More just an observation that the arrogance by Richmond supporters because of 3 good years is way over the top.Does commenting on here define how long people have followed their club?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
LIVE: Richmond v Melbourne - 7:25PM Wed
Squiggle tips Demons at 77% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
More just an observation that the arrogance by Richmond supporters because of 3 good years is way over the top.Does commenting on here define how long people have followed their club?
More just an observation that the arrogance by Richmond supporters because of 3 good years is way over the top.
Impressive team considering top 4 finish last year.Brisbane
Witherden Andrews Hinge
Answerth Gardiner Starcevich
Ah Chee Mathieson Cox
Bailey McStay Rayner
Cameron Hipwood McInerney
A Smith J Berry McLuggage
Skinner Allison E Smith T Berry
All players except E Smith and T Berry have played AFL already. No first year players included.
25 is a very strange cut-off, They are no longer ‘young’ when 25
Dogs side listed is strong as it has a group of 24-25 yr olds - Hunter, Bont and Macrae who are the stars.
The Dogs would be hoping to contend in 2020...
Re the Pies, pretty comfortable in our position as we have guys who are our key talents u25 - Grundy, DeGoey, Moore, Stephenson and Maynard
We also have a glut of our players who are 26 (so don’t count for this piece) but will be mainstays for next five years in - Treloar, Adams, Crisp, WHE, Mihocek.
The Pies having plenty of players in the 23-27 age group is why we should be challenging again for next couple of years.
not a bad sidePlayers are in a position close to where they should be. Three proven players, a bunch of exciting talent, a promising list of untried rookies and a stack of trusted 15-22 types. The future looks okay!
FB: J.Carter - G.Logue - E.Hughes
HB: L.Ryan - A.Pearce (C) - H.Young*
C: J.Aish - A.Brayshaw (VC) - D.Tucker
R: S.Darcy - B.Acres - A.Cerra
HF: B.Bewley - B.Cox - C.McCarthy
FF: L.Henry* - J.Hogan - S.Switkowski
Int: C.Blakely - L.Valente* - T.Duman - C.Serong*
The rest
B.Banfied, S.Giro, H.Dixon, M.Crowden, L.Schultz,
D.O'Reilly*, T.North*, M.Frederick*, S.Sturt*, L.Meek*, J.Pina*, T.Watson*, L.Thomas*, I.Butters*.
+50 games
20-49 games
* Y.T.D.
They have a lot of high draft picks, but only Cripps and Walsh have actually delivered. Curnow if he wasn’t so injury prone. The rest are B graders.
Pies are done IMO. Two heartbreaking finals losses are hard to come back from plus they won’t win a flag with Mihocek and Cox as their KPFs.25 is a very strange cut-off, They are no longer ‘young’ when 25
Dogs side listed is strong as it has a group of 24-25 yr olds - Hunter, Bont and Macrae who are the stars.
The Dogs would be hoping to contend in 2020...
Re the Pies, pretty comfortable in our position as we have guys who are our key talents u25 - Grundy, DeGoey, Moore, Stephenson and Maynard
We also have a glut of our players who are 26 (so don’t count for this piece) but will be mainstays for next five years in - Treloar, Adams, Crisp, WHE, Mihocek.
The Pies having plenty of players in the 23-27 age group is why we should be challenging again for next couple of years.
10 premiership players.....ahem where is jack ******* graham?Good thread. Dead at work, I’ll have a crack at Richmond. I endeavored to keep a similar structure to the 2019 side.
B: McIntosh Garthwaite Baker
HB: Vlastuin Balta Eggmolesse-Smith
C: Rioli Stack Short
HF: Castagna Chol Higgins
F: Dow Coleman-Jones Markov
R: Nankervis Ross Bolton
I: Soldo, Naish, Collier-Dawkins, Cumberland
9 premiership players remain which is great.
Missed out, Turner, Ralphsmith, Miller, Nyuon, Martin, Aarts, English
Tigers list has 10 premiership players.....eagles similarBest 25 and under in order
1: Dogs
2: Lions
3: North
4: Suns
5: Giants
6: blues
7: Saints
8: Freo
bottom 4
Cats, pies, crows, Eagles/tigers
Were you posting the last time you beat us?Can't help but notice you only started commenting on here when Richmond became relevant after 25 years of well not being so
McIntosh looks closer to 35. Is he really under 25?B: McIntosh, Garthwaite, Baker
HB: Short, Vlastuin (C), Markov
C: Martyn, Stack, Balta
HF: Castagna, Chol, Higgins
F: Rioli, Coleman-Jones, Cumberland
R: Soldo, Ross (VC), Bolton,
I: Nankervis, Naish, Collier-Dawkins, Eggmolesse-Smith
Yeah he's 25. Really went downhill in the looks department over the course of one preseason.McIntosh looks closer to 35. Is he really under 25?
You can say that again. Aging rapidlyYeah he's 25. Really went downhill in the looks department over the course of one preseason.
Mate Lions supporters have had nothing but pain for the last 12-13 years outside of last year. Even during the 3 peat era our supporters didn’t even come close to the arrogance a section of tigers supporters exhibit.Were you posting the last time you beat us?
Because those players are mainly flankers and not in key positionsTigers list has 10 premiership players.....eagles similar
Logic...not found
Best 25 and under in order
1: Dogs
2: Lions
3: North
4: Suns
5: Giants
6: blues
7: Saints
8: Freo
bottom 4
Cats, pies, crows, Eagles/tigers
I just can’t see how you can have North so high. They literally have none of the top 25 and under players.
I mean you have Collingwood bottom 4 and they have Grundy, De Goey, Stephenson, Phillips and Moore. I’d have all 5 of those guys are better than North’s best u25 player. Who is probably Zurharr at this point? I know footballs a team game but imagine for a second what Brodie Grundy would do to Tristan Xerri?
I’m actually not trying to attack North’s youth as I rate LDU, Thomas, Simpkin, Zurharr and Larkey but for the most part they are still mostly potential not real production. Especially when you consider other U/25 sides are rolling around with genuine stars of the competition.
Look at who he supports and there is your answerI just can’t see how you can have North so high. They literally have none of the top 25 and under players.
I mean you have Collingwood bottom 4 and they have Grundy, De Goey, Stephenson, Phillips and Moore. I’d have all 5 of those guys are better than North’s best u25 player. Who is probably Zurharr at this point? I know footballs a team game but imagine for a second what Brodie Grundy would do to Tristan Xerri?
I’m actually not trying to attack North’s youth as I rate LDU, Thomas, Simpkin, Zurharr and Larkey but for the most part they are still mostly potential not real production. Especially when you consider other U/25 sides are rolling around with genuine stars of the competition.
Tigers list has 10 premiership players.....eagles similar
Logic...not found