Search results for query: *

Fremantle was the most competitive on the day but I think the Swans were definitely the best outfit - they had a bad day though. Swans were consistent throughout that 2012-17 period, always a top 4 side. Unlucky not to have 2 or possibly even 3 flags.

Always rated Gibson highly. Hate hawthorn but like him, he was my favourite player from the Hawks. Ultra consistent, very underrated. Would take him. Mal Michael was great though.

A classic sign youve lost the argument and dont know what to say. good riddance

where did I call him ordinary? I'm not denying Martin is a good player - hes a very good player - but to compare him to Judd who trumps him completely is ridiculous. Recency bias is out of hand in the AFL community. They quickly forget. The current day best player for some reason is considered...

you have not watched many chris judd games. Comparison of their career achievements Martin Judd If you ask me, Martin has been a top 5 midfielder in this league for at most 4 seasons. 3 all-australians just proves that...

hes either better or he isnt. He may be slightly better, but 90% can still agree on that. % of votes on the poll isnt an indicator of HOW MUCH better he is, just that he IS better

Its not even a conversation. Judd is the 2nd best mid of the 2000s behind GAJ and Dusty isnt a top 10 mid of the 2000s. Judd was a top mid in the comp for a decade, Dusty kind of broke out in 2016 when he started winning awards but before that he was simply a very good player, nothing more.