Search results for query: *

Remove this Banner Ad

  1. P

    Prediction 2026 Best 23 Discussion

    Can’t say I agree with that. I think the players outside the 23 are there for a reason. The bottom 3 or 4 could be replaced without issue but losing too many players in the 12-19 bracket is exactly what cost us in the final against GC. I don’t think our players 24-32 are all that special...
  2. P

    Prediction 2026 Best 23 Discussion

    Difficult to argue with that as they are our best bunch of players however I see the next bunch as the group that determine our finals chances next year: Switta, Wags, MJ, Raz, B Cox, Chapman, McVee, Amiss, Voss If a bunch of these guys step up to support the guys you mention then I think we...
  3. P

    Review Rate the draft and trade period

    Pick swap was poor and still feel dirty we didn’t make more from that but I liked everything else we did. McVee is a good addition and got him at a decent price. I like the drafting strategy addressing the small fwd weakness and initially thought we should also target more mids but I think...
  4. P

    List Mgmt. 2025 Young Talent Time

    Ryan would get a game in every single side, his best is the type of game that helps win premierships. I hope Simpson gets some opportunities next year as I think he has some potential but if we are dropping Ryan for a 5 gamer then we are likely progressing like Carlton did this year. I hope we...
  5. P

    Mega Thread Non-Freo AFL Discussion 2025

    🤮 personally I hate it. I don’t want to see more frees paid, especially ones where I don’t even understand why they are paid. I was just whinging in the other thread about how over officiating has ruined rugby union. I guess channel 7 whinged about games over running and disrupting the...
  6. P

    Resource Non-AFL General Chat

    I simply can’t stand Union, played a bit and understand the rules but it has been ruined by officiating and kicking the ball out of play. Went to the Bledisloe at Optus and the first half was the worst display of “sport” I’ve ever seen. It was basically the ref just giving out penalties. Even...
  7. P

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management

    WC’s worst period looks like 2018-20 where they have played a total of 618 games but still have Kelly, Edwards and Williams on their list. Our 2013-15 cohort have played 603 games with only Pearce remaining. Unfortunately I don’t think the skipper can get us over the line on this one. Solid...
  8. P

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management

    That’s definitely part of it but our offseason antics during the 2013-15 as far as games played are historically bad for a 3 year period (if a stat like that was ever to mean anything). Our 2010-12 isn’t actually that bad. Pretty sure there’s only one team who has had a worse 3 year offseason...
  9. P

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management

    Someone’s paying attention. Unfortunately that’s not you nurries
  10. P

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management

    Here’s an absolutely useless random fact that I could tell to other people and receive some very blank stares. The last player Freo drafted/traded to play 200 games for us was, Nat Fyfe, taken way back in 2009. It’s currently the longest stretch of any team not to produce a 200 game player...
  11. P

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management

    Pearce missed 8 games this year. We went 8-0 in the games he missed. McDonald showed he is decent depth and 3 young guys still developing. Nothing is pointing to alarm bells for kpds.
  12. P

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management

    That’s a positive at least. I’m guessing Brodie’s exit offsets McVee’s addition or thereabouts.
  13. P

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management

    That would surely mean Port take on his salary…well hopefully…well maybe??? Sigh, are probably paying at least half his salary.
  14. P

    Mega Thread Non-Freo AFL Discussion 2025

    Honestly don’t agree with this. Ross is doing what he always does in getting a mature team together but these days it is more sustainable with FA for big clubs. Their additions make them a much better team in 2026 pushing mostly younger guys out of the B23. Those younger guys will now form a...
  15. P

    List Mgmt. 2025 Young Talent Time

    Agreed, our starting line up is good. For depth there’s Duds, Banfield spent most of his career as a pressure fwd, Simpson may struggle for time in the backline so may get more opportunities fwd and that’s before the draft and SSP. Best available for the first pick but don’t mind a slight bias...
  16. P

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management

    I wouldn’t mind some of the delisted AFL small fwds to be given a train on shot for a spot on the list. Lachlan Murphy, Jed McEntee, Lloyd Johnston, Darcy Craven etc. their fitness base should be there and should be able to play a pressure fwd role. Also think our mids need to rotate fwd more.
  17. P

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management

    Everyone is on the phone to Wallsy seeing if he can unlock some more trades with our picks.
  18. P

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management

    I’m not sure Wallsy’s drafting is all that great after pick 40. Aside from Tracey in the COVID affected ‘20 draft his success rate is pretty ordinary. Walker, Western, Tracey, Benning, Worner, Emmett, Knobel, Wagner, Reidy, Murphy, Delean, Jones, Carr, Riddle. Treacy and a couple of borderline...
  19. P

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management

    Brisbane gives up Starvevich, 19 & 52 for 16??? That’s even worse than what we did.
  20. P

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management

    WTF?? So Eagles give up 16 & 23 for Starcevich, 12, 33 & 52 **** me Walls there better be more to this. Edit: 🤮🤮🤮🤮
  21. P

    Welcome Farewell Liam Reidy!!! - Pick 13 In the 2022 Rookie Draft

    Who says Wallsy doesn’t win at the trade table!!!
  22. P

    List Mgmt. 2026 - What do we need?

    Not sure I follow. I get the knocks on Freddy but he kicked 16 goals in our 11 games against the top 9 sides and 14 goals in 13 games against the rest. If anything he’s been better against the top sides than the bottom ones.
  23. P

    2026 Rugby Internationals

    Urgh that first half of Wallabies vs ABs was worst display of “sport” I have watched in a long time. It was literally just the refs paying penalties. I think every point scored was the result of a penalty or not rewarded due to a penalty. Second half was better, despite the AB’s getting on...
  24. P

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management

    Agree with this. We likely throw in R4, F4 or swap pick 48 with 55. Are there any examples where a player of this level has gone for a 1st round pick? Even our own trades of players at this level have been R2’s with random sweeteners. JOM, Aish, Clark all had achieved more or rated higher...
  25. P

    Traded Judd McVee [traded to Fremantle for pick #23]

    Surely our 2nd gets it done with a random sweetener like #65, F4 or swap of picks 47 and 54 thrown in to muddy the waters. Definitely a decent player but not an A-grade mid or fwd. Doesn’t seem to be any examples of a similar type going for a 1st.
  26. P

    Toast Welcome to Freo Michael Frederick – Fremantle’s 4th 2019 National Draft Pick [Pick #61]

    And most of our supporters claim we have the best list in the league. It’s obvious we don’t have the depth of the best sides plus you are forgetting Dempsey and Dangerfield who are probably the best of Geelongs bunch. Freddy is probably our 4th best small fwd and Switta didn’t play 8 weeks and...
  27. P

    List Mgmt. 2025 Young Talent Time

    Exactly. If a market has competition then businesses will need to be innovative to ensure they stay competitive in the market. AFL simply has no competition for sports on this side of the country, so AFL don’t need to care. The rugby league team should be a good thing for competition but WA...
  28. P

    List Mgmt. 2025 List Management

    Random stat but our club has only ever had 4 players to kick 200 career goals for us which is incredibly poor compared to the clubs that started around when we did. Part of it has been trading players away but also trying to trade in goal kickers for huge cost who (apart from Farmer) have...
  29. P

    Autopsy Our bottom Six.

    I count 7 “bottom 6” players who played in the final - NOD, Duds, JOM, Fyfe, Worner, Banners and Freddy (I like Freddy but he’s a limited player). That doesn’t include: Raz - was borderline 23 5 weeks ago and may not be here next year. Amiss - up and down year. Chapman - bit of a nothing...
  30. P

    List Mgmt. 2026 - What do we need?

    Sounds like OMac will be kept and I do like him as depth but we have too many talls and he’s out of contract vs the young KPDs who eventually need some game time.

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom