Search results for query: *

Yep

Butters got to the ball first?

Far far worse than SSP. 6 plus

Concussed or knocked out?

The AFL have definitely backed themselves into a corner. Anyone knocked out cold, even with no malice, or a broken bone now has to be 5 plus. Next incident will be interesting

Yer that one was s**t to. Name me a Vic one that was rubbish? Struggling to think of one But can name a number of light one suspensions

Maynard? Especially if it's outcome based, not intent How was it a fraction higher than severe? No broken bones, not unconcious etc

Exactly the problem with the AFL or vfl

It'll be consistent for non Vic teams

4 weeks is a joke. This is now the bench mark going forward. Was never going to get a fair go at it given what's happened these last couple of weeks. 2 ok 3 max. 4 is poor. Hope we appeal. AFL making up for the Maynard incident

Regardless of what anyone thinks, the timing of this will make this an unfair case for spp. The media has already gone to town like no other hit of late.

Hits his head very hard on the ground, definitely contributes to the hit. Slung around. 2 weeks.... But being a interstate team and what's happ bed this week. 3 to 4

Definitely 1 week if not 2

intentional, low impact, high = 1 week. do i think it deserves a week, no BUT thats the guide lines. Which can you say it isnt? intentional yep defiantly, low impact yep, high yep. = 1 week i didnt take into big Vic club discount though

agree with that. i based it just on the way the AFL love the impact part of it. careless, high, low impact

the problem is, doesnt matter if you like the call or not, there will be no consistency in the call. itll be just another random call thats made and never paid again. Now he set the president for the day, any out of bounds even if pushed is deliberate if he had any even slight opportunity to...

should have been reversed and a free to marshall. simple easy and the ump was right there. embarrassing that nothing was done at the time. id want a please explain from the ump

shiels was slightly worse. and he got two so 2 down to 1 for ebo

My gripe is the umpire is right there. should have been a free to marshall and a shot on goal.

Glad Johnson got off under the circumstances gaff should think himself lucky that's all that happened to him

delusional.

you should be embarrassed with yourself and your stupidity

whos to say he was? but maybe extenuating circumstances and he gets off completely

lol 6 would be a joke....

high careless medium 1 to 2 weeks rewatched it. low impact fine at worst

I don't think the police will do anything about this. I don't think the Brayshaws will ask them to. I think Gaff will get a whopping football suspension for what he did on the football field. as long as the same lee way can be used by everyone on any football field. a presidency will be set here

long bow to draw between a high tackle and facing someone and deliberately punching him in the face.

so the same excuse can be used for me playing on a sat at my local oval? its ok its just football?

sure was

yer true, its border line either way. but totally different to a punch in the mouth off of the ball, theres no grey areas in it or can argue to much with it etc