Your Best 22 After The Trade Period

[NaturalDisaster]

Now that the trade period is done what does every think their best 22 next year will look. I've made a rough attempt on all teams.


Richmond:

B: Nick Vlastuin ~ Alex Rance ~ Dylan Grimes
HB: Chris Yarran ~ David Astbury ~ Bachar Houli

M: Brandon Ellis ~ Dion Prestia ~ Shane Edwards
R: Shaun Hampson ~ Dustin Martin ~ Trent Cotchin

HF: Sam Lloyd ~ Ben Griffiths ~ Josh Caddy
F: Daniel Rioli ~ Jack Riewoldt ~ Toby Nankervis

I/C: Anthony Miles ~ Oleg Markov ~ Shaun Grigg ~ Corey Ellis

pretty spot on, except i would have Connor menadue as best 22 over corey ellis

and Kamdyn mcintosh would be best 22

 

[Tyler Hodges]

Eh seeing as how those kids are all a year older and have proven they can handle finals pressure, that GWS list is scary, especially with Deledio. GG competition.

 

[aussierulesrules]

Good effort mike123.

For us you've left out two of the top 5 in our B&F though, in Geary (2nd) and Newnes (5th), who are also two of the leading candidates to take over the captaincy from N-Roo. Both are walk-up starts in our team, in particular after career-best seasons last year.

I'd say Koby Stevens will also be best 22 if he has a relatively full preseason and is fit and in form and at this stage will probably be ahead of Steele in the midfield pecking order. Probably ahead of Dunstan, too, especially with him coming off another shoulder reco. Ross comfortably ahead of all of them at this stage.

Montagna plays HBF these days and Riewoldt will almost certainly continue to play mostly wing, if Paddy, Bruce and Membrey are all fit and playing.

Here is my shot at it:

B: Dempster ~ Brown ~ Geary
HB: Montagna ~ Carlisle ~ Roberton
C: Riewoldt ~ Ross ~ Newnes
HF: Weller ~ Bruce ~ Billings
F: Gresham ~ McCartin ~ Membrey
R: Hickey ~ Armitage ~ Steven
I: Acres ~ Stevens ~ Savage ~ Gilbert

E: Dunstan ~ Steele ~ Webster ~ Wright ~ McKenzie ~ Lonie ~ Sinclair ~ Minchington ~ Goddard ~ Longer

The first 4 on the emergencies list were extremely stiff (Webster and Dunstan have both been best 22 for the last couple of years and Wright was a permanent fixture in our forward line at the end of this year, in a defensive role), which shows that we are starting to get some pretty decent depth happening.

 

[compact72]

Tom Boyd isn't best 22

How original.

Didn't watch the GF buddy?

 

[Mofra]

Tom Boyd isn't best 22

This is why Collingwood fans have a reputation folks.

 

[Smithdogmaddog]

This is stuffed.

The only weakness i see is KPD especially due to how injury prone phil davis is, not that it will be getting down there much!

 

[_Mike_]

FB: Morris, Adams, Wood

HB: Johannisen, Murphy, Biggs

C: Macrae, Picken, Hunter

HF: Stringer, T Boyd, Crameri,

FF: Dickson, Cloke, Dahlhaus

Fol: Roughead, Bontempelli, Libberatore

IC: Suckling, Daniel, Wallis, M Boyd

Em: Roberts, Campbell, Dunkley, Smith

 

[Established1870]

Port Adelaide:

B: Darcy Byrne-Jones ~ Jack Hombsch ~ Tom Clurey
HB: Nathan Krakouer ~ Logan Austin ~ Jasper Pittard

M: Hamish Hartlett ~ Oliver Wines ~ Jared Polec
R: Patrick Ryder ~ Travis Boak ~ Robbie Gray

HF: Jarman Impey ~ Justin Westhoff ~ Aaron Young
F: Chad Wingard ~ Charlie Dixon ~ Jackson Trengove

I/C: Jake Neade ~ Matthew Broadbent ~ Brad Ebert ~ Karl Amon

Would rather have Bonner over Broadbent at this stage and literally anyone over Neade. Palmer's a good shout for a spot in the starting 22 as well, we might still get a DFA (plz be Barrett/Barlow) and there's the 4 draftees in the Top 30 that we've got locked in. If we get Battle or Marshall then they'd be starting 22 surely and maybe Jonty Scharenburg if he's at the 30 mark still. Monfries coming back in gives us even more options.

 

[HeHateMe]

I have Burton starting 18 for the Hawks.

I'll give an attempt:

B: Stratton ~ Frawley ~ Birchall
HB: Duryea ~ Brand ~ Burton

C: Hartung ~ Shiles ~ Smith
M: Mcevoy ~ TMitchell ~ O'Meara

HF: Bruest ~ Gunston ~ Rioli
F: Sicily ~ Roughead ~ Puopolo

INT: Hodge ~ Burgoyne ~ Gibson ~ Vickery.

EMG: Langford ~ Whitecross ~ Lovell ~ Shoey.


Sent from my E6653 using Tapatalk

 

[clivenator26]

Now that the trade period is done what does every think their best 22 next year will look. I've made a rough attempt on all teams.

Fremantle:

B: Lee Spurr ~ Alex Pearce ~ Joel Hamling
HB: David Mundy ~ Michael Johnson ~ Hayden Crozier

C: Brad Hill ~ Connor Blakely ~ Stephen Hill
R: Aaron Sandilands ~ Lachie Neale ~ Nat Fyfe

HF: Harley Bennell ~ Shane Kersten ~ Michael Walters
F: Shane Yarran ~ Cam McCarthy ~ Micheal Apeness

I/C: Darcy Tucker ~ Ed Langdon ~ Lachie Weller ~ Danyle Pearce

I've got Sheridan and Ballantyne in mine for Crozier and DPearce who are emgs in mine along with Ibbotson. I'd also have Barlow in (at Langdon's expense) but it sounds like he won't be at the club next year.

Spurr Hamling Johnson
Mundy APearce Weller
BHill Blakely SHill
Bennell Apeness Yarran
Walters McCarthy Kersten
Sandi Fyfe Neale

Ballantyne, Langdon, Sheridan, Tucker
Emg - Crozier, Ibbo, DPearce (25)

 

[nuey]

Now that the trade period is done what does every think their best 22 next year will look. I've made a rough attempt on all teams.


Carlton:

B: Kade Simpson ~ Sam Rowe ~ Jacob Weitering
HB: Sam Docherty ~ Caleb Marchbank ~ Lachie Plowman

C: Dylan Buckley ~ Ed Curnow ~ Bryce Gibbs
R: Matthew Kreuzer ~ Marc Murphy ~ Patrick Cripps

HF: Andrejs Everitt ~ Levi Casboult ~ Rhys Palmer
F: Jarrod Pickett ~ Jack Silvagni ~ Andrew Phillips

I/C: Dale Thomas ~ Liam Sumner ~ Sam Kerridge ~ Matthew Wright


-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Good effort with carlton, I'm assuming you've left out injured players or I would have Byrne in there.
Could chop and change with Boekhorst/Buckley, Charlie Curnow/Everitt, Graham/Sumner but I think you're pretty close.

 

[MC_9]

GWS team is a joke.

From the centre line onwards, it is A-Grade talent everywhere. Would have to be close to the most talented list ever assembled.

 

[jakefooty23]

Tom Boyd isn't best 22

Lol, neither is Patrick Dangerfield

 

[happypieman7]

This is why Collingwood fans have a reputation folks.

welcome to the afl ......

 

[coniglio_number1]

GWS team is a joke.

From the centre line onwards, it is A-Grade talent everywhere. Would have to be close to the most talented list ever assembled.

Just out of curiosity what weaknesses do you see in the backline?

 

[Thats Wright]

No mate it's all Brad Scott's fault and don't get me started on JB and Thomas, Gibson, Hansen, and did I mention Brad Scott and also keeping the old guys on and never giving guys like Daw or Brown a chance and Chris Scott.

There should be laws against North bigfooty flogs posting more than once a week.

We don't get back this time you've stolen.

 

[Scotland]

FB: Morris, Adams, Wood

HB: Johannisen, Murphy, Biggs

C: Macrae, Picken, Hunter

HF: Stringer, T Boyd, Crameri,

FF: Dickson, Cloke, Dahlhaus

Fol: Roughead, Bontempelli, Libberatore

IC: Suckling, Daniel, Wallis, M Boyd

Em: Roberts, Campbell, Dunkley, Smith

Smith outside the 22? Surely not.

 

[yeee_haaaa!!!!!]

Pies

B: smith keefe Howe
HB: Goldsack Reid scharenberg
C: Sidebottom treloar wells
HF: Mayne white broomhead
F: Elliott Moore fasolo
R: Grundy pendles Adams
Int: de goey crisp Varcoe cox

On the fringe : hoskin-Elliott aish Blair Maynard Thomas Langdon Sinclair Oxley Ramsay greenwood Dunn wills Crocker Phillips Gault

 

[_Mike_]

Smith outside the 22? Surely not.

Team balance. Neither Cordy or Roberts are there either

 

[Suma Magic]

15-25 is very up in the air.

FB: Schofield Barrass Sheppard
HB: Hurn McGovern Wellingham
C: Jetta Mitchell Gaff
HF: Yeo Darling Sheed
FF: LeCras Kennedy Cripps

R: Lycett Priddis Shuey

I: Nelson Redden Masten Vardy

E: Hill Butler Duggan Mackenzie Hutchings

 

[The Joker]

FB: Morris, Adams, Wood

HB: Johannisen, Murphy, Biggs

C: Macrae, Picken, Hunter

HF: Stringer, T Boyd, Crameri,

FF: Dickson, Cloke, Dahlhaus

Fol: Roughead, Bontempelli, Libberatore

IC: Suckling, Daniel, Wallis, M Boyd

Em: Roberts, Campbell, Dunkley, Smith

Crameri, Dixon and Cloke in a forward line that has TBoyd and Stringer, that's 5 Full Forwards in the same F50!!!

 

[Rotayjay]

ADELAIDE
Backline: Okay
Forward line: Good
Midfield: Far, far off premiership quality.

What the club has done to address the midfield apart from waiting for Gibbs to fall into our laps: Nothing.

 

[Milanista28]

GWS on paper is fking ridiculous.

 

[Rotayjay]

GWS on paper is fking ridiculous.

Please don't mention it, you'll trigger me (and the reply squad of Bokonon, Ichabod Noodle, and General Giant that inevitably follows).

 

[coniglio_number1]

Please don't mention it, you'll trigger me (and the reply squad of Bokonon, Ichabod Noodle, and General Giant that inevitably follows).

Do you have a problem with supporters defending their club?