Traded Will Setterfield [traded to Carlton with #71 for #43 & future 2nd round pick]

[Ambrosia]

Heard Blues have offered 500k per year? I reckon that's wrong.

500k is fine. Pay a premium to lure blokes to your club especially as the bottom side .

 

[parmy2balmey]

I'd be a lot more concerned about the criticism if it came from someone who was functionally literate.

woooooooooo pants man

 

[branedotorg]

Big Carlton Essendon arm wrestle over Shiel and setterfield

Which way will it fall? 1 each?

I am blowing my own horn

 

[Crow till I die]

Well it becomes a very simple trade now that Shiel has picked Essendon.

Carlton 2019 1st + S McAdam (Steak Knives) to Adelaide
Adelaide M McGovern + Pick 19 to Carlton
Carlton Pick 19 + pick 42 to GWS for Setterfield

Happy days all round

 

[KnaveyBlue]

Well it becomes a very simple trade now that Shiel has picked Essendon.

Carlton 2019 1st + S McAdam (Steak Knives) to Adelaide
Adelaide M McGovern + Pick 19 to Carlton
Carlton Pick 19 + pick 42 to GWS for Setterfield

Happy days all round

Seems legit. Let me know when the deal is set to be lodged. I'm gonna make a killing selling torches and pitchforks along Royal Parade.

 

[Isaac Cumming No 1]

Seems legit. Let me know when the deal is set to be lodged. I'm gonna make a killing selling torches and pitchforks along Royal Parade.

I saw it and thought no need for us to complain.

 

[gillo94]

Well it becomes a very simple trade now that Shiel has picked Essendon.

Carlton 2019 1st + S McAdam (Steak Knives) to Adelaide
Adelaide M McGovern + Pick 19 to Carlton
Carlton Pick 19 + pick 42 to GWS for Setterfield

Happy days all round

How does this trade work?

Explain what all 3 clubs get

 

[Crow till I die]

How does this trade work?

Explain what all 3 clubs get

It is redundant now as the deal apparently will be announced tomorrow. It goes something like this:
Crows get 2 x 2nd rounders + McAdam + Carlton's 2019 5th rounder
Carlton get McGovern and Crows 2019 3rd rounder
Talk is that the 2 x 2nd rounders will be traded to Sydney for their 1st rounder (pick 13) - but that appears to be speculation rather than a lock

 

[gillo94]

It is redundant now as the deal apparently will be announced tomorrow. It goes something like this:
Crows get 2 x 2nd rounders + McAdam + Carlton's 2019 5th rounder
Carlton get McGovern and Crows 2019 3rd rounder
Talk is that the 2 x 2nd rounders will be traded to Sydney for their 1st rounder (pick 13) - but that appears to be speculation rather than a lock

Link?

What about Will Setterfield and GWS as you mention 2019 First Round pick

 

[Crow till I die]

Link?

What about Will Setterfield and GWS as you mention 2019 First Round pick

Barrass70 from your own board is stating done deal and have a chat with Arr0w from your board too. Not sure what the Setterfield deal will be - maybe your 2019 2nd and our 2019 3rd?

 

[XhazzafootyX]

Go sign them up then,you need all the players you can get!

You just stick to getting rejects from other clubs and we will stick to hitting the draft

 

[gandaal]

You just stick to getting rejects from other clubs and we will stick to hitting the draft

Since you feel that way maybe can send us some of the following:
Dan Hannebury
Jack Steele
Jake Carlisle
Josh Bruce
Tim Membrey
Shane Savage
Maverick Weller
Billy Longer

 

[XhazzafootyX]

Since you feel that way maybe can send us some of the following:
Dan Hannebury
Jack Steele
Jack Carlile
Josh Bruce
Tim Membrey
Shane Savage
Maverick Weller
Billy Longer

Ill give you maverick weller, shane savage and tim membery.

 

[gandaal]

Ill give you maverick weller, shane savage and tim membery.

Why would you do that if you don't pick up reject hacks from other clubs?

They must be stars, every one of them

 

[DrZeit]

Future 2nd + Future 4th for Setters and Finlayson.

GWS may get skittish with Hawthorn and Port apparently sniffing around our 2019 1st.

 

[fridgeman]

Just seeing what is holding up this trade?
Do Carlton have any other moves under way or is it this and then the draft for them?
With the McGovern deal done with Carltons 2018 2nd rounders they only have #43 + 69 and then 2019 picks but maybe they are waiting for the Crows to make a massive offer?
FWIW I would accept either 2019 2nd + 3rd rounder for Setterfield or maybe just pick swaps next year in the 2nd + 3rd rounders

 

[Isaac Cumming No 1]

Future 2nd + Future 4th for Setters and Finlayson.

GWS may get skittish with Hawthorn and Port apparently sniffing around our 2019 1st.

We wont want future picks.

We will have 6-7 list positions to fill, ideally from the draft, this year.

 

[Orange Agent]

Just seeing what is holding up this trade?
Do Carlton have any other moves under way or is it this and then the draft for them?
With the McGovern deal done with Carltons 2018 2nd rounders they only have #43 + 69 and then 2019 picks but maybe they are waiting for the Crows to make a massive offer?
FWIW I would accept either 2019 2nd + 3rd rounder for Setterfield or maybe just pick swaps next year in the 2nd + 3rd rounders

Carlton are the problem. Throw massive $$$ at a kid and have nothing to get the trade done. Hope we hold him.

 

[fridgeman]

Carlton are the problem. Throw massive $$$ at a kid and have nothing to get the trade done. Hope we hold him.

We wont want future picks.

We will have 6-7 list positions to fill, ideally from the draft, this year.

I am ok with future picks for Setterfield if it is the best deal for the club, I think the price for trying to trade up to #4 or #5 will be too high and the club will be better off taking two first round picks and 1 or 2 second rounders depending on who the club has identified and the academy players
i actually think the Crows could make a monster offer for pick 1 but it may happen after the player trade period closes as I think Setterfield isn't the priority for the blues

 

[Isaac Cumming No 1]

I am ok with future picks for Setterfield if it is the best deal for the club, I think the price for trying to trade up to #4 or #5 will be too high and the club will be better off taking two first round picks and 1 or 2 second rounders depending on who the club has identified and the academy players
i actually think the Crows could make a monster offer for pick 1 but it may happen after the player trade period closes as I think Setterfield isn't the priority for the blues

Fair enough as a view, mine is the club wont be. I dont think we'll get much for Setterfield, but Adrian Caruso was up to the challenge if finding a best 22 player with pick 56 last year.

 

[Kreuuuzeurns]

Carlton are the problem. Throw massive $$$ at a kid and have nothing to get the trade done. Hope we hold him.

We will have the currency to get him. Talk we are willing to deal our future first and even field offers for pick 1.

Setterfield will get done.

 

[DrZeit]

We wont want future picks.

We will have 6-7 list positions to fill, ideally from the draft, this year.

You're about to be flush with draft picks, you probably won't need our picks to help out filling those spots.

Carlton are the problem. Throw massive $$$ at a kid and have nothing to get the trade done. Hope we hold him.

Didn't GWS tell this kid to explore his options?

 

[Isaac Cumming No 1]

You're about to be flush with draft picks, you probably won't need our picks to help out filling those spots

Mmmm
Maybe, but we will have to draft at least 6 players this year I think. I'm pretty sure you're going to get a bargain with Setterfield, as long as his body is ok, be happy.

 

[curnwow30]

Surely GWS Cap issues are now resolved? Or can we expect a salary dump again to Carlton as has been the case in previous years?

 

[philthy05]

I can see why blues might want to sell your 2019 1st, to get multiple picks and deal one for settlefield but I can’t understand how hawks can give enough for it.