Opinion Brian Cook - Carlton's rebuild still has a fair way to go
- Thread starter Power Play
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Anyway, anyone for footy debates?
Great comeback, did the coach rubber stamp that one?
You said Collingwood DON'T have a 1st round draft pick.
If you still think you are right, I have a question for you.
What round pick was Nick Daicos?
A bunch of later picks, making up the value needed
Could of got him in the 2nd round if no one bid on him.
He was bid on, could have, would have does not work now.
I'll ask again.
What round pick was Nick Daicos.
Pick 4 mate, a pick Collingwood never had.
No avatar. I made the bet. You’ve seen the terms. More wins or percentage and I spend the summer talking cricket. That’s it
Never had, we damn well do have now though.
You said we DON"T have one, well guess what? pick 4 is one and we have pick 4.
Just ignoring him Rob, he knows he is wrong.
They never had a first round pick, they made up the value with multiple picks starting in the 2nd round, everyone knows that
Avatar only, I will accept the terms I want
Missed that word either, that wasn't complicated though
Calls people out but dodges when called out. It’s why I jumped in. I’m not a fan of bullies or smart mouth people
Got it. The cut of your jib has been noted
Where have I dodged, I took up your bet, less than 8 wins
Bullies or smart mouths, like people being adamant about a prediction then backtracking
Same
OK mate you clearly don't know what I'm talking about, learn a bit about the bidding system and how Collingwood were able to draft Daicos with pick 4. I won't talk to you anymore on that issue.
Yeah, obviously we are miles off from Carlton's 8 consecutive seasons of 8 wins or less.
That is what happens when you try rebuilding without a strong stable senior coach, and don't value strong senior leadership amongst the playing list.
This Carlton list just finished the season 1-4 including losses to North and Gold Coast. Still a bog standard list that relies too heavily on too few.
Exactly what happens when you recruit a bunch of flankers, and have plenty of first round picks not come on.
'Either' whilst being superfluous to the statement, ensured there was no doubt as to the proposed terms of the bet
To paraphrase, If Carlton have less than 8 wins OR a worse percentage than 2021, you make yourself scarce for the summer.
If Carlton have 8 or more wins AND a better percentage than 2021 (i.e. 'You do both'), he disappears for the summer.
Hope that makes sense. I can't make it any simpler.
Last edited:
Run and hide now mate.
You said DON'T have one, it doesn't matter how we got the pick, Collingwood DO have one.
If you had of said before the draft, you would have been right, but you didn't, you saw your mistake and tried to change what you said.
Then when you knew you made a fool of yourself, you reverted to insults.
It makes no difference how Collingwood got Daicos, he went at pick 4, meaning, Collingwood HAVE pick 4, which is, wait for it, a 1st round pick.
I said Collingwood never got a first round pick for finishing 2nd last, prove me wrong mate.
This is the post that you started with, I asked if you meant Collingwood.
Similar threads
