Competitions Your Draft Top 20

[HARKER]

O.K. there may not be any prizes here (Unless O.D.N. throws something in) but since we have a draft coming up, let's see how we fare with our top 20.
I'll draft up the selection order which can then just be either cut and pasted into your post or just quoted with your picks then added.
We'll award 1 point for every player you select that hits the top 20 and 3 points for every player you choose correctly as per the teams selection.

Rules:
1. The picks can be changed at any time until the deadline of 23.59 on Friday the 16th. November.
(Most of the better phantoms come into being the days after, so this largely should be your own work and reasoning.)
2. Any posts that have been edited after that time cannot be considered.
3. Your welcome to discuss your selections but please keep that separate to the list.
4. Other teams posters are also welcome.

 

[HereComesJuddy]

1.GWS - Lachlan Whitfield
2.GWS - Jimmy Toumpas
3.GWS - Lachlan Plowman
4.MELB - Oliver Wines
5.DOGS - Jonothan O’Rourke
6.DOGS - Troy Menzel
7.POWER - Sam Mayes
8.LIONS - Kristian Jaksch
9.TIGES - Brodie Grundy
10.DONS – Joe Daniher
11.BLUES - Nick Vlastuin
12.GWS - Jackson Macrae
13.GCS - Josh Simpson
14.GWS - Aidan Corr
15.ROOS - Jake Stringer
16.CATS - Tom Clurey
17.DOCKS - Dayle Garlett
18.PIES - Ben Kennedy
19.PIES - Taylor Garner
20.????? - Tim Membrey

Unlucky: , Nathan Hrovat, Sam Coloquhoun, Mason Shaw, Jesse Lonergan
Great idea Harks

 

[Sin City]

Pick 13 belongs to GC Harks

Good thread too

 

[inyourcool]

The following is done with the assumption that GWS take Tippett in the ND, no Adelaide pick in first round and a nice dose of fantasy!

1.GWS - Lachlan Whitfield
2.GWS - Jimmy Toumpas
3.GWS - Kurt Tippett
4.MELB - Brodie Grundy
5.DOGS - Oliver Wines
6.DOGS - Jonothan O’Rourke
7.POWER - Taylor Garner
8.LIONS - Kristian Jaksch
9.TIGES - Jackson Macrae
10.DONS – Joe Daniher
11.BLUES - Jake Stringer
12.GWS - Lachlan Plowman
13.GCS - Tim Membrey
14.GWS - Sam Mayes
15.ROOS - Ben Kennedy
16.CATS - Nick Vlastuin
17.DOCKS - Tom Clurey
18.PIES - Troy Menzel
19.PIES - Jesse Lonergan
20.PIES - Dayle Garlett

If only...

 

[Bronze]

1.GWS - Lachlan Whitfield
2.GWS - Jimmy Toumpas
3.GWS - Brodie Grundy
4.MELB - Ollie Wines
5.DOGS - Jake Stringer
6.DOGS - Jackson Macrae
7.POWER - Sam Mayes
8.LIONS - Jon O'Rourke
9.TIGES - Kristian Jaksh
10.DONS – Joe Daniher
11.BLUES - Troy Menzel
12.GWS - Lachlan Plowman
13.GCS - Ben Kennedy
14.GWS - Nick Vlastuin
15.ROOS - Nathan Hrovat
16.CATS - Tom Clurey
17.DOCKS - Dayle Garlett
18.PIES - Tim Membrey
19.PIES - Jesse Lonergan
20.???? - Sam Colquon

 

[krayfesh]

1.GWS - Whitfield
2.GWS - Toumpas
3.GWS - Stringer
4.MELB - Grundy
5.DOGS - Macrae
6.DOGS - Plowman
7.POWER - Mayes
8.LIONS - Jaksch
9.TIGES - O"Rourke
10.DONS – Daniher
11.BLUES - Wines
12.GWS - Clurey
13.SUNS - Vlastuin
14.GWS - Menzel
15.ROOS - Kennedy
16.CATS - Membrey
17.DOCKS - Shaw
18.PIES - Garlett
19.PIES - Garner
20.????? - Colquhoun

 

[Wickzki]

1.GWS - Lachlan Whitfield
2.GWS - Jimmy Toumpas
3.GWS - Brodie Grundy
4.MELB - Jake Stringer
5.DOGS - Oliver Wines
6.DOGS - Lachlan Plowman
7.POWER - Sam Mayes
8.LIONS - Jonothan O'Rourke
9.TIGES - Jackson Macrae
10.DONS – Joe Daniher
11.BLUES - Taylor Garner
12.GWS - Jesse Lonergan
13.GCS - Tom Clurey
14.GWS - Tim Membrey
15.ROOS - Nick Vlastuin
16.CATS - Troy Menzel
17.DOCKS - Dayle Garlett
18.PIES - Ben Kennedy
19.PIES - Nathan Hrovat
20.CROWS - Kristian Jaksch

 

[TerryWallet]

1 GWS - L.Whitfield
2 GWS - B.Grundy
3 GWS - J.Toumpas
4 MELB - O.Wines
5 WB - J.Stringer
6 WB - L.Plowman
7 PA - S.Mayes
8 BRIS - K.Jaksch
9 RICH - J.O'Rourke
10 ESS - J.Daniher
11 CAR - J.Macrae
12 GWS - T.Clurey
13 GC - N.Vlastuin
14 GWS - T.Menzel
15 NM - B.Kennedy
16 GEE - T.Smith
17 FREO - M.Shaw
18 COLL - T.Garner
19 COLL - J.Simpson
20 COLL - N.Wright

 

[coryne]

1.GWS - Whitfield
2.GWS - Toumpas
3.GWS - Wines
4.MELB - Grundy
5.DOGS - Macrae
6.DOGS - Plowman
7.POWER - Mayes
8.LIONS - Jaksch
9.TIGES - Stinger
10.DONS – Daniher
11.BLUES - O’Rourke
12.GWS - Menzel
13.SUNS - Garlett
14.GWS - Tippett
15.ROOS - Garner
16.CATS - Vlastuin
17.DOCKS - Membrey
18.PIES - Kennedy
19.PIES - Colquhoun
20.????? - Lonergan

 

[zeeCFC]

1.GWS - Whitfield
2.GWS - Grundy
3.GWS - Toumpas
4.MELB - Wines
5.DOGS - O'Rourke
6.DOGS - Plowman
7.POWER - Stringer
8.LIONS - Mayes
9.TIGES - Menzel
10.DONS – Daniher
11.BLUES - Vlastuin
12.GWS - Tippett
13.SUNS - Jaksch
14.GWS - Clurey
15.ROOS - Garlett
16.CATS - Vlastuin
17.DOCKS - Shaw
18.PIES - Lonergan
19.PIES - Kennedy
20.????? - Garner

Goes to show how good the potential talent is in the top 20

 

[Silvagnis]

So much fail.

You need to give us your top ten in reverse order to make this more interesting.

 

[zeeCFC]

So much fail.

You need to give us your top ten in reverse order to make this more interesting.

It still won't be the same without dramatic pauses that only Andy D cam deliver.

Hope Xavier Ellis becomes a brownlow favourite in some miracle so we don't have to hear the pause.

 

[Roy71]

1 GWS Whitfield
2 GWS Grundy
3 GWS Toumpas
4 MELB Wines
5 DOGS Stringer
6 DOGS Clurey
7 POWER Menzel
8 LIONS Shaw
9 TIGES Membrey
10 DONS Daniher
11 BLUES Vlastuin
12 GWS MaCrae
13 SUNS O'Rourke
14 GWS Plowman
15 ROOS Kennedy
16 CATS Mayes
17 DOCKS Jaksch
18 PIES Simpson
19 PIES Lonergan
20 ? Garlett

 

[FlowersByIrene]

1.GWS - Whitfield
2.GWS - Toumpas
3.GWS - Tippet
4.MELB - Grundy
5.DOGS - Wines
6.DOGS - O'Rourke
7.POWER -Mayes
8.LIONS - Plowman
9.TIGES - Garner
10.DONS – Daniher
11.BLUES -Stringer
12.GWS - Menzel
13.SUNS - Membrey
14.GWS - Clurey
15.ROOS - Macrae
16.CATS -Vlastuin
17.DOCKS - Jaksch
18.PIES - Kennedy
19.PIES - Garlett
20.????? -Lonergan

Would love for this to happen

I'll edit this before the final due date if the Tippet situation is figured out it could change a lot

Dockers might take Shaw over Jaksch with the whole WA thing although i think other wise Jaksch would be the first taken.
If Shaw goes to Dockers then Pies would take Jaksch and Garlett and 20 would be Kennedy

 

[Weiterbot23]

Damn it, stringer going too high in most ppl drafts. I never knew you could become so attached to someone from just a few YouTube clips...

 

[choo]

1.GWS -Whitfield
2.GWS -Grundy
3.GWS -Wines
4.MELB -Toumpas
5.DOGS -O'Rourke
6.DOGS -Plowman
7.POWER -Menzel
8.LIONS -Tippett
9.TIGES -Stringer
10.DONS – Daniher
11.BLUES -Mayes
12.GWS -Macrae
13.SUNS -Vlautsin
14.GWS -Membrey
15.ROOS -Simpson
16.CATS -Clurey
17.DOCKS -Shaw
18.PIES -Garlett
19.PIES -Garner
20.PIES-T Smith

 

[Silvagnis]

1. GWS - Lachie Whitfield
2. GWS - Troy Menzel
3. GWS - Lachie Plowman
4. Melbourne - Jimmy Toumpas
5. Footscray - Jonathan O'Rourke
6. Footscray - Sam Mayes
7. Port - Brodie Grundy
8. Brisbane - Jackson Macrae
9. Richmond - Ollie Wines
10. Essendon - Joe Daniher
11 Carlton - Nick Vlastuin
12. GWS - Ben Kennedy
13. GC - Jake Stringer
14. GWS - Josh Simpson
15. Norf - Taylor Garner
16. Geelong - Kristian Jaksch
17. Fremantle - Jesse Lonergan
18. Collingwood - Tim Membrey
19. Collingwood - Nick Graham
20. Adelaide - Nathan Wright

 

[HereComesJuddy]

The best thing about this draft is that we will all be looking at the top 10 on stage and figuring out who hasn't been taken. Then we get the first pick after that.

 

[inyourcool]

Damn it, stringer going too high in most ppl drafts. I never knew you could become so attached to someone from just a few YouTube clips...

You're not the only one!!!

 

[HereComesJuddy]

Damn it, stringer going too high in most ppl drafts. I never knew you could become so attached to someone from just a few YouTube clips...

Unfortunately, he will not slide past the Doggies with their 2 picks. They are into him more than I am into Jennifer Love Hewitt's puppies (which is a lot)

 

[Omega Blue]

1.GWS - Whitfield
2.GWS - Toumpas
3.GWS - Menzel
4.MELB - Wines
5.DOGS - O'Rourke
6.DOGS - Plowman
7.POWER - Mayes
8.LIONS - Jaksch
9.TIGES - Grundy
10.DONS – Daniher
11.BLUES - Vlastuin
12.GWS - Macrae
13.SUNS - Stringer
14.GWS - Curley
15.ROOS - Kennedy
16.CATS - Garlett
17.DOCKS - Shaw
18.PIES - Garner
19.PIES - Membery
20.????? - Simpson

 

[Blugazi]

1.GWS – Lachie Whitfield
2.GWS – Jimmy Toumpas
3.GWS – Lachie Plowman
4.MELB – Oliver Wines
5.DOGS – Jonathan O’Rourke
6.DOGS – Troy Menzel
7.POWER – Brodie Grundy
8.LIONS – Kristian Jaksch
9.TIGES – Nick Vlastuin
10.DONS – Joe Daniher
11.BLUES – Jackson Macrae
12.GWS – Sam Mayes
13.SUNS – Josh Simpson
14.GWS – Jake Stringer
15.ROOS – Ben Kennedy
16.CATS – Taylor Garner
17.DOCKS – Mason Shaw
18.PIES – Jesse Lonergan
19.PIES – Dayle Garlett
20.????? – Aidan Corr

 

[Sheephead]

1.GWS - Whitfield
2.GWS - Grundy
3.GWS - Toumpas
4.MELB - Wines
5.DOGS - Plowman
6.DOGS - Clurey
7.POWER - Mayes
8.LIONS - Shaw
9.TIGES - Vlastuin
10.DONS – Daniher
11.BLUES - Stringer
12.GWS - Jaksch
13.SUNS - Menzel
14.GWS - O'Rourke
15.ROOS - Membrey
16.CATS - Macrae
17.DOCKS - Garlett
18.PIES - Kennedy
19.PIES - Lonergen
20.PIES - Ben Jacobs

 

[WeNeverTanked!]

​

1.GWS - Whitfield
2.GWS - Toumpas
3.GWS - Grundy
4.MELB - Wines
5.DOGS - Stringer
6.DOGS - O'Rourke
7.POWER - McRae
8.LIONS - Jaksch
9.TIGES - Vlaustin
10.DONS – Daniher (FS)
11.BLUES - Menzel
12.GWS - Gartlett
13.SUNS - Kennedy
14.GWS - Shaw
15.ROOS - Mayes
16.CATS - Garner
17.DOCKS - Simpson
18.PIES - Colquhoun
19.PIES - Clurey
20.????? - Membrey

Anyone who has us getting O'Rourke, Wines and even Stringer at 11 are kidding themselves. All basically locks for top 10

 

[HereComesJuddy]

11.BLUES - Viney