Game Day St Kilda V Dogs 7.30 pm 18/4/2024 Marvel

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Outside contest been ok, but that’s because he’s an outside player. Anything in close he struggles and it’s been evident tonight.

This is why he’ll never be a midfielder.
Absolutely disagree. Ed is exactly what our midfield needs. Pace, power and defensive pressure. He is literally the player we've been praying for in the guts. This is his first game there, so it's far too hard to judge but very promising imo.
 
It's strange watching so many set shots go through the middle.

It’s our new golf based goal kicking methods

Adam Sandler Golf GIF
 

Log in to remove this ad.

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Absolutely disagree. Ed is exactly what our midfield needs. Pace, power and defensive pressure. He is literally the player we've been praying for in the guts. This is his first game there, so it's far too hard to judge but very promising imo.

We’ve seen almost none of those things you listed tonight. Watch the replay, and watch him struggle going against a direct midfielder at each stoppage contest.

He’s a behind the ball, line breaking player and struggles in a 360 degree contest.

He’s played ok because he’s an AA level footballer, but as far as an AFL level mid, that he’s not.

Once Libba’s back, he’ll be back to defence.
 
We’ve seen almost none of those things you listed tonight. Watch the replay, and watch him struggle going against a direct midfielder at each stoppage contest.

He’s a behind the ball line, breaking player and struggles in a 360 degree contest.

He’s played ok because he’s an AA level footballer, but as far as an AFL level mid, that he’s not.

He’s had a half to get used to it at the highest level.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top