn't funny by the way. "There whole team"?

Their whole team.

 

[dogboy23]

Originally posted by JLC
Betheras to WCE

Scotland to Essenscum

Prestigiacomo to the Bulldogs


I dont think we will trade anyone else. I thought Brent Tuckey was gone but by the sounds of things i coaching staff think highly of him. McKee is safe as it does not appear that we will get another quality ruckman

JLC

Is this just what you think or did you hear this somewhere if so where did you hear it.

 

[JLC]

We will see what happens. A friend told me about the Presti one. The other two trades are logical

APA

 

[Carltonboy56]

so what if there was a spelling mistake? Collingwood suck