Your Line Up

[Da Bomberman]

What do you Collingwood fans want as your line up in 2003?

(list it in H,HB, C etc)

 

[Jabso]

B. Didak Lockyer Rocca
HB. Buckley Freeborn R. Shaw
C. A Dimmatina B. Kinnear S. Cummings
HF. Tarrant Wakelin, T. Davidson
F. Fraser, Prestigiacomo, Molloy
Fol. Licuria, Lonie, Woewodin
Int. Burns, Scotland, Cloke, Dane Swan

 

[Nic]

Originally posted by jabso
B. Didak Lockyer Rocca
HB. Buckley Freeborn R. Shaw
C. A Dimmatina B. Kinnear S. Cummings
HF. Tarrant Wakelin, T. Davidson
F. Fraser, Prestigiacomo, Molloy
Fol. Licuria, Lonie, Woewodin
Int. Burns, Scotland, Cloke, Dane Swan

Lookin' good.

 

[ramjet]

i do like the idea of presti at FF. his 1st kick in afl was about 5 metres in front of me, V wce at subi. kicking from 15m inside the boundary about 40 out. out on the full. he's kicked 2 goals since then i think. the improvement warrants a spell up forward.

 

[TheMase]

Originally posted by jabso
B. Didak Lockyer Rocca
HB. Buckley Freeborn R. Shaw
C. A Dimmatina B. Kinnear S. Cummings
HF. Tarrant Wakelin, T. Davidson
F. Fraser, Prestigiacomo, Molloy
Fol. Licuria, Lonie, Woewodin
Int. Burns, Scotland, Cloke, Dane Swan

Licuria will struggle in the ruck.

 

[jefffff34]

Originally posted by jabso
B. Didak Lockyer Rocca
HB. Buckley Freeborn R. Shaw
C. A Dimmatina B. Kinnear S. Cummings
HF. Tarrant Wakelin, T. Davidson
F. Fraser, Prestigiacomo, Molloy
Fol. Licuria, Lonie, Woewodin
Int. Burns, Scotland, Cloke, Dane Swan

Now that's sarcasm.

Originally posted by Ramjet
he's kicked 2 goals since then i think.

Turn it up, he's kicked 3!

 

[Nic]

Originally posted by Hoggy



Turn it up, he's kicked 3!

I thought it was 4...

 

[FIGJAM]

I'll have a serious whack.

B. Johnson, Prestigiacomo, Clement
HB. Lonie, Wakelin, Cloke, Burns
C. Cole, Buckley, O'Bree
HF. Didak, Rocca, Lockyer
F. Tarrant, Fraser
Fol. McKee, Licuria, Woewodin
Int. Betheras, McGough, Scotland, Molloy

Hoping on improvement from Cole who will benefit from actually having a pre-season. Class, speed and hardness at the footy will be just lovely on the left wing with the wonderful HBF - HFF left foot trio of Lonie, Cole and Didak *FIGJAM salivates*.

Lonie showed why he is going to be a star after he recovered from his OP to have a great finals campaign.

Whilst Rogan, the most overrated player in the AFL, will show why he isn't, after he too is over his OP.

Two areas of concern are our ruck strength and lack of depth in our tall defenders.

Otherwise, I think we have a unit capable of another bumper year and hopefully good enough for the next step!

 

[Murray]

Why would a bummer person come over here and ask about our line up.
Does any Pie supporter here really give a chit about the bummers line up.
It must be lonely over there on the bummer board.

 

[Lockyer24]

Johnson Prestigiacomo Clement
Burns Wakelin Woewodin
Lonie Buckley Cole
Didak Rocca Lockyer
Fraser Tarrant Davis
McKee Licuria O'Bree
Molloy Betheras Scotland Cloke

 

[WoeyFanclub]

Clement, presti, cloke
Lonie, Wakes, Burnsy
woey, bucks, obree
willo, Rocca, didak
fraser, tazz, leon/ tarks
cole, scottland, rup, jono

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Originally posted by FIGJAM
I'll have a serious whack.

B. Johnson, Prestigiacomo, Clement
HB. Lonie, Wakelin, Cloke, Burns
C. Cole, Buckley, O'Bree
HF. Didak, Rocca, Lockyer
F. Tarrant, Fraser
Fol. McKee, Licuria, Woewodin
Int. Betheras, McGough, Scotland, Molloy

So Cloke is playing lose man in defence again...

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

I'll have a crack at a line-up:

B Johnson, Prestigiacomo, Clement
HB: Burns, Wakelin, Cloke
C: Woewodin, Buckley, Lockyer
HF: Betheras, Rocca, Didak
F: Tarrant, Fraser, Davis
R:. McKee, Licuria, O'Bree
I: McGough, Scotland, Molloy Lonie

 

[jefffff34]

Originally posted by Nic


I thought it was 4...

Round 17 1998 v West Coast @ VP
Round 18 1998 v Bulldogs @ The MCG
Round 18 2002 v Carlton @ The MCG.

The sad thing is I know that off the top of my head.

 

[FIGJAM]

Originally posted by Kane McGoodwin
So Cloke is playing lose man in defence again...

I think we always play a loose man in defence.

People/commentators seem to notice Clokey more because he is so freaking good at spoiling contests when loose. Many different blokes filled that position upon rotation this year. Clokey is just good regardless.

Your team is very good. But Ryan Lonie is awesome and is a walk up starting 18 player. Be like me sticking Ben Hart on the bench for you guys!

 

[Jabso]

Ok now lets be serious.
FB: Benjamin J, Simon P, James C
HB: Jason C, Shane W, Ryan L
C: Tarkyn L, Nathan B, Woewodin S
HF: Rupert B, Anthony R, Alan D
F: Leon D, Christopher T, Joshua F
Fol: Steven McK, Paul L, Scott B
Int: Glenn F, Jarrod M, Heath S, Shane O'B
Emg (4): Mark McG, Andrew W, Mark R, Richard C

 

[Kane McGoodwin]

Originally posted by FIGJAM

I think we always play a loose man in defence.

People/commentators seem to notice Clokey more because he is so freaking good at spoiling contests when loose. Many different blokes filled that position upon rotation this year. Clokey is just good regardless.

Your team is very good. But Ryan Lonie is awesome and is a walk up starting 18 player. Be like me sticking Ben Hart on the bench for you guys!

Don't normally see sides with 4 players named across HB though. Take your point about Lonie, but with Woey added to your squad, I couldn't squeeze him into the starting-18. BTW, Hart has been a consistently great player for 10 years & is a tier-1 player for us, so Lonie has got along way to reach Benny's standard.

 

[Squeak]

OK this team kicks all your asses...

B: Burns, Prestigiacomo, Clement
HB: Cloke, Wakelin, Freeborn
C: Woewodin, Licuria, Lonie
HF: Betheras, Rocca, Didak
F: Fraser, Tarrant, Buckley
R: McKee, O'Bree, Davis
Int: McGough, Crow, Molloy, Williams

to start with. Crow to take McKee's spot by mid-season and Williams going forward for Buckley who's going to half-back replacing Freeborn.

 

[SkARkS_69]

B:Burns Prestigiacomo Johnson
HB:Cloke Wakelin Clement
C:Lonie Buckley Lockyer
HF:Betheras Rocca Didak
F:Fraser Tarrant Davis
R:Mckee Licuria Woewodin
I:Molloy O'Bree Freeborn Williams
E:Scotland Steinfort McGough

 

[knuckles]

Originally posted by FIGJAM
I'll have a serious whack.

B. Johnson, Prestigiacomo, Clement
HB. Lonie, Wakelin, Cloke, Burns
C. Cole, Buckley, O'Bree
HF. Didak, Rocca, Lockyer
F. Tarrant, Fraser
Fol. McKee, Licuria, Woewodin
Int. Betheras, McGough, Scotland, Molloy

I prefer to focus on negatives.

Cloke - sloppy disposal will hurt again. Very limited IMO
Wakelin - stopper - nothing more. We need more
Fraser - hopefully this year we'll work out what his role his. A poor No. 1 draft pick IMO
Woewodin- don't expect much. He last played with one of the best rucks in the comp. He is about to play with one of the worst. Will give some toe though.
Molloy - Evidence that MM plays favorites. His best was at Fitzroy, has become worse since. Flat-footed, no skills, but does angry faces well. Hopefully his last at the club.
McGough - Does he actually know how to kick a ball?
Tarrant - 3 finals no goals. Down back for him.

Banking on Lonie, Didak, Rocca, Bucks, Obree and Cole ( moves well, disposal poor atm)to get us to the next level.

 

[FIGJAM]

Originally posted by knuckles
I prefer to focus on negatives.

Cloke - sloppy disposal will hurt again. Very limited IMO
Wakelin - stopper - nothing more. We need more
Fraser - hopefully this year we'll work out what his role his. A poor No. 1 draft pick IMO
Woewodin- don't expect much. He last played with one of the best rucks in the comp. He is about to play with one of the worst. Will give some toe though.
Molloy - Evidence that MM plays favorites. His best was at Fitzroy, has become worse since. Flat-footed, no skills, but does angry faces well. Hopefully his last at the club.
McGough - Does he actually know how to kick a ball?
Tarrant - 3 finals no goals. Down back for him.

Banking on Lonie, Didak, Rocca, Bucks, Obree and Cole ( moves well, disposal poor atm)to get us to the next level.

You can focus on whatever you want, but insinuating that we will not/cannot improve internally is more ignorant than negative!

Can see your point on all of those, but at the end of the day, they all contributed very well (except Molloy).

I am tired of having to defend Josh Fraser. Be patient and let him be OP free before writing him off as a "handy forward". McGough will grow up and play the majority of his games in much the same way he did against Hawthorn and Essendon, when he was fresh.