Who Would You Rather?

[Dave The Man]

Big Players Out of Contract:
Pavlich
Judd
Del Santo
Reiwlodt

Who Would you want wearing Black and White?

 

[Stakerz]

In order:

Judd
Riewoldt
Dal Santo
Pavlich

Judd is just obvious.

Hard to split Riewoldt and Santo.

Pavlich is just as good as Riewoldt so yes hmm ... runs.

 

[Collingwoodrow]

Judd
Riewoldt
Pavlich
Dal Santo................we already have Pendles!

 

[Dave The Man]

Mine Will Be:

Reiwoldt - Pavlich TIE
Judd
Del Santo

 

[doppleganger]

Judd
Riewoldt
Pav
Dal

 

[nossi5]

Judd
Pavlich
Reiwoldt
Dal Santo

 

[pies4eva]

Judd
Pavlich (i think he is a lot better than Riewoldt)
Dal (greater need for midfielders)
Riewoldt

 

[rand corp]

you'd take any one of them you could land but Judd is the best player going around at the moment by some way and we desperately need a champion mid IMHO.

Any one of the others but, we should've got Pav in that draft in the first place and only a typical AFL rort cost us.

 

[Vinnie Vegas]

Judd
Pavlich
Dal Santo
Riewoldt

If I had to order them, that would be how, but you'd have to see the deal before you say that you'd trade for somebody.

 

[Jimbeam]

Judd
Pavlich
Reiwoldt
Dal Santo

 

[DWil6]

Judd
Pavlich
Reiwoldt
Dal Santo

Agreed.

 

[Cyclops]

Do all 4 guys have injury clouds on them?

Judd's shoulders have held out magnificently for years now but he has a long term problem there: I am glad of every good game I see of his because I have an imminent sense of doom approaching for him.

Riewoldt seems positively injury prone.

Dal Santo is perhaps the fittest, I'm unsure how he's travelling now but he's had worries in the past.

Pavlich has had some shoulder problems from memory although her still finds ways to contribute.

Price aside, even an injured Judd is the most attractive, from Pav, Roo and Dal in that order.

Given that glamour and emotiion cloud a players value, we'd never get a fair trade for Judd, or to a lesser extent Roo. Dal and Pav (given Freo's history of brain-dead trading) might be do-able without breaking the bank.

Figuring realworld factors like injury and trade cost, I'd say we target Pavlich, then Dal Santo, then Judd, then Riewoldt.

 

[Jabso]

Big Players Out of Contract:
Pavlich
Judd
Del Santo
Reiwlodt

Who Would you want wearing Black and White?

In order:

Judd
Pavlich
Riewoldt
Dal Santo

In terms of needs Dal Santo would be #2 to Judd, but Pavlich and Riewoldt are much more influential players.

 

[APieceOfPie]

In Order:

Judd
Pavlich
Dal Santo
Riewoldt?

Riewoldt always goes missing in big games especially when ainter's are behind.

 

[PiesUnited]

In Order:

Judd
Pavlich
Dal Santo
Riewoldt?

Riewoldt always goes missing in big games especially when ainter's are behind.

Agree with you. Spot on......

 

[MarkT]

With our list:
Judd
Pavlich
Reiwlodt
Del Santo

If we had a much better midfield swap Judd & Pavlich and maybe Reiwoldt 2nd.

We’d still need a ruckman.

 

[daics cousin]

Just give us pavlich and judd,forget the rest.Riewoldt gets too many injuries and Dal Santo is not as good as everyone thinks.He is an outside middie,and can't get the hard ball.We have plenty of thosde types at the pies.
The pav in the forward line,with rocca,travis his mate medhurst and didak,rotate reid and chris Dawes when his ready ,man awesome,who's gonna stop uis then.Oh sorry and juddy in the midfield taking over from bucks and the new magpies dynasty begins......4 premierships in a row.
Now back to reality,judd will stay at west coast,the Pav may stay at freo or if he moves either adelaide or port will secure his services.
If reiwoldt moves he'll play for the goldcoast kangas in queensland,dal santo if he moved would be the most likely to come to collingwood,but we have a better younger dal santo------Pendles.DalSanto too much a reciever give me luke ball anyday or even armitage,he'll be good one day.

 

[WakeUpPies]

eddie could bribe them all

oh plz eddie bribe them

 

[Pie Fight]

What about Marc Murphy. Future star, 19yrs old. Seems a logical choice. Thomas, Pendles and Murphy for the next 10-12 yrs. Its more tempting than a Lara Bingle, Jenifer Hawkins sandwich.