Prediction Your Draft Selections

[ShaunWDT]

I'd be surprised if we considered Tim Kelly as a Motlop replacement he plays his best footy as an inside mid bursting out of stoppages.

 

[CatRiot]

Ok, I polled the Draft Selections of the 16 people that voted, on the basis of:

Pick 22= 5pts
Pick 24= 4pts
Pick 35= 3pts
Pick 58= 2pts
Pick 72= 1pts

*Noting that many didn't select Pick 72; and I have excluded Rookie Upgrades and Re-drafting delisted players; so the focus is on new talent for the club.

These are the results from

Total Pts - Player
30 Miers
21 Ling
18 Bailey
15 Houlahan
15 Wooller
14 Taylor
13 McCartin
10 Garner
8 Clavarino
8 Sambono
8 Kelly
6 L Fogarty
6 Worpel
5 Ballard
5 North
5 Allen
5 Petty
5 Balta
5 O'Brien
4 Nolan
4 CC Jones
4 Spargo
3 Moore
2 Ross
2 Lynch
2 Edwards
2 Starcevich
2 Ryan
1 Farrell
1 Milera
1 Parrish
1 Daniels

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

Ok, I polled the Draft Selections of the 16 people that voted, on the basis of:

Pick 22= 5pts
Pick 24= 4pts
Pick 35= 3pts
Pick 58= 2pts
Pick 72= 1pts

*Noting that many didn't select Pick 72; and I have excluded Rookie Upgrades and Re-drafting delisted players; so the focus is on new talent for the club.

These are the results from

Total Pts - Player
30 Miers
21 Ling
18 Bailey
15 Houlahan
15 Wooller
14 Taylor
13 McCartin
10 Garner
8 Clavarino
8 Sambono
8 Kelly
6 L Fogarty
6 Worpel
5 Ballard
5 North
5 Allen
5 Petty
5 Balta
5 O'Brien
4 Nolan
4 CC Jones
4 Spargo
3 Moore
2 Ross
2 Lynch
2 Edwards
2 Starcevich
2 Ryan
1 Farrell
1 Milera
1 Parrish
1 Daniels

Are you sure you have O'Brien right? I selected him with pick 22 and I've seen others mention him as well.

 

[CatRiot]

Are you sure you have O'Brien right? I selected him with pick 22 and I've seen others mention him as well.

Updated to include SpazzCat's entry, it was a replied/copy entry and I ignored it by mistake in the first calculations as I thought it was a duplicate. So the list is compiled from 17 people now.

I have not counted entries where people have used multiple selections, just ignored them for simplicity, and I'm counting "what people think Wells will select" rather than "their our preferences" where they have listed twice.

Total Pts Player
30 Miers
22 Bailey
21 Ling
17 Wooller
16 McCartin
15 Houlahan
14 Taylor
10 Garner
10 O'Brien
8 Clavarino
8 Sambono
8 Kelly
6 L Fogarty
6 Worpel
5 Ballard
5 North
5 Allen
5 Petty
5 Balta
4 Nolan
4 CC Jones
4 Spargo
3 Moore
2 Ross
2 Lynch
2 Edwards
2 Starcevich
2 Ryan
1 Crameri
1 Farrell
1 Milera
1 Parrish
1 Daniels

 

[ChookNorris]

Interestingly reading on the main board, Miers 6th slowest 20m at the combine...

 

[CatRiot]

Interestingly reading on the main board, Miers 6th slowest 20m at the combine...

That will make him slip a lot I suspect... Recruiters will not like that at all.

 

[CatRiot]

Just looking at Draft Central... I think Aiden Domic might be a good rookie selection. Just a smart player, finds the footy, strong presence.

 

[ShaunWDT]

Interestingly reading on the main board, Miers 6th slowest 20m at the combine...

Miers is slow as shit and that's my knock on him considering he's a small forward, won't get by just by footy smarts playing against men, don't want him any earlier than 35 personally and think he's a touch overhyped based on one performance.

 

[ChookNorris]

Miers is slow as shit and that's my knock on him considering he's a small forward, won't get by just by footy smarts playing against men, don't want him any earlier than 35 personally and think he's a touch overhyped based on one performance.

Friend of mine works with one of the line coaches at falcons. Reckons he should be a late or rookie, will struggle to make it.

 

[DanA]

Pick 22= Matt Ling
Pick 24= Oscar Allen
Pick 35= Brandon Starcevich
Pick 58= Bailey Fritsch
Pick 72= Sam Dobson

 

[winty]

Pick 72= Sam Dobson

 

[DanA]

I actually think it's gonna be a rookie pick but want him

 

[Deep]

Ling Miers McCartin Wooller pls

 

[Pure_Ownage]

I actually think it's gonna be a rookie pick but want him

We have no rookie slots free.

 

[BORIS332]

Interestingly reading on the main board, Miers 6th slowest 20m at the combine...

Yep, short and slow. His footy smarts might make him a stand out TAC level but he won't get near it at AFL level.

 

[BORIS332]

Ling Miers McCartin Wooller pls

Other states in Australia have draft prospects too FYI.

 

[Deep]

Other states in Australia have draft prospects too FYI.

Didn't realise all were Vics. I don't really care about getting Ling but I like Miers because he's a good small forward whilst McCartin ain't bad and it also could help lure his brother one day if we are interested. As for Wooller he's more of a roughy but I'd rather we keep Geelong in his family.

 

[Jhye Clark 13]

Pick 22= Matt Ling
Pick 24= Oscar Allen
Pick 35= Brandon Starcevich
Pick 58= Bailey Fritsch
Pick 72= Sam Dobson

I reckon you could be on the money with a VFL player being taken with pick 72.

 

[Pure_Ownage]

I reckon you could be on the money with a VFL player being taken with pick 72.

I like dobson but he is a similar age to menzel and black and none of the three of them can play midfield so i am not sure he is a great fit for us. A player from another vfl club maybe or possibly atkins if we take someone from within is maybe more likely.

 

[year of the cat]

Don't want Ling with any pick with a 2 in front of it or Ballard. We should be able to pick 2 players with our first two picks from a group that may include O'Brien, Bailey, Houlahan, Richards, Garner, Constable and Murphy. Give me two of them. Take a tall with pick 35 - happy if we call McCartin at 35. Wooller if he's gone. Maybe 58 and 72 on a small forward like Sambono or another runner such as Farrell.

 

[Pure_Ownage]

Don't want Ling with any pick with a 2 in front of it or Ballard. We should be able to pick 2 players with our first two picks from a group that may include O'Brien, Bailey, Houlahan, Richards, Garner, Constable and Murphy. Give me two of them. Take a tall with pick 35 - happy if we call McCartin at 35. Wooller if he's gone. Maybe 58 and 72 on a small forward like Sambono or another runner such as Farrell.

I can see the risk with Ling but there is potential there and at least he fills an obvious need on our list. Richards will probably be gone and other than OBrien i am not seeing anything else there that really addresses what we need. Don't mind the ideas for the later picks.

 

[ShaunWDT]

Ling would dominate with quality AFL on ballers feeding him the ball, Falcons were a good side but midfield was far from their strength, Worpel probably the best and he's considered a 2nd rounder at best and has poor disposial.

 

[Catsmaninamerica]

We will take

Tim Kelly
Toby Wooler
Liam Ryan
Jeremiah Scrutton

 

[Pure_Ownage]

We will take

Tim Kelly
Toby Wooler
Liam Ryan
Jeremiah Scrutton

No club outside of WA is taking ryan with a top 50 pick he has professionalism issues and is a big chance to end up quitting. I would be staggered if we use 35 on him as you have suggested there.

Would be happy with Wooller and Kelly though.

 

[Landgraft]

22 - Zac Bailey
24 - Sam Taylor
35 - Toby Wooller
58 - James Worpel
72 - Lachlan Pascoe

Others don't like him, personally I would be ecstatic if Worpel slid that far down the order. I do think we need to keep bringing in young mids, even if they won't play from the get-go and he deserves a chance at AFL level.

Pascoe is in there as a placeholder for Wells doing Wells things. I don't actually think we'll draft someone who just did an ACL, but it'll be some left field madness. Or it could just be Sambono.