Who Would You Rather?

[crow87]

Hey there Bomber Fans, very sorry to hear about the two injuries to two really good players of yours, hope you dont mind me posting on here but this sounded like a good thread.

Aaron Davey V Alwyn Davey Sorry, but true
J.Brown V Pavlich Would love either in the crows!
Dal Santo V Heath Shaw Tough one but DS gets the nod
Goodwin V A.Simpson Honestly and without bias
Richardson V Lloyd Less dummy spits, more goals and more free kicks!
Cox V Sandilands Best Ruckman in the league easily
Brad Johnson V Jarrad Waite No contest, but in the long run Waite because he's younger (obviously)
C.Bruce V S.Burgoyne Dont want the soft option
M.Murphy V B.Deledio Pfft, Deludio, dont make me laugh. Murphy is a champ
Rutten vs. Glass See Goodwin vs Simpson
Foley vs. Montagna I dont really know about middle of the road vic players
Kennely vs. Heath Shaw Depends what you need in your team, I probably favour Kenelly but Shaw give you good run
Lucas vs. Buddy Sorry, pure explosive pace, great mark and good kick, magic. Lucas is good too though
Hudson vs. Hille Doing very well for first season back from major surgery, Huddo by a long way for mine
Ebert vs. Milne Hmm, two seagulls but Ebert is more solid and easily better
Riewoldt vs. Pavlich Again, wouldnt mind either but Pav is ahead for me
Fletcher vs. Rutten Name any KP defender and I'd take Rutten ahead of him...
Fletcher vs. Glass ...With him second
Kepler vs. Rowan Jones Just more class, sorry but I'm not conviced by Kepler
Bolton vs. Tivendale Under-rated player

Thanks guys, did not mean to tread on any toes with essendon players, just my honest opinions.

 

[hewer]

Judd V Bartel
Aaron Davey V Alwyn Davey
J.Brown V Pavlich
Dal Santo V Heath Shaw
Goodwin V A.Simpson
Richardson V Lloyd
Cox V Sandilands
Brad Johnson V Jarrad Waite
C.Bruce V S.Burgoyne
M.Murphy V B.Deledio
Rutten vs. Glass
Foleyvs. Montagna
Kennely vs. Heath Shaw
Lucasvs. Buddy
Hudson vs. Hille
Ebert vs. Milne
Riewoldt vs. Pavlich
Fletcher vs. Rutten
Fletcher vs. Glass
Kepler vs. Rowan Jones
Bolton vs. Tivendale

 

[bring it on]

Rutten vs. Glass
Foleyvs. Montagna
Kennely vs. Heath Shaw
Lucasvs. Buddy
Hudson vs. Hille
Ebert vs. Milne
Riewoldt vs. Pavlich
Fletcher vs. Rutten
Fletcher vs. Glass
Kepler vs. Rowan Jones
Bolton vs. Tivendale


added the others

 

[RED AND BLACK SOLDIER]

Why would u want Waite over Johnson? Johnson is a gun!

Your right, BJ is a gun, but Johnson is 30-31 and waite is considerably younger at 24 and still developing and by the time Waite has finished he will probably be in his prime and just as good as B.J. Waite is tall, agile and quick for his size and IMO will be difficult to matchup in the future, and he is more versatile being able to play back, forward and even midfield which would make him a more important player because of his versatility. If Essendon could get Waite or BJ im pretty sure i know which player Essendon and their supporters would be wanting.

 

[Slattery_20]

Here's one I've been pondering recently

Jobe vs West
Jobe vs Goodwin
Jobe vs Luke Ball

Based on current form

 

[Darealrath]

Here's one I've been pondering recently

Jobe vs West
Jobe vs Goodwin
Jobe vs Luke Ball

Based on current form

West (not by all that much though)
Goodwin (comfortably)
Jobe (comfortably)

 

[King Patty]

Judd Easily
Aaron Davey - cause alwyn has broken arm - otherwise flip of coin.
J.Brown becuase i have picked Lloyd full forward - brown better CHF than Pavlich.
Heath Shaw - casue rebounding defender - dal gets tagged out of games as well and have plenty of other mids.
Goodwin
Lloyd easy best full forward
Cox - easy best ruckman in the game - sandilands is tall, but disposal lacks accuracy/efficiency
Brad Johnson Will fit in forward line well with Brown and Lloyd
C.Bruce has been better on form this year.
M.Murphy because Judd fills deledios - pacy midfielder role in team, and Murphy would be a star with Judd Judd/Bruce taking the taggers..

 

[mathew ollaik]

Just a bit of fun.....

Heres 10 matchups, tell me who you would have in your team.

Judd V Bartel
Aaron Davey V Alwyn Davey
J.Brown V Pavlich
Dal Santo V Heath Shaw
Goodwin V A.Simpson
Richardson V Lloyd
Cox V Sandilands
Brad Johnson V Jarrad Waite
C.Bruce V S.Burgoyne
M.Murphy V B.Deledio

Think this is just about right

 

[Aussie Assault]

Judd V Bartel
Aaron Davey V Alwyn Davey
J.Brown V Pavlich
Dal Santo V Heath Shaw
Goodwin V A.Simpson
Richardson V Lloyd
Cox V Sandilands
Brad Johnson V Jarrad Waite
C.Bruce V S.Burgoyne
M.Murphy V B.Deledio
Rutten vs. Glass
Foley vs. Montagna
Kennely vs. Heath Shaw
Lucas vs. Buddy
Hudson vs. Hille
Ebert vs. Milne
Riewoldt vs. Pavlich
Fletcher vs. Rutten
Fletchervs. Glass
Kepler vs. Rowan Jones
Bolton vs. Tivendale

 

[DonMania#5]

Rutten vs. Glass
Foley vs. Montagna
Kennely vs. Heath Shaw
Lucas vs. Buddy
Hudson vs. Hille
Ebert vs. Milne
Riewoldt vs. Pavlich
Fletcher vs. Rutten
Fletcher vs. Glass
Kepler vs. Rowan Jones
Bolton vs. Tivendale