1. Fremantle
Kicked ass!! Obviously in rebuild mode and brought in McCarthy. Let's step back and remember this cat. He's brilliant, he's going to be an A+ superstar. Hill, Hamling and Kersten for peanuts too. Only thing they lost was Mayne and well, that's beyond their control and he's probably...
People were critical of Grigg, Houli and Maric when they came through.
Chaplin and Knights have a fantastic opportunity to solidify their position in our starting 22. Most importantly, Richmond have grabbed onto the both of them for peanuts.
Both are not that good.
Dustin Martin + Pick 29-32 for Harley Bennell?
I really really like Harley Bennell...
Caddy and Toy...meh. Would have second doubts giving you guys Angus Graham for Josh Toy.
I won't claim to be a draft expert, however these clubs spring to mind when I consider who did the best.
1. GWS - people claim that more picks means more pressure to get it right...they got it right. I think losing Longer will hurt them in the ruck division, but they picked the cream of the...
Quite frankly he's a cheap get.
I don't consider him a risk whatsoever, he's free and worth a crack.
Things used to work differently for Richmond in the past, trading for players such as Thompson & McMahon hoping they suddenly became jets and we could win a premiership.
I'll give him a go...
Essendon would need to give something to Brisbane to get that Michael Risk compo pick, it's too complicated for Essendon to complete both trades by Monday.
I'm thinking a direct deal with Gold Coast could work, they'll need to give up something good, Essendon supporters are realistic though...
Yes cause the 2004/2005 drafts were recent, weren't they? :confused:
In more recent years we've drafted Riewoldt, Vickery, Martin, Cotchin, Rance, Bachelor & Conca who are all looking promising.
Richmond could have picked up Morris with a F/S selection.
The reason they didn't? Port Adelaide wanted him.
Port were going to make it clear that they would use a 2nd rounder for him, so effectively that makes Richmond have to use their 2nd rounder for Morris.
So what did Richmond do?
They...
To the Carlton supporters underrating Foley, keep in mind we have persisted with him through his injuries and he is finally getting games now, we know how good he can be when he is 100% and next season we will get to see it come to fruition.
Do you honestly think we'll do a straight swap for an...
St. Kilda are entitled to a bona-fide superstar for Goddard, that means pick 1-5 and pick 16-21 (or very decent player).
Anything less and they are getting reamed from behind.
If Richmond were to make an offer?
I'd go with Pick 14 & Compensation pick for Goddard and even that wouldn't quite...
Re: 2011 Trade Predictions - Part II
He is better than 1/13th of Brisbane's list, no offence. :D
Hard nut, good tagger, great endurance, leader around the club.
Of course he ain't perfect, how about Shane Edwards?
Re: 2011 Trade Predictions - Part II
How about
Pick 14, Compo Pick, Daniel Jackson
>
Dangerfield & Maric?
Daniel Jackson is a required player, good player and will add grunt to Adelaide's side, something they would lose if they were forced to trade Dangerfield.
I'd say we are...
These are the picks I would expect as compensation if we lost our players.
More Than Pick 1
Jack Riewoldt
Dustin Martin
Trent Cotchin
Pick 1-5
Tyrone Vickery
Brett Deledio
Picks 5-10
Alex Rance
11- 20
Robin Nahas
Bachar Houli
21-30
Shaun Grigg
Chris Newman
...Hmm its hard to do this, I...
2nd rounder for Lachie Hansen? Shown something, but not enough in 5 years to be worth any more.
Would need to be repackaged by our club into a defender, that's what he played best in juniors and Richo is his idol and barracked for Richmond, so why not?
We get it...
Because Collingwood has a phenomenal structure, great coaches, solid facilities, strong culture and promising young prospects it means we can overrate individuals who have been trained by the best to play a good role.
You saying Ben Reid is the best makes me think Neeld...
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.