Fair call but i think we need to give support to cloke.. the games he is beaten in we have no plan B.. he needs help..we have potential crumbers to work with in that area, our priorities are elsewhere, not saying we dont need to address the crumbing area. Good discussion, mate..
Getting a tall will fix alot of the problem cos then we will have someone who can clunk marks, not just cloke. The crumbers or lack thereof are a concern cos the ball is not being marked by tall forwards other than cloke. Elliott, dwyer? Kmartin, fasolo, etc can fill a void. I dont think...
Exactly mate, we need to recruit a key forward to enable reid to go back to defence.. Hard to find but i dont see anyone on our list to fill the void either end
R
Reid is FAR more valuable in defence. Makes Brown better and we frankly have no choice, especially with keefe stil pretty green.. Either way we need a KPF or a KPB..
Like i said mate, we need to recruit a KPF.. Reid and lynch arent the answer.. When u get 3 tall forwards firing the crumbers can consist of elliott (u CAN work on his positioning) and half forward/midfielders - but u have to get ur tall structure right first. Who was our crumber in 2010?
Sick of people mentioning us having to change the culture - it is BS! If the collingwood hierarchy deem Martin would improve our list, and we can afford him, we will have a crack, regardless of his alleged 'behavioural issues'. From what i saw he had a really good year, is always disciplined on...
i respect your opinion, mate, but you cant categorically say he will or he wont... none of us can.. i dont see the harm in enquiring about him though..
not me, mate.. i am all for players trying to get the money they see fit that they deserve... if it means changing clubs then so be it..whether he plays for us or not..
i still think if the players footballing ability fits in with what will help fix our deficiencies then go for him and pay him what we are comfortable with paying him..
if our culture is strong, which i believe it is, it will encourage any ''tools'' to toe the line... but yes, i agree with the...
exactly! and our culture is very solid, people... we lose a few games and finish 8th and all of a sudden our culture sucks? dont buy it.. our culture is very very solid..