Search results for query: *

It will be interesting to compare your last year's trio against our trio of Jackson, Pickett, and Rivers from 2019 in years to come.

You learn more from your losses. This could be a blessing.

Gawn is superior in disposal numbers, he takes 4 times the amount of marks, far more contested marks, plenty more marks inside 50, 8 times the amount of goals, 50% more effective disposals, better disposal efficiency, more score involvements, more intercept possessions, etc. Gawn is a far...

We'll see. It's stupid to make absolute declarations about teenagers. We ''may'' know in 10 years who's better.

Yes, I know he averages one hitout a game. One is a ruck/forward and the other, at best, is a forward/ruck. There's a big difference in their roles. Silly comparison.

Gets confusing with the Hawthorn player.

I'm not sure why you're comparing them. One is a key forward and the other a ruck/forward.

Weightman ahead of Pickett. Interesting.

You said: ''He got top coaches votes vs the dees and had a few BOG earlier in the season.'' When told by another poster this wasn't the case and that no Richmond player received a vote you replied: ''You better check Then.'' I then show the coaches votes for Anzac Eve, which shows no Richmond...

Melbourne vs Richmond VOTES PLAYER (CLUB) 10 Christian Salem (MELB) 7 Christian Petracca (MELB) 6 Jake Lever (MELB) 3 Clayton Oliver (MELB) 2 Max Gawn (MELB) 2 Tom McDonald (MELB)

In this stats obsessed world people seemingly forget to use their eyes. They overlook sheer brilliance. Petracca does things on a footy field few others are capable of. And you'll find that many of the best players in history lead the clangers stat. It's about as useless as they get.

Good God. Curnow actually did something.

It's incredible how this is suddenly ''news'' again.

You have a horrible mind. I wish you had a better childhood.

You don't even realize how silly this post is. They're very different players. Cripps will always be a far better forward, but he won't be a better midfielder. I'm convinced people don't see what Oliver does and get fixated by Cripps size. It's because of Cripps' size I question whether...

Now's the the time nor place. Create a poll if you like. Oliver is a better midfielder than any of those three players. And at 21 he's only going to get better.

We didn't play Carlton twice, Collingwood did.

nah nah

It was an irrelevant game. Just good to have a hit out.

OK

Oliver didn't play. Harmes is no.4. Melksham, May and others mentioned are not ''spuds''.

From my best 22 we were missing: Oliver, Viney, Jones, May, Lever, Melksham, Tom McDonald, Kolodjashnij, and Fritsch. Some might say Hannan. Six of our top 10, like Collingwood. But it's a practice match, so literally nothing can be read into it. Grundy was the most important player between...

It's a horrible opinion.

Hogan = 47 Hogan v top 8 teams - 6 games = 3 contested marks, 8 goals Weideman v top 8 teams - 5 games = 13 contested marks, 8 goals That's no slight on Hogan, I love the guy. They're just the facts. Weideman is only 21, but he's had his first full preseason, has bulked up more, and his 4th...

Firstly, answer my question: what percentage difference is there within the various ratings of the club's draws. Secondly, I made no such conclusion at all. My rankings of the teams heading into 2019 are 1. Richmond, 2. West Coast 3. Collingwood and 4. Melbourne. You're assuming too much. I...

Btw, I've been comparing Melbourne and Collingwood and you've been harping on about ''cherry picking'' and Melbourne having had the easiest draw as stated by CD. Low and behold here's their three easiest positions with regards to the draw. 16. Collingwood +2 - (Made top four) 17. North...

How is showing that two teams, in this case Collingwood and Melbourne, have played the bottom six and the top eight the exact same amount of times ''cherry picking'' ? One of the main reasons our draw was considered easier was Adelaide's fall from grace and we got to play them twice. And we...

I've already shown you that we played the bottom six 9 times and the top eight 8 times, which is exactly the same as Collingwood. We played Gold Coast twice and Carlton once and Collingwood played Carlton twice and Gold Coast once, which evened things out. West Coast played the bottom six...

I have no idea what you're talking about or why you referenced my post. Are you sane ?

Himmelberg and Weideman ? He's a very good player Himmelberg. I think he'll have an outstanding career. He has had an advantage over Weideman in that Weideman was deprived games because of the Tom McDonald/Hogan duo. With Paton being injured Himmelberg was able to partner Cameron and play...