BigFooty Geelong Board Team Of the Sesquicentury - Part 2 (Player Nominations)

Remove this Banner Ad

May 11, 2006
16,589
3,993
On the Outer
AFL Club
Geelong
Other Teams
Chicago Bulls, Aussie Swim Team,
OK before you ask sesquicentennial means 150 years.


To Celebrate the 150 year Anniversary (sesquicentennial) of the club let's put together the best team of players to play in that time.

This will happen in 4 parts:

1). A selection of a committee of posters to determine the final team from your nominations.

2). Poster contribution. Suggest some players or even make your team of players. The criteria is a regular team, 4 on the bench, 4 emergencies, Coach. Capt, Vice Captain, 1 Assistant Coach

3). Once everyone has discussed it to the hilt the committee will sort out the final selection

4) Announcement with me doing a special poster on Photoshop for everyone to download and print out and hang on the wall and a Desktop wallpaper for you to use on your PC

Part 2 Player Nominations

nominate single or multiple players or even a whole team.

Make sure you back up your nominations with good reasons
 
Re: BigFooty Geelong Board Team Of the Sesquicentury...Part 2 (Player Nominations)

kellykellykelly post in the other thread

Buddha, in the guts, lock in.

a few stats!

Played 274 games, kicking 243 goals for Geelong, 1987-2001
Played in 21 finals, kicking 21 goals
133 career Brownlow Medal votes
Geelong best and fairest 1991, 1993-94, 1996
State representative on eight occasions - Victorian Captain
All-Australian 1991, 1993-94, 1996
Geelong Captain 1995, 1999
Geelong Team of the Century
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Re: BigFooty Geelong Board Team Of the Sesquicentury...Part 2 (Player Nominations)

Maybe that Ablett bloke.

I think he kicked a few goals.
 
Re: BigFooty Geelong Board Team Of the Sesquicentury...Part 2 (Player Nominations)

It's probably worth reposting Geelong's team of the century, to get an idea of who was in the running:

TeamoftheCentury_620px_v1.jpg
 
Re: BigFooty Geelong Board Team Of the Sesquicentury...Part 2 (Player Nominations)

Well, I'll assume Ablett Snr is a given so...

I'll pump for Bernie Smith

West Adelaide Best & Fairest 1947
West Adelaide Premiership 1947 (BOG)
Brownlow Medal 1951
Geelong Carji Greeves Medal Best & Fairest 1951, 1956
Geelong Premiership 1951, 1952
Geelong Captain 1950, 1954
South Australian rep 1 game
Victorian rep 4 games
All Australian 1953
Named in both Geelong's and the AFL's official 'Team of the Century'
Inducted Australian Football Hall of Fame 1996

* A centreman during his career with West Adelaide as well as during the early part of his VFL stint with Geelong, Bernie Smith is remembered as one of the greatest back pockets in the history of the game. Moved to the back pocket by coach Reg Hickey in 1951 he went on to win both the club best and fairest award and the Brownlow Medal that same season, while for good measure he was among the Cats' best in their grand final defeat of Essendon.

Smith was ideally suited to a back pocket because he was pacy, had good ground skills, marked well, was always cool under pressure, and had superb judgement. Opposition coaches came to view him as Geelong's first line of attack, and in what was a virtually unprecedented move for the times he was often subjected to what would now be called tagging.

Bernie Smith played 55 games with West Adelaide winning a best and fairest award in that club's premiership year of 1947. He won 2 best and fairest trophies during 183 games with Geelong, played in 2 premiership sides, and was club captain for part of 1950 and the whole of 1954.


* http://www.fullpointsfooty.net/SAToC_backs.htm
 
Re: BigFooty Geelong Board Team Of the Sesquicentury...Part 2 (Player Nominations)

Cant go past 1989 Brownlow winner, Paul Couch...

Games: 259 (18 finals)
Goals: 203

Big 'V' guernseys: 5 times
Club B & F winner: '86, '89 and '95
All-Australian: '89, '91 and '92

Named on the pine for the Geelong team of the century

Get him in there!
 
Re: BigFooty Geelong Board Team Of the Sesquicentury...Part 2 (Player Nominations)

Got curious about Joe Slater, ferreted around for some information. Here is one description:

Originally from United Methodists in the Church Union Association, Geelong utility Joe Slater was considered to be one of the foremost players of his day, and was named on a half back flank in the club's official 'Team of the Century'. Strong overhead, and boasting phenomenal pace, he was capable of performing effectively as a forward or across centre, but it was as a defender that, by common consent, he played most of his best football. Between 1906 and 1914 Slater played a total of 108 VFL games, and kicked 17 goals. He represented the VFL twice. Having quit football in order to enlist, he lost his life while serving his country in World War One.

Did some further digging and found his service record here. Captain Joseph Henry Slater, 22nd Battalion AIF. A bout of tonislitis prevented him from joining the battalion on Gallipoli; having recovered, he was gazetted captain and rejoined the 22nd in February 1916. Was mentioned in despatches for 'distinguished and gallant leadership in the field' in November 1916. He was killed in action on the 3/5/17, when the 22nd was part of the unsuccesful second attack on Bullecourt.
 
Re: BigFooty Geelong Board Team Of the Sesquicentury...Part 2 (Player Nominations)

matthew scarlett would have to be a good chance.
 
Re: BigFooty Geelong Board Team Of the Sesquicentury...Part 2 (Player Nominations)

Hickey, Reg

VFL Playing Career Statistics
Clubs: Geelong
Games: 245 (14 finals), Goals: 24
Born: Tuesday, 27th March, 1906
Debut: Saturday, 5th June, 1926 20 years, 70 days vs Richmond (Rd 6)
Last Played: Saturday, 18th May, 1940 34 years, 52 days vs Richmond (Rd 4)
Premierships: 2 (1931,1937)

Coached from 1932-1959 (inc. Captain/ Coach), won 2 more premierships (1951-52)
60.69% winning record
 
Re: BigFooty Geelong Board Team Of the Sesquicentury...Part 2 (Player Nominations)

Peter Riccardi

Without doubt one of the pre-eminent Geelong footballers of the 1990s, Peter Riccardi, who joined the Cats from Geelong West-St Peter's, would almost certainly have enjoyed premiership success with the club had he counted another two or three players of similar energy, passion and skill among his team mates. As it was, he played in a losing grand final against West Coast at the end of his debut season of 1992, and went on to do so twice more during a career encompassing 288 games over fifteen seasons. Boasting exhilarating pace and a pounding left foot kick, Riccardi was capable of changing the course of a match with an explosion of brilliance. He slowed down as his career went on, but became more adaptable, and arguably a better player all round. Had he a touch more consistency to his game he would have been universally acclaimed as a champion. Individual career highlights included three top three finishes in Geelong's best and fairest award, including a win in 1998. Former club great Bob 'Woofa' Davis said of Riccardi after the player announced his retirement in 2006, "I think Peter has been a magnificent player for the Geelong Football Club and I'm positive that every one of the teammates he's played with would regard him as one of the best players they played with".

http://www.fullpointsfooty.net/r.htm#Peter Riccardi (Geelong

Games: 288 (including 19 finals)
Goals: 286
Debut: Round 4, 1992 v West Coast
Last game: Round 19, 2006 v St.Kilda
3rd most games for Geelong (behind Ian Nankervis and Sam Newman)
12th most goals for Geelong
B&F winner 1998
GFC Hall of Fame member
Member of the VFL/AFL Italian team of the century
60 career Brownlow votes


 
Re: BigFooty Geelong Board Team Of the Sesquicentury...Part 2 (Player Nominations)

I'd love Reg Hickey to be our coach... Can someone be coach and play in the team?
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Re: BigFooty Geelong Board Team Of the Sesquicentury...Part 2 (Player Nominations)

I'd love Reg Hickey to be our coach... Can someone be coach and play in the team?

I would like to think that as well, but my ideal Coach/ Captain/ Vice Captain would be:

Mark Thompson as coach, Reg Hickey as Captain, and Bill Goggin as VC
 
Re: BigFooty Geelong Board Team Of the Sesquicentury...Part 2 (Player Nominations)

Doug Wage - Top 5 goal kicker, can't go past that

Matthew Scarlett - possibly the best defender ever let alone that Geelong has had

Sam Newman - 300 game star, second best ruckman we have had behind Farmer
 
Re: BigFooty Geelong Board Team Of the Sesquicentury...Part 2 (Player Nominations)

Couple of other nominations:

Alistair Lord:

Geelong's 1962 Brownlow Medallist Alistair Lord was an effervescent, attacking centreman who was continually in the thick of the action. The Cats procured him from Cobden and he made his league debut in 1959, often alternating during the early phase of his career between a half forward flank and the pivot. During his Brownlow year he averaged 30 disposals a game and finished 9 votes clear of his nearest rival. Not surprisingly, he won Geelong's best and fairest award the same year. Lord was in the centre when the Cats beat Hawthorn in the 1963 grand final, but his form after that became patchy as he seemed to lose his motivation. He retired in 1966 after 122 VFL games. He also represented the VFL on 8 occasions.

Games: 122
Goals: 79
1962 Brownlow Medallist
1962 Carji Greeves Medallist
VFL Guernseys: 8

James Wilson:

A former jockey who once rode in the Melbourne Cup, James Wilson roved for Geelong with great talent and ebullience during the late 1870s and early 1880s. His high status and enormous ability were emphasised by his being voted Champion of the Colony on no fewer than three successive occasions from 1880 to 1882. Geelong was very much the pre-eminent team in the VFA during Wilson's career, winning half a dozen premierships in the seven years between 1878 and 1884. James Wilson's brother William, another former jockey, also played for Geelong with great distinction for several years.
 
Re: BigFooty Geelong Board Team Of the Sesquicentury...Part 2 (Player Nominations)

The Lords were very stiff to not get a starting gig in the GFC Team of the Century IMO, Alistair especially.
 
Re: BigFooty Geelong Board Team Of the Sesquicentury...Part 2 (Player Nominations)

I think the fact he played only 122 games counted against him. But was a great player nonetheless.

Michael Turner:

Michael followed in the footsteps of his father Leo, a great player for the Club and selected also in this team in the other wing position. Michael was recruited from Warrnambool, and immediately set about demonstrating his exceptional ability, fast, skilful, and a courageous dasher, his explosive pace often showing a clean pair of heels to his opponents with the skill to run from the packs at full speed, finding space and bouncing the ball two or three times before driving the ball either deep into the forward line, or through the goals. To watch both father and son playing in the same team with their style of play complimenting each other would be a supporters delight.

Club Captain from 1984-6
Represented Victoria 11 times
All-Australian in 1979
Geelong team of the century
 
Re: BigFooty Geelong Board Team Of the Sesquicentury...Part 2 (Player Nominations)

Ian Nankervis anyone??? Games record holder, rep footy, and the list goes on....
 
Re: BigFooty Geelong Board Team Of the Sesquicentury...Part 2 (Player Nominations)

Why dont we do a team of players/ coaches who left Geelong to go onto mediocre/ crappy careers with other clubs??

Feel free to do that in another thread. Although it has been done before so you should try doing a search.

But if anyone wants to try and turn this thread into a joke then be prepared for getting an infraction. Last and only warning.
 
Re: BigFooty Geelong Board Team Of the Sesquicentury...Part 2 (Player Nominations)

I'd like to nominate:

Edward 'Carji' Greeves

A natural sportsman, Edward Greeves excelled at cricket, tennis and rowing, but most especially at football. Geelong wanted him to line up for them while he was still at school, but the school authorities refused to allow it. He had to wait until 1923 to make his debut, quickly developing into one of the most eye-catching centremen in the game.
The prime reason that Greeves was so eye-catching was his kicking style, which was said to be one of the most classically perfect ever seen. Schoolboys all over Geelong would practise for hours trying to emulate it. Moreover, in an era when genuinely two-sided footballers were the exception rather than the rule, Greeves could kick with either foot with almost equal facility and expertise.
In 1924, the twenty year old Greeves' career blossomed when he was selected to represent the VFL at the Hobart Carnival and, of course, won the inaugural Brownlow. With his elegant style of play ensuring that he always caught the umpire's eye, Greeves also later ran second in the Medal on three occasions in an era when only the best player afield received votes.
In 1928, well over half a century before Darren Bennett, Greeves spent nearly seven months in the USA, four of them as kicking coach for the University of Southern California's gridiron team, the Trojans (and not the University of South Carolina, as many sources wrongly suggest). Although he was not the first Australian footballer to have an impact on the American game - that honour resides with Pat O'Dea - he was the first such footballer to be deliberately 'head-hunted' by the Americans, and the first to travel to the USA for purposes specifically and exclusively to do with gridiron. While in California, Greeves was reportedly a great success, earning a gold medal for his services, and was indeed offered the opportunity to remain, but the 1929 VFL season saw him resuming his career with the Cats, for whom he went on to play a total of 137 games in eleven seasons, with premierships in 1925 and 1931 the highlights.
Other noteworthy features of Greeves' football career include the facts that he never wore proper football boots, preferring ordinary boots of very soft leather, and he played the entirety of his VFL career as an amateur.
Once his VFL career was over, Greeves maintained his involvement in football by coaching first Warracknabeal, and later Ararat. His importance in the history of the Geelong Football Club was highlighted in 2001 when he was included, as centreman, in the club's official 'Team of the Century'. The Cats' annual best and fairest award is currently named in his honour.
Source: Devaney, J. 2009, Edward Greeves (Geelong), viewed 29 April 2009, <http://www.fullpointsfooty.net/g.htm#Edward%20Greeves%20(Geelong)>
 
Re: BigFooty Geelong Board Team Of the Sesquicentury...Part 2 (Player Nominations)

It's fair dinkum unbelievable this guy hasn't been nominated yet....

Bobby Davis

Debut: 1948
Retired: 1958
189 games
149 goals
B&F in 1957
Coach of Geelong 1960-1965
Premiership coach 1963
Premiership player 1951-52
Captain of 1958 All-Australian side
Member of Geelong team of the century
 
Re: BigFooty Geelong Board Team Of the Sesquicentury...Part 2 (Player Nominations)

May as well toss a few names out there.

Bruce Morrison
Gary Malarkey
Roy West ........ three candidates for the full back position along with Scarlett.

Also ......

John Hyde
Denis Marshall
Peter Walker
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top