I see similarities between Holmes and Jordan Clark, I’ve seen them both in action and they both posses amazing leg speed. Putting aside bias, who would you choose? (I’m happy with Holmes btw)
I have noticed we don’t have a player in the top 50 for contested possesions, to solve our clearance...
We have seen a few failed attempts of NRL to AFL but who could go the other way?
Watching Reid today for a split second I thought maybe he would be better at NRL?
Trying to think of others with potential for the switch past or present, maybe Leigh Matthews?, Mcleod (maybe too light?)...
Running through some potential players to achieve 30 in a game and over 9 goals in a game in their career. I can only find these names at the moment and there has to be more. (Seperate occasions not on same day)
Pavlich
Ablett snr
J Cameron
L Matthews
P Daicos
Interested to see peoples all time SOO sides. I will attempt Western Australia pre warning there will be bias to the 1985 and beyond players.
Western Australia
Worsfold Glass D Marshall
Mcpharlin Rance J Mcgovern
Cable Black Matera
J Krakeour Kennedy P Krakeour
Lecras Franklin P Farmer
Cox...
Who do we rate as the top families of all time? I’m just putting this out their for discussion, I’m sure I’ve missed some.
1- Rioli
2- Matera
3- Motlop
4- Burgoyne
5- Pickett
Are Jeff and Polly Farmer from the same family lines?
With some amazing midfields around atm and developing ones as well, who do you rate as the best midfield of all time.
The first few that pop into my mind are
West Coast 2000's - Kerr Cousins Judd Embley and they what they have that alot of others don't is a star ruckman Cox.
Brisbane 2000's-...
The clubs complaining over no game last week and feeling like they are unfairly done by….? Shut up.
I know one team is mine but it makes no sense you are fresh, you are playing a team that has lost Docherty one of their leaders and another that has lost Coleman who is one of the main weapons...
Who would you take from this list of the last 19 years
What team would you pick and not on positions just as a group of players which one would you choose.
Pick 1 Team
D Swallow
M Murphy
B Gibbs
M Kreuzer
J Watts
T Scully
J Patton
L Whitfield
T Boyd
P Mcartin
J Weitering
A Mcgrath
C Rayner
S...
Do the pre season trial players get wages or accomodation etc? It must be quite expensive if young,not working and in the places like Sydney Melbourne for 3 months.
I know this is rubbish but top 5 for first names eg: Peter Gary Tom .
Let’s start off with
Peter
1- Peter Daicos
2- Peter Matera
3- Peter Hudson
4- Peter Knights
5- Peter Bell
Honourable mentions- Peter Everitt Peter Riccardi Peter Burgoyne Peter Featherby
Dean
1- Dean Cox
2- Dean Kemp
3-...
Who is the king of Victoria currently ?
The best player in Victoria?
Petracca Bont N Daicos J Cameron D Martin?
I’d say he’s close on the best,he just won a premiership and the hype is huge because of his age.My number 1 is …
Nick Daicos - He is the king of Victoria right now I’d say - I think...
I saw that Lebron James has played against a total of 35 percent of NBA players ever now which was crazy when I first heard it. The more I thought about it it made sense he has played 21 of around 70 years which is already 25-30 percent of time and he is playing in a competition now with more...
The only stats I could find on left footers was from 2015 and it was 20 percent of the league, I’m guessing similar numbers now??
I can’t name too many “lefties” Brownlow
Medalists from the AFL era though.
Matt Priddis Tom Mitchell Simon Black Paul Couch any others?
A lot of top vote getters...
Who are the best brothers to play the game?
It got me thinking of a couple that I think are underrated but definitely not the best of all time. I find it hard to pick off the top of my head even though I’m sure there are some obvious ones. Below are some that are good and a little underrated in...
I am going to put forward 22- 3 player option picks, decades from 1990-2000, 2000-2010, 2010- present.
choose 1 from each option. I will try and fill positions but may be a bit midfield heavy as all lists are. (not all of the best players as well want some lower ranked comparisions.)
#1- Mick...
Players who were not stars in there career but there top stats are of that level.
My first one is
Jared Brennan
Top Stats
Posessions -31
Goals-7
Marks- 14
tackles-16
Clearances-14
Who else has outstanding top games but never put together alot throughout there career.
Going into 2024 who has the top 5 midfields in our opinions?
My team no where near it but very impressed by some sides depth and top line trios etc.
Some impressive ones are
Port Adelaide- Rozee Butters JHF Wines Boak Houston Drew
Top class midfield with Rozee Butters as good as any combo in...
This is my top 50 off the top of my head for 2024- It will come with large criticism but fair enough! Please post yours as well.
1- M Bontompelli
2- C Petracca
3- N Daicos
4- T Greene
5- J Cameron
6- L Neale
7- C Rozee
8- S Taylor
9- Z Butters
10- E Gulden
11- T Stewart
12- C Curnow
13-Z...
You see the likes of Jamie Elliot even Mark Lecras who are the best you have seen?
my nominations for best under 6ft would be Medhurst Chapman T Greene J Farmer.
I feel like I am missing someone very obvious?
What is the best state 18s side of all time in terms of stock.
I am having trouble finding the teams but I think 2004 WA side would of had-
Franklin, Lecras, M Morton, A Swallow, Toovey
2008 would of had some good ones as well
Natanui Rich Walters S Hill
17
Naughton Allen Taylor Ainsworth
I didn’t know enough about Peter Moore but seeing as he may hand the cup to his son! Moore was captain and played in 4 losing grand finals but managed to win every other award within the club and 2 Brownlow medals as well, but I’m sure he was dissatisfied with not getting the one medal he...
Brownlow top 10 - I haven’t seen many Brownlow threads so hopefully I am not posting in the wrong area.
My prediction is
1- N Daicos
2- C Petracca
3- M Bontompelli
4- L Neale
5- T Greene
6- Z Butters
7- C Rozee
8- Z Merrett
9- C Serong
10- J Dawson
With the Tasmanian team set to be in the AFL in the next few years and there being about 4-5 potential top 40 picks from there and 2 top 10 picks, do you think that teams will lean towards the Tasmanian if it’s line ball knowing that they may have enormous trade value in 3-4 years time when...
It amazes me as I see the game as having a clear advantage with a great ruckmen but the amount of Premiers with average to bad Rick divisions is amazing. Geelong last year Stanley pffft Richmond dynasty no one special, Hawthorn Dynasty no one special, Brisbane no one special.
This year hard to...
Both have been close on the best players in this final series, I am a huge fan of Tom Green and Sam Walsh both have such fierce determination when their sides need them, who would you take?
Which club puts together the best back 6 of all time? Ones that pop to mind are eagles and Carlton but would be interested to know where we rate these lineups.
Geelong would be in my opinion this lineup
Milburn Scarlett Stewart
Enright Taylor Bilcavs
West Coast
Wirrapanda Glass Worsfold...
Thinking with the Eagles what is the maximum turnover or is there one in terms of players?
Shuey Hurn Natanui gone and a couple more that are probably close. They probably want to delist 10 but how many can they?
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.