Search results for query: *

Would really like to see Mirra get a run, I think he would be very valuable in the backline.

Will be interesting to see whether David Mirra can slot straight in and play a role for us. A very capable and consistent player.

He will be a midfielder.

Hard for Brand to displace Frawley, and it will obviously be a week to week thing with who they match up with. I think Stratton and Hardwick play slightly different roles. Hardwick is an elite kick and I could see him being used as a rebound defender. If anything, Stratton and Sicily play more...

This is the team, Ashley Browne selected for Hawthorn in 2018: B: Blake Hardwick, James Frawley, James Sicily HB: Grant Birchall, Ben Stratton, Shaun Burgoyne C: Isaac Smith, Tom Mitchell, Jarman Impey HF: Cyril Rioli, Jack Gunston, Ryan Burton F: Luke Breust, Jarryd Roughead, Tim O'Brien Foll...

In: Puopolo, Lovell, Hodge Out: Duryea, Langford, Whitecross

hawks need to not only win this but win this game by a big margin, if we have any shot of getting into the finals we need to up that percentage big time

Would like to see Vickery, O'Rouke and even Wilsmore get a game, all been playing well in the VFL. Birchall out (knee unfortunately) Howe (isn't offering much and lacks composure with the ball) Sicily (is only offering a little bit more than Howe)

L love him, but he looks half the player he once was. Can't jump, looks slow, lacks touch. Unfortunately, he needs a run in the seconds, but I'm not sure that will even help. Maybe everything he has gone through has ultimately ended his football career.

Roughead gone

In: O'Meara (if fit) Out: Howe Also if Birchall is ready to come back, then I reckon Hardwick makes way. Even though he played well, I'm not sure who else you'd drop? Gibson? Yeah that won't happen.

In: Whitecross, Brand, Hartung Out: Stewart, Miles, Gibson Whitecross can win more contested ball and is a good user. Brand because we are getting smashed in contested marks. Hartung because he offers us run. Gibson looks slow, as does Burgoyne, one of them has to go. Stewart and Miles...

Whitecross can win more contested ball and is a good user. Brand because we are getting smashed in contested marks. Hartung because he offers us run. Burgoyne looks slow, as does Gibson, one of them has to go. Stewart and Miles haven't offered anything. Need to use the ball better, O'Meara...

IN: Whitecross, Brand, Hartung Out: Burgoyne, Stewart, Miles

I agree with this, who comes out is the issue. Hodge will obviously come in, but i think you can only really take out two players and them two players in my opinion are Shoenmakers and Duryea. I don't think Shoenmakers offers enough around the ground to warrant his position and I think Duryea is...

Agree, would rather see Sicily go forward and Shoenmakers come out of the team. He is an excellent set shot but doesn't give enough around the ground. Even a Burton for Shoenmakers, that kid has a lot of talent and potential. I agree Duryea out for Hodge

Yeah i am unsure how he fits in the backline with that set up and who he would replace. Needs a year of experience though

I think we need to be playing the young guys like Burton, Stewart, Miles, Brand. In all honesty, we probably aren't going to win the flag this year, would rather play the kids and be looking forward to the next premiership assault in a year or 2.

IN: Hodge, Burton OUT: Shoenmakers, Duryea

In: Hale, Anderson, Langford Out: Hodge (mrp), Hill, Suckling

Chris Yarren to Hawthorn? Could see him having a huge impact at a good club under good leadership. Has huge talent, just seems to need something to play for which he doesn't get at Cartlon.

Is shoenmakers offering enough to warrant his spot? Perhaps an Anderson would offer more. In: Lake Out: Suckling Sub: an impact player/runner.

Irrelevant to the theme of the conversation in this thread but does Hawthorn need to start to think about replacing Clarkson? I know a lot will think this is a stupid question but he has been at the club a long time and with continued talk of Bolton been poached as a senior coach at various...

IMO, Hale is looking very old and slow. He is a better forward but i think McEvoy is more agile and offers more around the ground. Also has a bigger tank.

IN: Lewis, Birchall, Shoenmakers, Langford OUT: Suckling, Howe, Litherland, Puopolo (if injured) if not than maybe Duryea? (Has been playing well though) I think Shoenmakers has done well since he has moved forward and being at the game yesterday it was extremely windy and wet and was probably...

On Suckling, I think he probably still has the best kick in the competition however there is so much that can go wrong with his style which was shown tonight. With Hodge coming back next week i feel he is the most vulnerable, especially if Shoenmakers is staying in the side (which i felt he...

Slightly confused with the line up, naming Frawley, Gus but dropping two smaller players in Anderson, Whitecross. Hartung will probably be sub and that leaves us down on two midfield type players in the starting line up. Surely Shoenmakers will start up forward. Just don't see how this line up...

In: Frawley, O'Rouke Out: Shoenmakers, Whitecross. *only because Whitecross has been sub two weeks in a row. *Anderson out if they are going to start Whitecross.

Shoenmakers for Lake. Anderson for Poppy (If injured) Woodward for Mitchell (If injured) O'Rouke or Simpkin could also be options, Sicely still looks a bit raw for senior footy. Shiels to come back if he is fit. On another note, Langford is defiantly below the standard he set towards the end of...

pretty sure clarko had every right.