Glad someone has said this. I've been saying for a while that something is not right with this team.
-
Welcome to BigFooty.com
- As a user with under 5 posts you may post replies in threads. Go for it!
- After posting 5 times in existing threads and 3 days of membership you gain the privilege of starting a new discussion thread yourself, and sending Private Messages to other users.
Exceptions: You may immediately start new threads in the Suggestions and Feedback board if you have any questions or comments on the site. You can also post in the Introductions Board to introduce yourself.
Dismiss this or any other notice by clicking the 'X' in the top right corner.
-
Weekly Prize - Join Any Time - Tip Round 10
The Golden Ticket - MCG and Marvel Medallion Club tickets and Corporate Box tickets at the Gabba, MCG and Marvel.
Round 9 Winner: philreich
-
Autopsy Round 7, 2024 : Hawks get pecked by Swans
- Thread starter Strapping Young Lad
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Glad someone has said this. I've been saying for a while that something is not right with this team.
Can't we play North every week?
I'll say it again for the slow learners.
Without our best hand full players playing at the top of their game we are no hope of even being consistently competitive.
The rest of the list is C grade (or worse) or too young to have a meaningful impact.
On to the positives from today.
Meek battled hard and is giving his best.
Shammy has slotted in well.
Day got through. Showed glimpses.
Moore, good again. Especially early.
I'll say it again for the slow learners.
Without our best hand full players playing at the top of their game we are no hope of even being consistently competitive.
The rest of the list is C grade (or worse) or too young to have a meaningful impact.
On to the positives from today.
Meek battled hard and is giving his best.
Shammy has slotted in well.
Day got through. Showed glimpses.
Moore, good again. Especially early.
- May 5, 2014
- 6,417
- 12,940
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Melbourne Victory TSM
Was a rough watch, but these are the games you will have with a young list.
It just felt like Sydney’s system and defensive / offensive 50s each were so well drilled, that we bounced off their defensive 50 and ours got ripped apart too easily.
Thought Sammy’s presser was good - much better than the loss to GCS. Summed up how I saw the match a bit too. Gotta stay positive and try and find the little wins.
Fact is we bottomed out and we will have blow outs as our side grows. Our forward 50, like last year, still is a massive issue. But we have some big ins coming back in that space over coming weeks (Lewis, Wingard and Wiz) + a few other good prospects doing all the right things at Box Hill (Dear, JOS and Bennetts)
We will be okay - it’s a bloody young list so we will get beat up a bit on the way. Wouldn’t be the Hawks without a few bumps
It just felt like Sydney’s system and defensive / offensive 50s each were so well drilled, that we bounced off their defensive 50 and ours got ripped apart too easily.
Thought Sammy’s presser was good - much better than the loss to GCS. Summed up how I saw the match a bit too. Gotta stay positive and try and find the little wins.
Fact is we bottomed out and we will have blow outs as our side grows. Our forward 50, like last year, still is a massive issue. But we have some big ins coming back in that space over coming weeks (Lewis, Wingard and Wiz) + a few other good prospects doing all the right things at Box Hill (Dear, JOS and Bennetts)
We will be okay - it’s a bloody young list so we will get beat up a bit on the way. Wouldn’t be the Hawks without a few bumps
The Sam Mitchell coaching honeymoon period is over for me. The Hawks under his reign have the saddest on-field performance I can ever recall ever watching. Consistently smacked, smacked early and very little to get excited about for the future.
The AFL has many recent examples of bringing back playing legends soon after retirement to coach the club and it going very poorly - Voss, Hird, Buckley, even Primus. Now Mitchell is joining them with a bullet.
The list management decisions driven by Mitchell have been inconsistent in terms of age demographic, especially overpaying for a cooked Gunston which is looking worse by the week.
His use of the sub is often puzzling at best and looks to be the tip of the iceberg for his struggles with the tactical side of the game.
He was a superstar player who has given so much to to the Hawks on the field. I just don't believe senior coaching is his thing, at least not at the club where he played.
The AFL has many recent examples of bringing back playing legends soon after retirement to coach the club and it going very poorly - Voss, Hird, Buckley, even Primus. Now Mitchell is joining them with a bullet.
The list management decisions driven by Mitchell have been inconsistent in terms of age demographic, especially overpaying for a cooked Gunston which is looking worse by the week.
His use of the sub is often puzzling at best and looks to be the tip of the iceberg for his struggles with the tactical side of the game.
He was a superstar player who has given so much to to the Hawks on the field. I just don't believe senior coaching is his thing, at least not at the club where he played.
Mitchell is feeling the heat.
He has been a different person in the last month compared to the previous years.
Can one of our ITKs please put our minds at rest and confirm he is carrying?
PLEASE!
Strapping Young Lad
Moderator
- Apr 19, 2006
- 98,030
- 238,296
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Storm, Spurs, Socceroos
- Thread starter
- Moderator
- #183
- Apr 11, 2015
- 4,185
- 5,061
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Cill Chainnigh
We need to work on our weak handballing skills. We handball so much but either the ball falls short or we handball to players in poor positions.
We only have a few players that seem to be able to handball more than a couple of metres and a lot who can’t handball that far.
Kicking for goal is really poor. Our kicking in general is atrocious.
We get the ball inside 50 and don’t score most times. So many times we went to enter our forward 50 and our forwards were outnumbered or not even there..
Our backmen seem to always play behind their opponent and so do our forwards, there seems to be a contradiction in playing philosophy there.
We are either unfit or lazy, we don’t run with our opponents.
We fumble too much, it is one of the major differences between the opposition and us.
Lots of work still to do.
We only have a few players that seem to be able to handball more than a couple of metres and a lot who can’t handball that far.
Kicking for goal is really poor. Our kicking in general is atrocious.
We get the ball inside 50 and don’t score most times. So many times we went to enter our forward 50 and our forwards were outnumbered or not even there..
Our backmen seem to always play behind their opponent and so do our forwards, there seems to be a contradiction in playing philosophy there.
We are either unfit or lazy, we don’t run with our opponents.
We fumble too much, it is one of the major differences between the opposition and us.
Lots of work still to do.
Still just watching the replay (into the last quarter) but what a strange game.
I thought we put in a lot of effort early - high pressure, throwing ourselves at the contest, lots of smothers, etc - for absolutely no reward.
Even at this stage, we are still somehow winning the clearances, the contested ball and even the inside 50s but are 11 goals down.
We lack structure, polish and any kind of target to kick to (which forces us to go round in circles instead of risking it foward).
I thought we put in a lot of effort early - high pressure, throwing ourselves at the contest, lots of smothers, etc - for absolutely no reward.
Even at this stage, we are still somehow winning the clearances, the contested ball and even the inside 50s but are 11 goals down.
We lack structure, polish and any kind of target to kick to (which forces us to go round in circles instead of risking it foward).
f4zz
Senior List
Our backline tallest player is 195cm. Most teams have key forwards 198 to 200+. Our guys are asked to play above their weight week in week out ffs. Play ethan phillips, play two kpfs. Stop handballing in circles. And get rid of our useless forwards coach
it's mind boggling especially when you don't have elite ball users in the middle or the ability to run the ball thru.
Chol was okay, dismal one on one. In his defence like you pointed out that's not his game. He would look better with two KPP next to him. Playing the Ruck/Fwd role. The forward line would function alot better if we had a fit Lewis, Dgb + Chol and a swarm off smalls (Moore,Ginny,Watson,Bruest,Wingard).
- May 4, 2013
- 4,725
- 9,955
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Can't help but think the vitriol thrown at Chol wouldn't be as bad if he was white
f4zz
Senior List
Reminds me of games last year where Fergus Greene was our kpf. Selections have been horrible under sam.
- Sep 6, 2011
- 13,111
- 21,461
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- GWS (Kayo) Also AFL Member so all clubs
Adamant we are better off just kicking it into space in the forward 50 and backing in the smalls to crumb the ball. No point trying to kick to a contest, the ball will just come back over your head.
- Mar 17, 2011
- 2,517
- 4,069
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Everton, Denver Broncos
That was frustrating. Too many senior players taking the wrong option like going inboard at half back to a player under severe pressure instead of the (three!) safe out kicks up the line.
Sicily needs to get back to basics. If Nash isn’t dominating clearances and tackles he doesn’t bring anything else to the team.
Lastly the forward structure was woeful
Sicily needs to get back to basics. If Nash isn’t dominating clearances and tackles he doesn’t bring anything else to the team.
Lastly the forward structure was woeful
- Apr 15, 2013
- 1,845
- 2,947
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Yes, we have serious difficulty turning F50 entries into goals.
- Don't have a real marking presence
- Can't find space to kick to advantage consistently or execute when we do.
- Struggle to convert more than 40% of our set shots
Fixing one of these would get us into games for longer. Chol's free kick was heart breaking, we just can't afford that stuff right, every shot on goal is essential.
- Aug 31, 2008
- 23,997
- 48,737
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Nuggets
He absolute does not deserve it.
I made this point earlier in the year and people jumped all over me. Players who were getting the job done last year simply aren't anywhere near the same standard in 2024.
People wonder about Sicily. IMHO, I feel he's unsure about how he should play the game. I feel the 3-game suspension he received last season for what appeared to be a good tackle in the Brisbane Lions game must be playing with his psyche and confidence. Add to that the lotto the AFL is conducting with player suspensions of late wouldn't be helping him. He knows one false move means certain suspension.
Not sure why others are down on form. I never thought players such as Newcombe would be a problem.
Opposition goals from stoppages is a problem as well, and I hate to think that maybe Sammy doesn't know how to fix this.
Strapping Young Lad
Moderator
- Apr 19, 2006
- 98,030
- 238,296
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Storm, Spurs, Socceroos
- Thread starter
- Moderator
- #195
SSSSSS
Brownlow Medallist
- Apr 18, 2011
- 19,979
- 43,463
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Six decades of domination
We play a game of hot potato with the handballs. No one takes responsibility to find the kick, it's just kick the can down the road to the next guy to eventually cough it up.
If we're going to cough it up at least cough it up deep. Handballing backwards to the next man just means we cough it up higher up the ground and suddenly our defense has it's pants down.
If we're going to cough it up at least cough it up deep. Handballing backwards to the next man just means we cough it up higher up the ground and suddenly our defense has it's pants down.
Ka Norkers
Debutant
little bit tired of hearing how Ethan Phillips should be selected, like he'll be some sort of panacea for our backline woes.
maybe they will play him, but anyone who has watched the BHH games (I have, all of them) will have seen he absolutely leaks goals, and at best, his disposal is iffy. At this stage, at least, but here's hoping his transition to full-time professional will see him improve out of sight in the next year.
If he was selected now, I shudder to think how he'd go.
maybe they will play him, but anyone who has watched the BHH games (I have, all of them) will have seen he absolutely leaks goals, and at best, his disposal is iffy. At this stage, at least, but here's hoping his transition to full-time professional will see him improve out of sight in the next year.
If he was selected now, I shudder to think how he'd go.
- Apr 15, 2013
- 1,845
- 2,947
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
I honestly think we're not playing him to his strengths. His effort is fine, but he's not built for bash and crash forward craft.
sir_jaycee
Team Captain
On top of the execution and decision making skills when the heat is on , which is not AFL standard i have observed the following when watching the boys live at the ground this season.
When bringing the ball from defence , our players always focus on looking at options on the side they are on . Most times they never look at alternative options ( switching ) it’s just a simple look but most times the players don’t do that. Hence we always bomb it long down the line. It’s also predictable to defend against.
They need to have the intent to switch, to keep the opposition on there toes
When defending , flooding back , our last man in the forward line is a tall . It should be our quickest forward , as they will be able to use their speed if we kick long into space to beat the press .
Thirdly , teams counter us with gut running. To counter this we need to counter back , our issue is that we move the ball slowly out of defence therefore allowing the opposition gut runners to recuperate if the counter doesn’t come off. So what is happening is that they counter us and then rest when we have the ball .
If we move the ball quicker after a failed counter against us then the opposition will think twice
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
When bringing the ball from defence , our players always focus on looking at options on the side they are on . Most times they never look at alternative options ( switching ) it’s just a simple look but most times the players don’t do that. Hence we always bomb it long down the line. It’s also predictable to defend against.
They need to have the intent to switch, to keep the opposition on there toes
When defending , flooding back , our last man in the forward line is a tall . It should be our quickest forward , as they will be able to use their speed if we kick long into space to beat the press .
Thirdly , teams counter us with gut running. To counter this we need to counter back , our issue is that we move the ball slowly out of defence therefore allowing the opposition gut runners to recuperate if the counter doesn’t come off. So what is happening is that they counter us and then rest when we have the ball .
If we move the ball quicker after a failed counter against us then the opposition will think twice
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
SSSSSS
Brownlow Medallist
- Apr 18, 2011
- 19,979
- 43,463
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
- Other Teams
- Six decades of domination
Please make him captain already.
Speaks well.
Doesn't do stupid things.
Leads from the front.
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked
