Recent content by combaning

Seeing his reaction last night and the way he looked Phil Davis in the eyes has made him a new favourite of mine. Good luck and go well Phoenix!

Agree. No one in their household looked happy. Especially Mum. Geelong can be hard to let go of. I hope I am wrong, but gee it looked like GWS had killed a family member. Perhaps they are a very serious family and perhaps Tanner is a very serious young man. He might just love leaving home as...

How many first rounders are delisted after 2 years?

Why unrealistic. Most clubs fall over themselves to extend first round picks in first 3 months of players being there. Maybe top 30 are minimum 3 yrs with some triggers. Try being a "why not" person for a week. It would be good for your personal development!

Would prefer O McDonald. 81 games with plenty left in tank. Plug and play when Davis gets injured next.

First rounders should be a minimum 3 year contract with a "non-negotiable" fourth year trigger (e.g. 10 games first year, 25 games by year 2 or 40 games by end year 3). There should also be pay increment or games bonuses in that 3-4 year contracts so young stars are rewarded sensibly for...

I'd prefer Suckling over Savage for depth. Is Cumming up to it? I'd prefer a long-term option there. Ash could develop another year off half back too.

Agree. So if that's the case what are our immediate needs where we can draft and then plug and play? I feel like we are already well balanced. Do we go to draft to go for KPP who know they have to develop in the 2s? Speaking of which where are Flynn and Briggs up to. Surely if they are up for...

What else do you want?

Stop picking first rounders that leave because they don't want to do 2 years development in the now VFL.

Minimum is 37 and maximum 44

Take a deep breath. The sun will rise in the morning and the Giants will be there in round 1 2021. I actually think Cameron out improves our forward structure. We have for years predictably bombed it in to Cameron only to have a 3rd up defender knock the ball away and the balls zips up the...

Add Chaos and Mike to that list

He played for two AFL clubs. Or was it three? He is in the AFL Old Boys Club and uses those networks?

Why don't you tell us in one go instead of having a conversation with yourself?