OH WE'RE FROM DIVER LAND
- Jun 19, 2014
- AFL Club
Didn't say you were any of those things. All I said was that as I replied to your earlier post, was that I did not take into account 2020 in relation to Xavier because of the impact I believe COVID likely had to that season.Your argument on each of those points is not with me. Pointing out a flaw in your argument doesn't mean I am the personification of every criticism anyone ever levelled at Xavier Campbell, and I'm not going to defend those arguments on that basis either.
I think it's important when making a judgement about his performance that we are appraised of the facts, both what he is responsible for, and exactly what happened in the areas he is responsible.
A CEO doesn't get credit for everything good that his underlings do and then when it turns to sh*t it was someone else's responsibility. Either he's fully responsible, good and bad, or he's not. And if he's not then that's not good enough.
You are also saying the exact same thing I am? If Xavier is responsible for game day failings (like some on here are saying) then he must also be responsible for the positives in membership growth, I'm simply pointing out that its a bit unfair to say he is to blame for one thing but then give the credit to someone else when someone is successful.