List Mgmt. Would you take Aish back?

[Nunez]

Watching on the couch and Aish literally just popped on screen kicking the ball at training. It was a shank.

 

[jonnobackpocket]

This thread is shit and the people attacking James personally are shit.

Go spread your shit off this board you bunch of shit sprayers

Having an opinion on a player on big footy is shit?

 

[Billy Puller]

Having an opinion on a player on big footy is shit?

Calling someone an arrogant soft **** isn't an opinion an a blokes playing ability but a completely unfounded opinion on a bloke you don't know.

So yep I'd say that's pretty shit

 

[jonnobackpocket]

Calling someone an arrogant soft **** isn't an opinion an a blokes playing ability but a completely unfounded opinion on a bloke you don't know.

So yep I'd say that's pretty shit

The way he acted and treated the club was arrogant and the way he played and effort he gave was soft, that is what I based it on. Didn't realise we had to "know" someone to have an opinion. Do you have an opinion on Donald Trump?

 

[luthor]

Calling someone an arrogant soft **** isn't an opinion an a blokes playing ability but a completely unfounded opinion on a bloke you don't know.

So yep I'd say that's pretty shit

Well i said "NO" because I sincerely believe he's a crap player.

Having voted that way, I agree with you BP.

One can have an opinion about his playing ability without getting down and dirty about the man's character.

 

[SizeMatters]

I personally didn't think Aish was as bad as people are making out while he was at the Lions. Sure he couldn't break his way out of a wet paper bag, he did indeed panic under pressure, was pretty slow too and not to mention his elite around the body kick to the boundary line was always going to be a winner... actually come to think of it his only claim to fame was being SANFL and Norwood royalty. I guess he has that to fall back on I suppose.

 

[a mayes ing]

Not even sure why this is a thread. We aren't taking him back, if we have this one then why not have a thread on Docherty and polec etc. Not even a good player, reckon he might forge himself a C+ or a B- career if he manages to stay in a team but will never amount to nything imo. Just not very athletic, hard to believe the stats he got in underage years

 

[T Rick]

I was disappointed with the way Aish left us and wanted him to stay. The issue that has always had me bemused is why we were so desperate to keep him if he is as bad as he now is? If he had committed, would he be a better player for the Lions now?

 

[3KZ is Football]

You are in my top 3.

Take me on a date then we can talk baby

I'm over here.

 

[Billy Puller]

I'm over here.

I'm just waiting by the telephone.....

 

[FFB1]

And thinks Aish is not a very good player.

 

[MacMum]

Oh wow, here we go again..


...and NO, I wouldn't take Aish back. Why is this even being talked about?

 

[Fatcat08]

well this went about as well as expected. Next person to start an Aish thread gets a week off.

 

[ZoBlitz]

well this went about as well as expected. Next person to start an Aish thread gets a week off.

Can we make that a rule for any re-signing threads too?