Search results for query: *

Yeah, tough one to pick tonight. Thinking Sydney in a close one.

Umpiring review revival time. Nah, back to 2023 match replays instead.

Caught up on reading the thread. Great win, time to watch the replay...of the season.

They were at the ground. Even less of an excuse, Hamish just gets caught up in his prepared soliloquies and commentating the play is an afterthought.

Cheers, yep he is where he shouldn't be, or very close to it, for sure! I recall an instance on the far wing Noble running past side of player/mark, no Ess player close by and thought, gee he must be close to the protected zone (likely would have been paid a few years ago...), so let's say both...

Front on contact, certainly could have been some I missed. Technical and annoying for sure, especially as all those paid in this game were so minor. I just watched this a few times, no issue with ball up for me. He was tackled immediately and was attempting to dispose I feel. Yes he managed to...

Posted my review in the post game thread before seeing this thread. Spot on, some notes relevant to your post:

Suggested other endeavours didn't pan out so I'm back to an umpiring review like round 1. Round 1 there was some talk of bad umpiring and Geelong getting the advantage, not consensus opinion though. My review didn't show any major disadvantage to us. This time though, seems an overwhelming...

Rather than just talk about a select few decisions, let’s discuss them all! Or just move on to the Port preview thread, to each their own. Q1 Geelong free – holding the man. Fair call. Collingwood free – high contact in ruck contest. Stanley clumsy. Fair call. Geelong free – Adams holding...

Nice win and thanks for the memories Bucks!

Lucky there is no "No umpiring complaints during game." rule for this thread!

Saintly Viewed - De Goey frizzle - Elliott Copeland - Stephenson Moeydw - Beams magpie_marty - Beams Ingy - Elliott Ppoiter - Mihocek caloschwaby - Stephenson AD2010 - Elliott reggie - Elliott Hong Kong Pie - Stephenson Morganashlee - Elliott Pedro - Stephenson Sr36 - Phillips lyfsux -...

Agreed. At one stage one of them commented on how loud the crowd was or the atmosphere or something. I thought that's great, pity we can't hear it!

Don't think any other team could pull this outfit off, good work Carlton!

Why do only some players have the patches on the back of the shorts and others don't? And some are even different shades of grey?

Why is Dangerfield not wearing the orange socks?

Did the man on the mark give him an extra 8 metres for any reason there?

Haha nice commentary on the Hogan goal by Hamish: "from just inside the arc... its got....urghh" Did I hear that right?

Who knew the score review was a father and son setup?

In as Avatar

Yeah same, don't see much VFL. Some people talked him up perhaps too much leading to unrealistic expectations but I really think he can be a damaging, impactful HFF.

Rob's will always have the best burgers!

What a goal in the 3rd. So glad to have a player in the team to have the confidence to do that.

We've always known he has it. Seemed quite composed today. Get some consistent games and he's a HFF lock

;) All good.

I thought White did ok in the ruck, at least in the centre bounces.

My one tip against Collingwood that year, actually ever! Still managed to win the tipping that year, never tipped against us since!

My memory is quite bad so was just going off search results. 2015 then?

I thought he was going to kick it out on the full! I've got no idea!