Troy SelwoodNice where did you read that? Everything i can find just says he's a half back
No current season stats available
He looks the most AFL ready of this draft class... I think he will be a pretty good player.
This is it, the club have actually seen what Nick brings, who is arrogant enough to think they know better?
Menz was always SJ mark 2Menzel was mackie mark 2. So he must be menzel mark 2 or mackie mark 3.
Off to detention for you, boy....GGS boy?
Can't make it sadly.![]()
Menzel and mackie are virtually twins in both looks, shape and game style. Mackie also started off as sj type foward as well Many forget. But unlike sj both menzel and mackie were faster, had bigger kicks and could take an overhead grab.Menz was always SJ mark 2
We see things differently. When I first saw Menzel, 2 of us immediately said- SJ. The kicking action, the goal sense, the swagger, the confidence.Menzel and mackie are virtually twins in both looks, shape and game style. Mackie also started off as sj type foward as well Many forget. But unlike sj both menzel and mackie were faster, had bigger kicks and could take an overhead grab.
Another impressive character.
SDK fills one of those posts. Perhaps Krueger gets a gig there too (maybe they will even try Sav back there). Neale could also be a type as he is the same height etc as SDK. Plenty of talls to try and we always end up finding someone be it our own forwards or from other teams.Blitz and hendo are taller at the KP end and I advocate getting a KPD but we're deep enough for sub 195cm defenders I feel.
I am actually on board with Neale going back there. But I also think that by the time SDK is ready to be the number 1 on gorillas we're down 2 positions not 1SDK fills one of those posts. Perhaps Krueger gets a gig there too (maybe they will even try Sav back there). Neale could also be a type as he is the same height etc as SDK. Plenty of talls to try and we always end up finding someone be it our own forwards or from other teams.
Sdk probably needs to be ready in 12 months as i expect hendo to retire then.I am actually on board with Neale going back there. But I also think that by the time SDK is ready to be the number 1 on gorillas we're down 2 positions not 1
Depends more on nous for SDK now more than anything. It took Scarlett a couple of years (I remember him getting monstered by the likes of Lloyd early on).I am actually on board with Neale going back there. But I also think that by the time SDK is ready to be the number 1 on gorillas we're down 2 positions not 1
I think post Selwood/Dangerfield we will have to go through a period of having a new team take time to emerge. We will probably be less likely to take as many fa’s, more likely in the initial years to build through the draft again. We’ll have to all be patient.Sdk probably needs to be ready in 12 months as i expect hendo to retire then.
We need Neale to be ready for when Stanley retires which he hopefully plays for another couple of years.
Patience is viceI think post Selwood/Dangerfield we will have to go through a period of having a new team take time to emerge. We will probably be less likely to take as many fa’s, more likely in the initial years to build through the draft again. We’ll have to all be patient.
That will go well around here, you would think. After all, it's hardly the characteristic that first springs to mind when you think of our board.I think post Selwood/Dangerfield we will have to go through a period of having a new team take time to emerge. We will probably be less likely to take as many fa’s, more likely in the initial years to build through the draft again. We’ll have to all be patient.
At this point in the draft I don't think people are too fussed who we pickThis is it, the club have actually seen what Nick brings, who is arrogant enough to think they know better?
Certainly at Geelong... I first saw him in the champs playing HBF .. and played more like a rebound defender ... but once at Geelong.. watching his forst or second VFL game he was like watching SJ back to the futureWe see things differently. When I first saw Menzel, 2 of us immediately said- SJ. The kicking action, the goal sense, the swagger, the confidence.
Mackie started as a really lean fragile looking player- admittedly, he never got really big!
Are you kidding!At this point in the draft I don't think people are too fussed who we pick
People watch the u-18s and know the standout kids so having an opinion on the early picks is fair enough. When you get this late on it is really speculative and you just trust whoever they pick.Are you kidding!
P47, .. many great players have been picked 40's and plenty of failures in the top 10.
Yeah but they know what they know they're not throwing darts.People watch the u-18s and know the standout kids so having an opinion on the early picks is fair enough. When you get this late on it is really speculative and you just trust whoever they pick.