2015 AFLCA Votes

Remove this Banner Ad

Seppo said:
RICHMOND V FREMANTLE
9 – David Mundy (Frem)
8 – Troy Chaplin (Rich)
4 – Brandon Ellis (Rich)
3 – Michael Barlow (Frem)
2 – Shaun Grigg (Rich)
2 – Kane Lambert (Rich)
1 – Stephen Hill (Frem)
1 – Matthew Pavlich (Frem)
Click to expand...
Some strange voting going on there.

5 - Chaplin (coach #1)
4 - Mundy (coach #1)
3 - Barlow (coach #1)
2 - Grigg (either coach)
1 - Pavlich (either coach)

5 - Mundy (coach #2)
4 - Ellis (coach #2)
3 - Chaplin (coach #2)
2 - Lambert (either coach)
1 - Hill (either coach)

One of the coaches somehow didn't give Mundy the 3 votes, and completely forgot about Ellis...then gave a BoG to Troy Chaplin!! :confused:
The other gave two of Grigg/Lambert/Hill/Pavlich votes ahead of Barlow.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

The discrepancies in voting is usually because of players roles. Ross may have given Ellis 4 but if he failed in a task that Hardwick set, and Ross did not notice he had that task (obviously as he failed at it!) Hardwick gives him none.
 
Fremantle vs GWS
7 Mundy (Frem)
5 Neale (Frem)
5 Sandilands (Frem)
4 McPharlin (Frem)
4 Walters (Frem)
2 Hill (Frem)
2 Treloar (GWS)
1 Cameron (GWS)

Weird set of votes again. Seems the coaches were divided once again. I can't seem to figure them out.
 
100 Nat Fyfe (Frem)
85 Dan Hannebery (Syd)
65 Todd Goldstein (NM)
65 Matt Priddis (WC)
60 Andrew Gaff (WC)
56 David Mundy (Frem)
55 Scott Pendlebury Coll)
53 David Armitage (St K)
53 Trent Cotchin (Rich)
53 Josh Kennedy (Syd)

Mundy jumped into 6th place now :thumbsu:
 
electricfeel said:
Fremantle vs GWS
7 Mundy (Frem)
5 Neale (Frem)
5 Sandilands (Frem)
4 McPharlin (Frem)
4 Walters (Frem)
2 Hill (Frem)
2 Treloar (GWS)
1 Cameron (GWS)

Weird set of votes again. Seems the coaches were divided once again. I can't seem to figure them out.
Click to expand...

Reginald Perrin guess they didn't watch the game. Or perhaps coaches really rate clearances.
 
Last edited:

(Log in to remove this ad.)

ydraw said:
Reginald Perrin guess they didn't watch the game. Or perhaps coaches really rate clearances.
Click to expand...
Actually just one coach! One of the most bizarre set of votes when two players get 5 from one coach and none from the other.

4/3 Mundy
5/0 0/5 to Sandi and Neale
1/3 and 4/0 McPharlin/ Walters
2/0 0/2 Hill and Treloar
And Cameron with the final vote.
 
Frank J Moose said:
Actually just one coach! One of the most bizarre set of votes when two players get 5 from one coach and none from the other.
Click to expand...
I found this a difficult game to vote overall. And coaches probably take into account things like how their pre-planned matchups worked and probably don't pay too much attention to who to give votes to as they have more important thing to do during the game...
 
Schauermann said:
I found this a difficult game to vote overall. And coaches probably take into account things like how their pre-planned matchups worked and probably don't pay too much attention to who to give votes to as they have more important thing to do during the game...
Click to expand...
Leon Cameron was probably too busy running up and down talking to the 4th official that he missed most of the game!
 
Frank J Moose said:
Actually just one coach! One of the most bizarre set of votes when two players get 5 from one coach and none from the other.

4/3 Mundy
5/0 0/5 to Sandi and Neale
1/3 and 4/0 McPharlin/ Walters
2/0 0/2 Hill and Treloar
And Cameron with the final vote.
Click to expand...

Is the split of voting between the coaches published somewhere or are you just having an educated guess?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Nothing
2024 AFLCA votes
Replies
2
Views
331
pK75
pK75
Nothing
Freo AFLCA votes 2023
2
Replies
38
Views
3K
King Tenz
King Tenz
Bud
Coaches Votes round 2
Replies
7
Views
300
Bender571
Bender571
Snuffaluphagus
MVP Rd 20 Votes vs Melbourne @Home
Replies
12
Views
496
FDH16
F

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top