Who will win a premiership first?

[Geelongfor2008]

Who will win a premiership first? and why

 

[Young Gun #6]

Already been done. With Dogs etc.


It should be done on teams that haven't one a premiership in a long time not teams that won it 2 or 3 years ago and 6 or 7 years ago and 1 that has only been in the league for 10 years.


BTW why aren't Essendon in there?

Port Adelaide and West Coast are better than them when they have a full side.

 

[TigerCleavage]

That's a tough one, I'd probably say West Coast. I just can't see them being down for too long.

 

[weagles_fan]

West Coast has the best list out of these teams and with a top pick this year (probably Rich) as well as some other good youngsters from the draft through trades they will be in the best position to be a flag threat in 2010/2011.

 

[Fortress Hawk]

Who will win a premiership first? and why

I say westcoast because they already have a good backline! The have the best ruckman by far whcih you can build a team around! A few quality mids and a promising forawrd line with the addition of kennedy! Also have the best coach of all four teams above!

 

[Young Gun #6]

West Coast has the best list out of these teams and with a top pick this year (probably Rich) as well as some other good youngsters from the draft through trades they will be in the best position to be a flag threat in 2010/2011.

How can you say West Coast have the best list??

Port have a much better list.

It will defiently be Port or West Coast next to get the glory.

I can honestly not see Port being down for much longer. They have just underperformed and lost about 7 by under 10pts this season. They could be 10-5 easily.

 

[Hawkk]

Port Adelaide without doubt.

Talented young list that clearly overachieved badly last year and decimated in the GF by Geelong.

Probably the most obvious of the bottom 4 clubs this year to rise into the top 4 next year

 

[Tigersman]

Port for me as well.

could see them in the eight next year. not so with the others.

 

[whelan=legend]

Melbourne are continously feilding the youngest side in the competition while going for the proper rebuild. Dees will win one first. I'm so confident im even bookmarking this shit.

BTW West Coast have an older list and are absolutely getting smacked from pillar to post. How do people still rate them??

 

[jman_cool]

How can you say West Coast have the best list??

Port have a much better list.

It will defiently be Port or West Coast next to get the glory.

I can honestly not see Port being down for much longer. They have just underperformed and lost about 7 by under 10pts this season. They could be 10-5 easily.

Port are coached by one of the biggest duds in the AFL.

 

[BLUE BLEEDING]

west coast
port
melbourne
freo

west coast are a strong club and will bounce back, and have good youngsters. should trade kerr, then future will be much brighter with picks they would be recieving.

port are well coached and are also strong.

melbourne ahead of fremantle because melbourne are a younger side.

fremantle have to get rid of alot of older players but the young players they pick up need to be quality, which will be a hard task, especially with the new teams getting good picks in the next few years.
also would get a benefit if they trade pavlich, will be better for their premiership hopes.

 

[SAINTS 4 07 FLAG]

whoever gets Naita

 

[BLUE BLEEDING]

whoever gets Naita

spare me.
i saw him perform live and he was very average.

he could be a star or be a complete dud. he might be a bit risky for a top pick (others have also agreed.) he needs to do more than just tap the ball down in the ruck.

i would take rich and watts before him.

i hope you do your own research and do not just read about him, see the radical looks and believe he will be awsome.

 

[SAINTS 4 07 FLAG]

spare me.
i saw him perform live and he was very average.

he could be a star or be a complete dud. he might be a bit risky for a top pick (others have also agreed.) he needs to do more than just tap the ball down in the ruck.

i would take rich and watts before him.

i hope you do your own research and do not just read about him, see the radical looks and believe he will be awsome.

Mate I saw him at the Champs on tele and at Subi. His off the ball work is poor but i think if an AFL club pick him up he will thrive under current stars who will teach him what AFL footy is all about. I couldnt decide which out of those dud teams would win..so i just went with the big mother

 

[davey_magik]

Bias says Melbourne, but I always find it hard to rate interstate sides as I see less of them.

I think Freo have a better future than West Coast.

 

[jacko_boy]

none will win a flag for years but west coast have a better side than port, freo and dees.

west coast didnt win the flag with just cuz and judd shorly the veteran eagles can stand up they still have some great players in cox - best ruckman in comp. kerr - hasn't copped with tagging. embley - norm smith medilist in 06.

 

[Young Gun #6]

Port have players like that as well though.

Port- C.Cornes, K.Cornes, P.Burgoyne, S.Burgoyne, Brogan/Lade, S.Salopek.

All great players.

 

[Puddy]

out of those 4 teams Port Adelaide has the strongest list, my prediction would be that we bounce back next year and we will make the finals

West Coast has gone down and will stay down for a very long time

Fremantle will clean their list out and start over, will be like West Coast but will succeed eventually

Melbourne will come 10-12th next year, then go for finals in 2010, Miller will star for them.

 

[Young Gun #6]

Also why aren't Essendon in the poll??

They have a very poor list and are near the bottom.

 

[Hodgepodge]

i went with west coke, they're the most successful of the AFL sides.

 

[Young Gun #6]

That means nothing. They were successful when they had good sides. It won't be 5+ years until they have a good side.

 

[thewigginaut]

fremantle will never win a flag

 

[phurry]

The new Gold Coast side will win a Premiership first!

 

[quotemokc]

Fremantle will NEVER EVER FOREVER NEVER win a premiership!

 

[whelan=legend]

Frawley (19) Martin (21) Bartram (20)
C Johnson (22) Garland (20) Petterd (20)
Buckley (21) Dunn (21) Morton (18)
Wonnaeamirri (19) Bate (21) Grimes (19)
Sylvia (22) Juice (21) Maric(18)
Meesen (22) Jones (20) McLean (22)

Melbourne's 22 and under squad. We will win the premiership first