Who won the deal? Tarrant vs Medhurst vs Polak

[Pie 4 Life]

I will be simming to the end of their careers just to find out which club ended up with the better player in terms of their needs. That's right, Tarrant is now in the West, Medhurst is now at the Pies and Polak is now at Punt Road. Game by Game I will be showing stats as well as giving 3-2-1 votes to the three depending on who did the best for that week.

Just who could lead their team to the Holy Grail?

 

[Pie 4 Life]

2007 Season Round 1:


Graham Polak vs Melbourne @ MCG, Friday Night: LOSS
6 Kicks, 6 Handballs, 12 Disposals, 8 Marks, 1 Hitout


Chris Tarrant vs Carlton @ MCG, Saturday: WON
9 Kicks, 0 Handballs, 9 Disposals, 7 Marks, 1 Hitout, 6 Goals


Paul Medhurst did not play - LOSS


Votes:
3 Chris Tarrant
2 Graham Polak
1 Paul Medhurst

 

[The Dice Man]

Is Polak playing in defence?

If so how did his opponent go?


Considering Medhurst and Tarrant are both fowards, they're obviously going to earn more votes than a backman, even on a quiet day kicking 2 or 3.

 

[YelloMit]

Go Tazz!

 

[Lonie_from_50]

Taz >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> The Rest

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Round 2:

Graham Polak vs Bulldogs @ TD, Saturday - LOST
13 Kicks, 5 Handballs, 18 Disposals, 11 Marks, 2 Hitouts

Chris Tarrant vs Collingwood @ Subiaco, Saturday Night - LOST
6 Kicks, 2 Handballs, 8 Disposals, 4 Marks, 2 Hitouts, 1 Goal

Paul Medhurst vs Fremantle @ Subiaco, Saturday Night - WON
14 Kicks, 10 Handballs, 24 Disposals, 4 Marks, 1 Goal

Votes:
3 Paul Medhurst
2 Graham Polak
1 Chris Tarrant

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Is Polak playing in defence?

If so how did his opponent go?


Considering Medhurst and Tarrant are both fowards, they're obviously going to earn more votes than a backman, even on a quiet day kicking 2 or 3.

Yes I rate them mostly by how they compare to their team and their opponents on the day.

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Round 3:

Graham Polak vs Essendon @ MCG, Saturday - WON
5 Kicks, 1 Handball, 6 Disposals, 4 Marks, 2 Hitouts, 1 Goal

Chris Tarrant vs Adelaide @ AAMI, Saturday - WON
8 Kicks, 1 Handball, 9 Disposals, 8 Marks, 1 Hitout, 4 Goals

Paul Medhurst vs Kangaroos @ TD, Saturday Night - WON
17 Kicks, 4 Handballs, 21 Disposals, 7 Marks, 1 Goal

Votes: Judging vs Opponents
3 Graham Polak
2 Paul Medhurst
1 Chris Tarrant

 

[YelloMit]

Tarrant did better than Polak in that last game.

 

[RoosterLad]

Polak's opponent may have been left to feed on scraps though...

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Tarrant did better than Polak in that last game.

Nope kept his opponent to one goal and four marks. Tarrant wasn't a star in his team either.