who would you like as a pie?

[diehard pie]

pretty simple. Pick a player from any other club you would most like at Pie land. Someone who would really fit in. Why?

For me it has to be a Wells or a Judd. We need that pace in the midfield

 

[Stakerz]

Rupey Betheras!

 

[Coin_Toss]

Rupey Betheras!

Yeah, I would love him back at the club..

But seriously, everyone wants Judd. If Judd wanted to come home, Collingwood wouldn't be the only team interested.

 

[MarkT]

Judd without any hesitation. We need a strong, quick, skilled midfielder with some heart. He's it.

 

[the_mighty_pies_3733]

The most underated player in the AFL, Chad Fletcher.

 

[iampig]

C.Judd, A.Cooney, L.Ball, J.Kelly or D.Wells..cant go wrong with these 5

 

[guess_who]

To be honest I would rather a quality forward like Fev, who has a bad or below average game and still kicks 2-3 goals rather than a forward that is inconsistent infront of goals kicking 5 straight one week and 1.4 the next. FEV for me.

 

[Lonie_from_50]

Darren Milburn and Chad Fletcher

 

[VEEBEE]

andrew embley=gun

 

[kleos]

Jesus playing chf.
Imagine the scores we could kick, and he could even help the midfiield out with his pace.

 

[hotpie]

No way, the umpires would crucify him. I'd rather have Pontius Pilate in the side in a tagging role.

 

[iampig]

Tarrant & Fevola are equal in value.Both rely on leading & pace but struggle winning enough contested marks to be "power" forwards.Neither is good enough to be the 1 target up forward.They are both poor mans versions of M.Lloyd.

Rocca on the other hand is good at contested situations but lacks the stamina to get to enough contests to be "power" forward.

The only forwards worth getting are J.Brown,W.Treadrea & N.Riewolt.These 3 are the best 3 forwards in the AFL by a fair margin because team plans can be formulated around them.They can win contested marks or bring the ball to ground.They also have the speed & nouse to sting as leading forwards.

 

[jimmy35]

Judd,Cooney and Ball would fill out our midfield nicely.