Werewolf Work it out Werewolf

[ClarkeM]

Shuey is pretty sus though

 

[Proper Gander]

This game would be good fun to watch from the dead PM

 

[Shueygod]

I think you're forgetting most of the vanillagers have a chance of being evil still, so screw the slam dunk village option. I'm gonna play my game.

Not most, at best 2/8 would be negatively impacted. A vote on Mgbc would be almost as likely to impact the 2/8.

Plus surely you play the odds in that scenario, it’s why I’m playing as a Doc.

 

[Nothing]

Can someone summarise the players possible roles and combinations?

 

[cats_09]

This game would be good fun to watch from the dead PM

Do you think they're laughing at us trying to work things out?

 

[Nothing]

Can someone summarise the players possible roles and combinations?

From the merry-go-round on JHF, shuey and CM.

 

[Proper Gander]

Do you think they're laughing at us trying to work things out?

Yep.

 

[ZergMinion]

Not most, at best 2/8 would be negatively impacted. A vote on Mgbc would be almost as likely to impact the 2/8.

Plus surely you play the odds in that scenario, it’s why I’m playing as a Doc.

MCBG 100% has a kill or seer results.

 

[Proper Gander]

MCBG 100% has a kill or seer results.

Is this 100% logic or part vibes?

MC looks like an evil game to me, can you share anything more concrete?

 

[Pie 4 Life]

This game would be good fun to watch from the dead PM

It sure would. Does anybody know if they happened to be the ones who put someone in the Dead PM? Asking for a spreadsheet.

 

[Gralin]

It sure would. Does anybody know if they happened to be the ones who put someone in the Dead PM? Asking for a spreadsheet.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Can someone summarise the players possible roles and combinations?

Shuey is almost certainly the doctor with only the RB the other possibility (unless we factor in the 2IC being successful). I targeted Shuey last night so I know for a fact they went for 3KZ which removes any killing role possibilities given it was successful.

JHF was defending being the arsonist for some reason because they said they got a successful target of porps N1, but porps missed a kill. They went me N2 and I had the amulet (hence the unsuccessful) so they're almost certainly the roleblocker unless they are lying and its a seer and they're the head.

Clarkey is the most confusing as got both successful targets, of Gralin and DP, but both are alive, and he says they're not seers. Of course he could be lying, but it was a way of getting out of the could-be-SK train of thought because I initially suggested Headless (who targeted Clarkey twice with unsuccessful) could be the Arsonist (hence missing on the SK). It would fit being a NI player though if Clarkey is getting seers, because Headless would also be unsuccessful as Arsonist.

If Headless isn't the Arsonist, then its someone who might think they're a villager and have just hit two unsuccessful targets (heads or protected) which is why if we find the Arsonist at some point, we'll likely have the heads as well.

 

[Nothing]

porps N1, but porps missed a kill.

Porps didn't putin a N1 action.

Otherwise thanks.

 

[Proper Gander]

MCBG 100% has a kill or seer results.

I’m still puzzling this one out.

The only meaningful contribution MC has made was to cast shade on pie.

If MC is one of three seers they could have seered Pie (an obvious early seer target) and taking a punt on being more likely evil so trying to get players sus about Pie

 

[Crimson Azure]

What were your targets and results

What were everyone else’s?

And you’re assuming I have an action that works when I select a primary.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Porps didn't putin a N1 action.

Otherwise thanks.

Yeah either way could still be the RB or doc but more likely the former the way they have posted.

 

[Crimson Azure]

Are you being evasive Crimson Azure

No I am not, I don’t have time to wade through the last 20 pages so looking for a little quid pro quo.

 

[Proper Gander]

What were everyone else’s?

And you’re assuming I have an action that works when I select a primary.

Not keen on your wanting to know everyone else’s results before committing, Crim

 

[Nothing]

What were everyone else’s?

And you’re assuming I have an action that works when I select a primary.

We (well pie and Cats) are tracking actions and if successful. If you search their posts you'll see everyone else's actions.

 

[Proper Gander]

No I am not, I don’t have time to wade through the last 20 pages so looking for a little quid pro quo.

Search the thread for “spreadsheet “ and you should find something

 

[Nothing]

This is the spreadsheet I’ve got based on reported actions within this thread - we’ve got 3 players who haven’t offered any information to their targets at this stage, and web’ve had confirmed kills every night from the Mafia, Wolves and SK…should we maybe be looking at someone who hasn’t been as forthcoming?

View attachment 2503031

Here

 

[Proper Gander]

How come cats and pies spreadsheets show different results for Clarke’s actions?

 

[cats_09]

How come cats and pies spreadsheets show different results for Clarke’s actions?

Mine's now been updated - I had Clarke wrong for N2

He claims success on both nights

 

[Proper Gander]

Mine's now been updated - I had Clarke wrong for N2

He claims success on both nights

That’s what I remembered

 

[cats_09]

What were everyone else’s?

And you’re assuming I have an action that works when I select a primary.

In trying to help us "Work It Out", we're trying to track submitted night actions to see if any patterns start to show to help nut out the what we don't know

If you're willing, would you like to share your submitted targets for N1 and N2, and if you were successful or not