Ziebell vs Sidebottom

[Dave The Man]

Both Highly Rated Inside Mids from the Murray Bushrangers Both Middle 1st Rounders 9 and 11 in the Draft and Both have great skills.

Who will have better Career?

 

[__aria__]

ziebell will have a better career

sidebottom is likely to have an influence sooner and get good gametime from malthouse next yr

 

[hellfire]

I haven't seen either play at AFL level, so I might just wait to comment.

But given that Nostradamus above me knows, I'll go with what he says.

 

[__aria__]

gee hellfire sorry for participating in the thread mate

 

[Dave The Man]

gee hellfire sorry for participating in the thread mate

Yeah I am just asking for an Opinion and That can of course change when they play more at a High Level

 

[smiddaz123]

ziebell will have a better career

Reasons?

Not disagreeing....just wondering what exactly you base this one...

 

[Kaladin Stormblessed]

Well since I am not nostradamus, nor have these two players played a single AFL game, I'm going to with the knowledgeable people, i.e. the recruiters, as to who they rated higher and pick Ziebell.

Tell me I am crazy

 

[Lord_Travis]

i stuffed up. Click Sidebottom but meant to click Ziebell. THe thread title and poll has their names listed opposite! Tricker!

 

[didaka]

Reasons?

Not disagreeing....just wondering what exactly you base this one...

Plays for North could be a possibility

 

[abs_of_STEELE]

Sidebottom, only because I have watched Sidebottom play live and havn't even seen any of Ziebell.

 

[cormick]

Ziebell.
Because he will.
Because he's better.

Good enough reasons?

 

[Mario the Lothario]

Zeibell is bigger, better inside, is a better kick and a better mark.

Sidebottom is quicker.

Does anyone dispute these points?

 

[__aria__]

Zeibell is bigger, better inside, is a better kick and a better mark.

Sidebottom is quicker.

Does anyone dispute these points?

only your last point
if sidebottom is quicker its not by much at all

 

[Silvagnis]

Zeibell is bigger, better inside, is a better kick and a better mark.

Sidebottom is quicker.

Does anyone dispute these points?

Ziebell is quicker by a hair's breath.

 

[Smyth94]

Sidebottom, only because I have watched Sidebottom play live and havn't even seen any of Ziebell.

Didn't they play in the same team in the TAC and Champs?

Zeibell is bigger, better inside, is a better kick and a better mark.

Sidebottom is quicker.

Does anyone dispute these points?

Better kick? If he is, well then it can't be by much

 

[mattty2005]

ziebell will have a better career

sidebottom is likely to have an influence sooner and get good gametime from malthouse next yr

i would have thought ziebell will have an influence sooner

 

[Burzum]

Didn't they play in the same team in the TAC and Champs?

I think Ziebell played a lot of school footy.

 

[__aria__]

i would have thought ziebell will have an influence sooner

yeah u might be right

i made that comment purely on what teams they play for
malthouse tends to give the younger guys a lot of opportunities whereas sometimes laidley does not

 

[DoubleO7]

Zeibell is bigger, better inside, is a better kick and a better mark.

Sidebottom is quicker.

Does anyone dispute these points?

What? Who have you been watching.

 

[Mario the Lothario]

What? Who have you been watching.

This (1:17) -

[YOUTUBE]4jdQMpJ49a8[/YOUTUBE]

 

[BluesMan]

Havnt seen either play, soo i wont bother to vote, both have catchy names as well soo its hard to pick a winner!

 

[smiddaz123]

This (1:17) -

[youtube]4jdQMpJ49a8[/youtube]

Oh you're a youtube scout?

I rest my case.

I could say Sidebottom will be better and show your a video of the TAC Cup Final. But that would be stupid.

Just like you showing me some random goal. Stupid.

 

[__aria__]

yea mariolothario ziebell is a better kick but that is a poor attempt to try and prove it

 

[DoubleO7]

yea mariolothario ziebell is a better kick but that is a poor attempt to try and prove it

My ass he is.

 

[smiddaz123]

yea mariolothario ziebell is a better kick but that is a poor attempt to try and prove it

Oh is he?

Did you find a new youtube video to back this up?

Please link me, it'd be a great laugh.