Search results for query: *

👀

Id love to know what cogs thinks about the aussie test performance last night and also if he believes the moon landing is fake......

If this does come to fruition, youll have 2 solid picks, id be chasing a KPD hard Aliir is a loan horse down back apart from Rampe, maybe target Serong with the other pick as a replacement for Paps?

We have enough kids, id happily give up our first even if it was around pick 8, papleys a gun, plus has a year to run on his contract. Pay slightly overs if thats what its deemed to be, get it done, move on.

Id say the ankle in round 1, being rushed back only to reinjure said ankle and the shoulder probably didnt help his development last year. Pretty sure there was a thumb operation in there as well, happy to be corrected if thats not the case.

Didnt stop hibberd and melksham choosing Melbourne. They arent the same calibre of player but each has their own motives.

Not sure if gillo has been banished from our backyard but i feel he thinks this is his domain.... has plenty of head scratching moments

Having a laugh

Good to see you haven't entirely deserted the place!

Jesus the barrel scrappers are plentiful here....

The amount on the payslips probably wouldnt stack up either. Also the job as well

There was a bit more to that deal than just picking pies over tiges, list quality etc. id be looking at treloars missus and her current job eddie got her.

Swap the 3rd for a future 2nd and add Marchbank and you've got a deal son.

Clubs up the pointy end of the ladder will pay slightly overs for players the feel fill a specific need. ie Hawthorn. Richmond look to be well and truly on the way so with newman calling it a day and a spot on the hbf opening up id say Yarran would fit in pretty nicely also the fast game plan...

If carlton land treloar ill eat a live cat.

Who has time to cry over Boyd when everyone at carlton is mourning the loss of Waite :rolleyes:

Throwing a million dollars a year at a 20 year old :thumbsu:

Would you want to play for melbourne?

Whole family are as Blue as they come, Boyd was down in the rooms every weekend he could be, Id say the chance to play for the jumper and guaranteed game time would be enough, hes got plenty of years ahead to be in a successful side. I think he would also know how integral he is to Carlton...

Not wrong

He either stays loyal at GWS or he comes to the blues its as black and white as that. Dogs were supposedly in the hot seat for Docherty last with better pick etc etc. Doc nominated us, end of story. Same will happen with boyd.

Gibbs is a better player than frawley everyday of the week, personally though not getting caught up with his draft pick No. And output alone id say end of first round. Spose you can just use frawley as a gauge n youll have your answer, given we are up the same end of the ladder as them also....

Worth an end of first rounder at best. Which is probably what a premiership contender would offer looking for that specific piece of their puzzle. In no world is he worth a pick after melbournes first, and if they award that then ill have lost pretty much all faith in the great game.

Im eager to see how he handles himself when the goals come flowing through at a rate of knots, spitting the dummy and pointing the finger at these youngsters like he does at collingwood will go along way to getting him little respect from the playing group. anyway trade is done so time will...

A player on the decline who has maybe 3 semi-decent years left for someone who is making a serious name for himself and has at least 8 solid years left.... win-win? pfffft please.... To a team in a premiership window shaw would be worth a 1st no doubt, but to a team that simply wants to become...

Ifs, buts, maybes, fact is he isn't and the guy would fumble the moon if he tried to catch it!

Tend to agree, I also think giving up pick #13 was a massive fail! If pick #2 was good enough for md 1 then pick #3 was good enough for md2... All power to you blokes, but I'm baffled and as I said #13 would have gotten you a really good player.

Cameron wood says hi. #14 better a green vest than nothing at all. Lucas, barring injury will be a jet.. Obviously showed more than talia as a junior hence the reason he was picked. Maybe lend Carlton your crystal ball so we get it right :rolleyes:

Touché!

Whitfield, Grundy and Plowman for mine, best mid, best ruck, best backman... Which pushes the mids down a couple of spots :)