Search results for query: *

My mother's brother's sister's father says Bont to the Giants is a done deal.

I'm interested, the reason I haven't replied earlier is the "I prefer the idea of people controlling a team different to the one they support" as I'd only be interested in doing the giants, I don't feel my list knowledge is deep enough to be applicable elsewhere. Happy to step aside though if...

1. Brisbane Lions - Luke Davies-Uniacke 2. Fremantle - Cameron Rayner 3. Carlton - Andrew Brayshaw 4. North Melbourne - Aaron Naughton 5. Fremantle - Paddy Dow 6. Collingwood - Nick Coffield 7. St Kilda - Darcy Fogarty 8. St Kilda - Adam Cerra 9. Western Bulldogs - Jaidyn Stephenson 10. Carlton...

Definitely more a Fwd that can play Ruck rather than the other way around, I just glanced at my lists before answering and have him noted as a ruck option :)

Pretty sure Miller, De Koning and Wooller will all get a jumper along with Hayes, CCJ and Crossley, the rest would be most likely rookies if anything

Thread topic is the GWS list manager moving on, followed almost immediately by a thread derailer and then almost every other post in here involve penis measurement discussion. Well done at bringing meaningful and engaging discussion to the board

NFI atm, suspect he could get Wilson's gig, at that rate 18+ would be expected. They are all suspect to injury as well any number of other non talent variables, that's why there are odds and a bookie

I have $10 on Setterfield at $34/1 simply because the price was ridic, Witherden does look like the start line favourite though

This thread feels very 1989, long live the VFL

If Setterfield is longer than $21 I'll be having a lazy $50 on him. Witherden looks the goods though

Don't know enough to comment on why tbh, Club's statement at the time is below, certainly feels like the potential Ablett one, but doesn't mean it is. The GIANTS today confirmed that veteran defender Joel Patfull has announced his retirement from the game effective immediately. In the interest...

It's counted in the cap, and I'm not sure on the discount you mention either. that's why Patful is on our list this year

You are arguing with a noticeboard, there is zero debate intelligence present, best to just use the button BF provide for us to avoid the challenged..

He has a high demand side, but his supply chain is lacking, could be a long wait ;)

Unlike Father/son because that shit has no bias whatsoever

Very true, Sydney HATES losers, just look at the history of the Swan's crowds vs their ladder position

Wow, it's not that at all buddy. It's ONE player on the top 20, ONE, not all the best talent unless there is only ONE, now if there was only ONE no-one would give a shit

Well if we are producing that many and only have priority access for one top 20 player guess who we are growing them for..... Well maybe not freo, but 16 other teams at least :p

Bah, take that back, Anderson was quoting McClure, you could be right :eek:

Agree, he is an unreliable source of everythiung, I think he is quoting or paraphrasing an earlier report by Brett Anderson in this instance

lol, yep, Giant's be devastated :P

If we are not to be worried about cost and draft position is irrelevant, this form may as well shut down

Ducked out for a bit ;)

Your post quoted leagues with significantly less following, why is less good but more bad? Scared? Not even a tiny bit, imagine if the AFL removed the draft now not that this is even remotely likely, kind of hard to think of a club more likely to thrive than those orange guys your nightmares...

Yet vastly more successful leagues like the NBA and NFL do, this feels like something a VFL tragic would come up with

I may have missed it but I don't think any Giant's fan has said that? As far as I know again, no-one here has suggested they should. Again with the not suggested two top 5 picks... You guys should work for the HUN, start your own rumors then publish stories to refute them :)

Two tops 5 picks and I agree, but two top 10 picks and the risk doesn't equal the reward

Yeah, that's what I was getting at, 1 shot with as close as you get to a guarantee of success vs 2 maybes. Word is he will re-sign in very early part of this year thus ending another exodus thread

Mostly I give up at this point, but will persist for clarity, I understand what you saying, but you are vastly overvaluing draft picks. Let's say Carlton finish 14th next year. They have pick 5, their nominal value for the following draft is pick 9 for arguments sake. What you are saying is...

In my perfect world we never get to find out and only time will tell either way, but if he leaves I find it hard to believe we would not get fair value, the only players we have been prepared to give away for less than fair value are those starved of opportunity, this would not be that, this...