Will Scarlett get suspended?

[dodgyhodgy]

Hi guys, just wanted to hear your guys opinion on what will happen to scarlett? Do you think he will get off or will he get 1-2 weeks.
Not meaning to bag your players but from memory Didak has been caught acting before, and hopefully for scarlo he was putting all of it on.

 

[grayza]

IMO i reckon he will get off....but you never know with the tribunal

 

[The Scarecrow]

Right now the Tribunal is a lucky dip, or Unlucky dip (depending on the team) anything is posible with them. I really didn't see what happened, so I really don't know.

 

[shuveradda]

He Should Get off..

 

[grayza]

well you just dont know with the tribunal, it looked like there was force with the knee, but you dont know if didak was playing up or not, although he did stay done for a while

at the tribunal do they make players lift their shirt etc to expose bruises or cuts that may have been sustained during play

surely there would be a nice bruise on dids' back at the mo if he got kneed hard

just an opinion shuverada, its like an ass-hole everyones got one

 

[kristin5]

From memory, so far all players this year charged with infringing against a Pies player have gotten off, so I expect this one to be no different.

 

[lufc&gfc]

Originally posted by kristin5
From memory, so far all players this year charged with infringing against a Pies player have gotten off, so I expect this one to be no different.

Are you implying that the tribunal favours players that get reported after an altercation with a Collingwood player?????
Lets hope for your reputation that you aren't.

 

[shuveradda]

Originally posted by grayza
well you just dont know with the tribunal, it looked like there was force with the knee, but you dont know if didak was playing up or not, although he did stay done for a while

at the tribunal do they make players lift their shirt etc to expose bruises or cuts that may have been sustained during play

surely there would be a nice bruise on dids' back at the mo if he got kneed hard

just an opinion shuverada, its like an ass-hole everyones got one

I respect that Opinion..

 

[kristin5]

Originally posted by lufc&gfc
Are you implying that the tribunal favours players that get reported after an altercation with a Collingwood player?????
Lets hope for your reputation that you aren't.

Aren't we on our high horse?

Anyway, no I'm merely stating it as a strange but true coincidence.

And if you don't like what you read here, get off our board.

 

[guess_who]

Should he be suspended-YES
Will he be suspended-NO

 

[Lonie_from_50]

The dirty dog will get off, but shouldn't.

Only because the tribunal will keep up their same old consistancy.

 

[lufc&gfc]

Originally posted by kristin5
Aren't we on our high horse?

Anyway, no I'm merely stating it as a strange but true coincidence.

And if you don't like what you read here, get off our board.

I enjoy reading the comedy which is the Collingwood supporters bemoaning how hard they have, everything is always stacked against them when in reality it's the complete opposite.

 

[guess_who]

Originally posted by lufc&gfc
I enjoy reading the comedy which is the Collingwood supporters bemoaning how hard they have, everything is always stacked against them when in reality it's the complete opposite.

Hey, nobjokey how about you go and eat some shi*

 

[lufc&gfc]

Originally posted by guess_who
Hey, nobjokey how about you go and eat some shi*

Now, there we go, spoken like a typical Collingwood supporter. Is that the most intelligent response you can come up with?????

 

[Lonie_from_50]

Originally posted by lufc&gfc
I enjoy reading the comedy which is the Collingwood supporters bemoaning how hard they have, everything is always stacked against them when in reality it's the complete opposite.

Look on the history side of this. Yes.. Collingwood supporters are known as the toothless and the feral, but most of we know our god damn football, we are god damn loyal and most of all we actually fill a stadium whatever the game, time, position or Weather.

And another History pointer for you is...


Collingwood v Geelong
Won: 121
Lost: 87
Drawn: 1

Premierships: 14 v 6
Last GF Appearance: 2003 v 1995
Brownlow Medallists: 8 v 4


That is just a couple of stats for you.

 

[guess_who]

Originally posted by lufc&gfc
Now, there we go, spoken like a typical Collingwood supporter. Is that the most intelligent response you can come up with?????

Yes, I may be your typicall pies supporter but im ****ed off, now don't even give me that **** ok.
Besides I'm sure that I am far smarter then you!

 

[Cyclops]

Will Scarlet? Isn't he Robin Hood's mate?

 

[funktrain]

Originally posted by guess_who
Yes, I may be your typicall pies supporter but im ****ed off, now don't even give me that **** ok.
Besides I'm sure that I am far smarter then you!

So to quote you--> "I may be your typicall pies supporter".... lets just ponder that for a minute shall we, and concider some of the indicators that make a collingwood supporter!
-Typically working class sc*mbag heritage, with an uncle or a cousin involved in the organisation of a union right up to his concrete boots.
-Never known for any great literary achievements. Centrelink forms aside.
-Dental issues.
-Having an inane ability to say they know someone important. And of course their 'someone important" is usually another Collingwood supporter! Figure that out?

.....and the list just goes on and on. Feel free to add to the list people

 

[guess_who]

Originally posted by funktrain
So to quote you--> "I may be your typicall pies supporter".... lets just ponder that for a minute shall we, and concider some of the indicators that make a collingwood supporter!
-Typically working class sc*mbag heritage, with an uncle or a cousin involved in the organisation of a union right up to his concrete boots.
-Never known for any great literary achievements. Centrelink forms aside.
-Dental issues.
-Having an inane ability to say they know someone important. And of course their 'someone important" is usually another Collingwood supporter! Figure that out?

.....and the list just goes on and on. Feel free to add to the list people

There is one thing that unites the collingwood faithfull more then any one else, and that is passion for the Pies.

As a matter of interest what do you do? what is your job?

 

[Lonie_from_50]

Originally posted by guess_who
Besides I'm sure that I am far smarter then you!

**** MAN, your going to have to face the music now, for some reason you tell me that I have a big head.

Gee,

 

[guess_who]

Originally posted by Lonie_from_50
**** MAN, your going to have to face the music now, for some reason you tell me that I have a big head.

Gee,

"Two things are infinite: the universe and human stupidity; and I'm not sure about the the universe."

 

[Lonie_from_50]

guess_who, Your point with that quote????

It has nothing to do with what I said mate.

 

[kristin5]

Please stay on the topic rather than making personal attacks.

 

[Hulk_Hawkins]

Originally posted by Lonie_from_50
And another History pointer for you is...


Collingwood v Geelong
Won: 121
Lost: 87
Drawn: 1

Premierships: 14 v 6
Last GF Appearance: 2003 v 1995
Brownlow Medallists: 8 v 4


That is just a couple of stats for you.

History speaks louder than words doesn't it? But- I know these are only cliches but here goes
You are only as good as your last game
A week is a long time in Football