Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: St Kilda v Western Bulldogs - 7:30PM Thu
Squiggle tips Saints at 51% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
The deal also included Plowman and Phillips, who will be long term players AND pick 8 coming back Carlton's way.The deal also involved Geelong's first round pick this year, and a salary dump of Lamb (who we got off Sydney by offering him "more than he was worth" to get him to play for us).
So many collingwood fans getting emotional about some apparently dud player thats under contract for another year. Just because some clubs shop long serving players under contract around doesnt mean everybody does.
Not sure why people are thinking he's worth a first rounder. Why wouldn't clubs back themselves in the first round of the draft instead of getting WHE? He comes with as many question marks as a draftee considering his minimal AFL output and his injuries.
If the rumours are true and he wants to come to us, we don't have a first rounder to trade anyway and probably won't get one for the players that we are likely to have on the trade table (Williams, Cloke, Witts, Broomhead).
I imagine if it's with us we would offer whatever we get for Witts if it's not Witts himself should the Giants be interested in a young ruck (others are).
GWS trade: WHE, marchbank, tomiilson and pick 32 to Carlton
Carlton trade: pick 5 and 23 to GWS
That would be a disaster for Carlton
What about
GWS - Steele, WHE, Tomlinson
Blues - Pick 5 and 3rd rounder
That would be a disaster for Carlton
What about
GWS - Steele, WHE, Tomlinson
Blues - Pick 5 and 3rd rounder
Worth a late teens pick. Taken at 4 he has shown some glimpses of being a star and that will see clubs pay. I would happily give up a pic in the late teens to secure him.
This is just pathetic drivel. He is absolutely not worth a first rnd pick. He was pick 4. He has played like a pick 54. He has not by any means shown star quality. JOM showed star quality. Jacob hopper showed star quality. Christian petracca showed star quality. Bontempelli showed and proved star quality.Worth a late teens pick. Taken at 4 he has shown some glimpses of being a star and that will see clubs pay. I would happily give up a pic in the late teens to secure him.
How do you know a dog would be happy with that, they could also be annoyed that they clang together to much too..He's a great athlete, but a s**t footballer. If someone offers the giants a second rounder they will be as happy as a dog with two dicks.
GWS trade: WHE, marchbank, tomiilson and pick 32 to Carlton
Carlton trade: pick 5 and 23 to GWS
Looks like you should have traded Tommo when he was worth something.Didnt the blues offer something like pick 11 for Tommo alone last year? 2 of those guys are under contract for next year.
Looks like you should have traded Tommo when he was worth something.
Giants fans are hilarious.. If WHE was at the pies they'd be saying 4th rounder at best
Nope I wouldn'tAnd you would be saying top ten pick. SHOCK HORROR
Nope I wouldn't
Haha I'm not like you, I don't see the point in it.Yeah I'm sure. Any how....
Ahh yes, if the Giants don't get what they want they wont trade him. Rather simple, and they will have another year to show him off and develop him.
This is just pathetic drivel. He is absolutely not worth a first rnd pick. He was pick 4. He has played like a pick 54. He has not by any means shown star quality. JOM showed star quality. Jacob hopper showed star quality. Christian petracca showed star quality. Bontempelli showed and proved star quality.
Couldnt give a s**t where he wants to go whether its ruddy freo or nt crocodiles. Stop playing this dumb childish game pumping up everyones tires.
He has shown great athletic ability. He can leap and sprint and take a good mark. Thats about it. You judge a player on what theyve shown not what pick they were 4 yrs ago and 'potential'. I can find a bloke in the VAFA who can run fast jump and take a nice grab
I guess youre just taking the tried and true richmond approach - overpaying for a spud becuase 'he once showed a bit 3 years ago and was pick 4 in a compromised draft 5 years ago'
Some pies posters would though, like they're wanting a top 10 pick for Jarred F. WittsNope I wouldn't
No we wouldn't. Just like we know that Broomhead is worth nix at the moment despite his obvious talent.And you would be saying top ten pick. SHOCK HORROR