Shermanator
Confidence Coach
- Mar 23, 2001
- 15,331
- 48,948
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Wildcats/Pacers/Chelsea/Scorchers
They’re cok smokers
Review 2023 National Draft Review Thread II [McKercher, Z.Duursma, Goad, W.Dawson, Hardeman, Maley]
- Thread starter giantroo
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Shermanator
Confidence Coach
- Mar 23, 2001
- 15,331
- 48,948
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Wildcats/Pacers/Chelsea/Scorchers
Dan
[__]
North Melbourne - 2018 Luke Davies-Uniacke and Paul Ahern Player Sponsor
North Melbourne - 2017 Junker and Wagner Player Sponsor
North Melbourne - 2016 Daw & Anderson Player Sponsor
North Melbourne - 2015 Daw & MacMillan Player Sponsor
North Melbourne - 2014 Daw, Black, Gibson Player Sponsor
North Melbourne - 2013 Daw, Black and Gibson Player Sponsorship
North Melbourne - North 2012 Player Sponsor
North Melbourne - North 2011 Player Sponsor
- Mar 21, 2010
- 26,374
- 43,289
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Bali 6's, Dorothy Mantooth
For like an hour maybe 2.
You lot.....like seagulls to a chip.
The Talent Scout
Team Captain
- Nov 12, 2023
- 519
- 1,109
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- west adelaide fc
So funny, with all the interviews, people jet-setting around, talk of this player and that player, no one knows who's getting who! The Hawks are the same, they want this player/that player, that player won't get to us, its like DAYS OF OUR LIVES. Plus still Saturday and Sunday to go! You've gotta love it!
Im happy to be proven wrong.
Apologies if I've missed the program - several mock drafts show us taking Riley Hardemann. If we're using our latter picks to plug gaping holes in our list, why would we select a medium defender?
Kanga Glory
Premium Gold
North Melbourne - 2024 Hugh Greenwood Player Sponsor
Veteran
North Melbourne - 2023 Aaron Hall and Flynn Perez Player Sponsor
North Melbourne - 2022 Aaron Hall and Flynn Perez Player Sponsor
North Melbourne - 2021 Taylor Garner and Flynn Perez Player Sponsor
North Melbourne - 2020 Taylor Garner and Flynn Perez Player Sponsor
North Melbourne - 2020 Aileen Gilroy Player Sponsor
Read Today's PaperTributes
7:20am Saturday, November 18th, 2023
Rewards
Melbourne
11 °/ 20 °
Hi, Peter
Jay Clark and Sam Landsberger
less than 2 min read
November 17, 2023 - 10:08PM
News Corp Australia Sports Newsroom
4 comments
Will the Eagles blink and trade Harley Reid away? Who gets the draft’s best tall Dan Curtin? Who will be the bolters and the first round’s biggest sliders? Jay Clark and Sam Landsberger reveal all in their definitive Phantom Draft.
Scroll down to see who your club will land.
DRAFT INSIDER: THE PLAYERS LINKED TO EVERY CLUB
FINAL PHantom draft
Powerful, confident, country kid certain to go No.1. Sound like anyone? Luke Hodge, perhaps? Except ‘Hodgey’ was never this famous as a teenager.
Why?
Unless the Roos fold and fork over picks No.2 and 3 for Reid then he will be the centrepiece of the Eagles’ rebuild. Does Ben Cousins’ No.9 jumper await?
2
Freakishly athletic key forward the first of three academy gifts for Dimma’s Suns. Plenty
of Charlie Curnow in this kid.
Why?
Surely North Melbourne, like most clubs, has Walter ranked a clear No.2 on its talent board and bids here. Questions will be asked if not.
3
Rates his work in the kitchen, but it is his class and precision on the grass that has him a lock to land at Arden St.
Why?
It’s simple. He is the best midfielder behind Reid, and arriving 12 months after Sheezel and Wardlaw arms Alastair Clarkson with three bankable beauties to
transform this club.
4
Brother of Essendon recruit Xavier Duursma is deadlier than a bow and arrow in front of goals.
Why?
Going small again because Duursma is too damn good. Will target talls at picks 15, 17 and 18. Suspect Duursma for Ben McKay (this was the compensation selection) will wind up looking OK for the Roos.
5
‘The Wizard’ weaved through 70 goals this year. Yes, 70. Remarkably agile, speedy and downright devastating in front of the sticks.
Why?
The Hawks need a key defender and they just picked up a small forward in Jack Ginnivan. But Watson’s magic will be irresistible and you wonder whether the struggles of Denver Grainger-Barrass (No.6 pick in 2020) might spook them from taking Curtin.
6
Has looked like he was ready to rock at AFL level for two years now. The Tasmanian (he boards at Melbourne Grammar) is a tough onballer with ticker.
Why?
Did the Dogs trade up to this pick to secure Watson? Probably. But they won’t be too disappointed because Sanders is a safe bet and they suddenly need to replenish what has become an ageing midfield.
7
Classy outside ball user could blossom like Hugh McCluggage. Speed and agility in spades.
Why?
Melbourne need to sharpen the sword going inside 50m and Windsor is an outside weapon.
8
Intercepting defender can dominate in all parts of the ground with his strong aerial game and slick disposal.
Why?
Looks like West Coast will swoop, offering its future first-round pick to GWS for the rights to Curtin at pick seven.
9
Star goal kicker has been likened to Charlie Curnow for his marking strength and burst power.
Why?
Natural replacement for Tom Hawkins. But Cats will consider trading back for multiple picks in the teens.
10
Gun defender has a huge tank and nice close-out speed. Gets in the right spots to spoil or mark and is rated by some as a better forward.
Why?
Defence has been a problem area for Bombers for years, but Bombers could yet trade back for multiple picks. Riley Hardeman on radar.
11
Star half back drew comparisons to Geelong’s Tom Stewart before firing in a new forward role late in season. Mr Fix it.
Why?
Crows need to bolster back half and Leake can be the next Tom Doedee. GWS a chance at seven if they don’t trade with Eagles.
12
Dynamite goal kicker is ready to go. Loves to be physical and aggressive in his ball use. X-factor.
Why?
The Demons love the tough ballwinners and the popular Tholstrup can do special things. Would shine alongside Kysaiah Pickett.
13
Plays like a 200cm midfielder who can take a grab as a resting forward. Handy combo.
Why?
‘Dimma’ must be laughing. Read is rated as a top-10 talent and helps plan for life after Jarrod Wits.
14
Patience required. Athletic marking forward who will take time.
Why?
Bevo probably wishes Croft was 185cm – with Darcy, Jamarra, Naughton and English there are already a few big boys to choose from – but another bargain pick up for the Dogs
15
Pocket rocket onballer works hard in the clinches like Daniel Kerr or Touk Miller. Gun worker bee.
Why?
Bid may come earlier but no way it’s later than the Swans. Killer draft haul for GC.
16
Athletic ruckman has shown he has clean hands and a big motor to roam the ground. Steadily improved.
Why?
Swans will consider trading back to grab Green later down the order. North Melbourne also circling at this mark.
17
The Wangaratta midfielder runs rings around most of this year’s crop aerobically and seizes his chances in front of the sticks.
Why?
Ross Lyon requested more run and Wilson’s work covering the ground is phenomenal. Not sure the Saints are in love with this draft though. Could they trade their pick?
18
Intercepting defender was one of the stand-out prospects in South Australia this year with his ability to blunt the opposition. Son of Luke.
Why?
Hawks will match a father-son bid from Crows. Hawks desperately need to fill key defensive holes.
19
The big bolter of bunch. The kid with serious wheels got a wriggle on in the final two months of the season to surge up draft boards.
Why?
No invite to Vic Metro or draft camp, no worries for Edwards. He is in such hot demand that the Crows might just pull the trigger here.
20
Raw 200cm defender has grown 20cm in the past two years. Shows promise marking overhead and switching into the ruck.
Why?
North has to take a tall key defender to future proof the back line following Ben McKay’s departure.
21
Captained Western Australia’s U18s as a creating halfback interceptor with a dash of attacking flair.
Why?
Hardeman would flow nicely through the Orange Tsunami. But Essendon is also a fan and could trade back from its first pick to land Hardeman first.
22
One of the most exciting prospects, Collard is a Bobby Hill-type who shone with consecutive hauls of five goals to close the season.
Why?
The Roos have delisted Phoenix Spicer and would love another livewire. But concerns over homesickness has some clubs wary.
23
Banished from Tassie Devils for 10 weeks for an alcohol indiscretion on a training camp. Superboot bounced back to solidify his first-round prospects as a Grant Birchall type.
Why?
The Roos are light-on for stoppers with Ben McKay gone and Griffin Logue injured. Plenty think Schoenmaker will be a Kangaroo.
24
Explosive ball winner who also showed signs of life behind the ball.
Why?
Four academy gifts for the Suns, who may just win the draft. Dimma’s got some new toys.
25
Brother of Essendon’s Zach Reid had a so-so season but is a super ball user by foot.
Why?
Will Kelly is on the outer, Nathan Murphy’s future is clouded and swingman Jeremy Howe is 33. But could Collard creep through to the Pies?
26
Ex-basketballer has toe and is largely untapped after only one SANFL season. Grew up idolising Sam Jacobs as a Crows fan.
Why?
Reilly O’Brien is 28 and Riley Thilthorpe is unlikely to become a full-time ruckman. So it is time for the Crows to up-skill an understudy.
27
Run and gun utility who also passes the character test in flying colours.
Why?
Lyon lamented the Saints’ lack of leg speed and this lad has some serious toe.
28
Carroll has been low on fanfare but crept his way up draft boards as the season wore on. Splash of speed surging out of the backline.
Why?
Blues like this kid who might be an upgrade on delisted wingman Lochie O’Brien.
7:20am Saturday, November 18th, 2023
Rewards
Melbourne
11 °/ 20 °
Hi, Peter
AFL Phantom Draft 2023: Jay Clark and Sam Landsberger reveal how the first round could play out
Days out from this year's AFL Draft, there are still major questions about how the first round will play out. We reveal who your club is likely to land in our definitive Phantom Draft.Jay Clark and Sam Landsberger
less than 2 min read
November 17, 2023 - 10:08PM
News Corp Australia Sports Newsroom
4 comments
Will the Eagles blink and trade Harley Reid away? Who gets the draft’s best tall Dan Curtin? Who will be the bolters and the first round’s biggest sliders? Jay Clark and Sam Landsberger reveal all in their definitive Phantom Draft.
Scroll down to see who your club will land.
DRAFT INSIDER: THE PLAYERS LINKED TO EVERY CLUB
FINAL PHantom draft
Harley Reid
West Coast
Bendigo Pioneers, 187cm midfielderPowerful, confident, country kid certain to go No.1. Sound like anyone? Luke Hodge, perhaps? Except ‘Hodgey’ was never this famous as a teenager.
Why?
Unless the Roos fold and fork over picks No.2 and 3 for Reid then he will be the centrepiece of the Eagles’ rebuild. Does Ben Cousins’ No.9 jumper await?
2
Jed Walter
Gold Coast (matching North Melbourne's bid)
Gold Coast academy, 194cm key forwardFreakishly athletic key forward the first of three academy gifts for Dimma’s Suns. Plenty
of Charlie Curnow in this kid.
Why?
Surely North Melbourne, like most clubs, has Walter ranked a clear No.2 on its talent board and bids here. Questions will be asked if not.
3
Colby McKercher
North Melbourne
Launceston, 182cm midfielderRates his work in the kitchen, but it is his class and precision on the grass that has him a lock to land at Arden St.
Why?
It’s simple. He is the best midfielder behind Reid, and arriving 12 months after Sheezel and Wardlaw arms Alastair Clarkson with three bankable beauties to
transform this club.
4
Zane Duursma
North Melbourne
Gippsland Power, 189cm midfielder/forwardBrother of Essendon recruit Xavier Duursma is deadlier than a bow and arrow in front of goals.
Why?
Going small again because Duursma is too damn good. Will target talls at picks 15, 17 and 18. Suspect Duursma for Ben McKay (this was the compensation selection) will wind up looking OK for the Roos.
5
Nick Watson
Hawthorn
Eastern Ranges, 170cm forward‘The Wizard’ weaved through 70 goals this year. Yes, 70. Remarkably agile, speedy and downright devastating in front of the sticks.
Why?
The Hawks need a key defender and they just picked up a small forward in Jack Ginnivan. But Watson’s magic will be irresistible and you wonder whether the struggles of Denver Grainger-Barrass (No.6 pick in 2020) might spook them from taking Curtin.
6
Ryley Sanders
Western Bulldogs
Sandringham Dragons, 188cm midfielderHas looked like he was ready to rock at AFL level for two years now. The Tasmanian (he boards at Melbourne Grammar) is a tough onballer with ticker.
Why?
Did the Dogs trade up to this pick to secure Watson? Probably. But they won’t be too disappointed because Sanders is a safe bet and they suddenly need to replenish what has become an ageing midfield.
7
Caleb Windsor
Melbourne
Eastern Ranges, 184cm WingmanClassy outside ball user could blossom like Hugh McCluggage. Speed and agility in spades.
Why?
Melbourne need to sharpen the sword going inside 50m and Windsor is an outside weapon.
8
Daniel Curtin
West Coast (via GWS trade)
Claremont, 197cm defenderIntercepting defender can dominate in all parts of the ground with his strong aerial game and slick disposal.
Why?
Looks like West Coast will swoop, offering its future first-round pick to GWS for the rights to Curtin at pick seven.
9
Nate Caddy
Geelong
Northern Knights, 193cm forwardStar goal kicker has been likened to Charlie Curnow for his marking strength and burst power.
Why?
Natural replacement for Tom Hawkins. But Cats will consider trading back for multiple picks in the teens.
10
Connor O’Sullivan
Essendon
Murray Bushrangers, 197cm key defenderGun defender has a huge tank and nice close-out speed. Gets in the right spots to spoil or mark and is rated by some as a better forward.
Why?
Defence has been a problem area for Bombers for years, but Bombers could yet trade back for multiple picks. Riley Hardeman on radar.
11
James Leake
Adelaide
Launceston, 187cm utilityStar half back drew comparisons to Geelong’s Tom Stewart before firing in a new forward role late in season. Mr Fix it.
Why?
Crows need to bolster back half and Leake can be the next Tom Doedee. GWS a chance at seven if they don’t trade with Eagles.
12
Koltyn Tholstrup
Melbourne
Subiaco, 188cm forwardDynamite goal kicker is ready to go. Loves to be physical and aggressive in his ball use. X-factor.
Why?
The Demons love the tough ballwinners and the popular Tholstrup can do special things. Would shine alongside Kysaiah Pickett.
13
Ethan Read
Gold Coast (matching Sydney's bid)
Gold Coast academy, 202cm ruckmanPlays like a 200cm midfielder who can take a grab as a resting forward. Handy combo.
Why?
‘Dimma’ must be laughing. Read is rated as a top-10 talent and helps plan for life after Jarrod Wits.
14
Jordan Croft
Western Bulldogs (matching Sydney's bid)
Calder Cannons, 201cm key forwardPatience required. Athletic marking forward who will take time.
Why?
Bevo probably wishes Croft was 185cm – with Darcy, Jamarra, Naughton and English there are already a few big boys to choose from – but another bargain pick up for the Dogs
15
Jake Rogers
Gold Coast (matching Sydney’s bid)
Gold Coast Academy, 170cm midfielderPocket rocket onballer works hard in the clinches like Daniel Kerr or Touk Miller. Gun worker bee.
Why?
Bid may come earlier but no way it’s later than the Swans. Killer draft haul for GC.
16
Will Green
Sydney
Northern Knights, 204cm ruckAthletic ruckman has shown he has clean hands and a big motor to roam the ground. Steadily improved.
Why?
Swans will consider trading back to grab Green later down the order. North Melbourne also circling at this mark.
17
Darcy Wilson
St Kilda
Murray Bushrangers, 186cm midfielderThe Wangaratta midfielder runs rings around most of this year’s crop aerobically and seizes his chances in front of the sticks.
Why?
Ross Lyon requested more run and Wilson’s work covering the ground is phenomenal. Not sure the Saints are in love with this draft though. Could they trade their pick?
18
Will McCabe (matching Adelaide's bid)
Hawthorn
Central District, 197cm defenderIntercepting defender was one of the stand-out prospects in South Australia this year with his ability to blunt the opposition. Son of Luke.
Why?
Hawks will match a father-son bid from Crows. Hawks desperately need to fill key defensive holes.
19
Charlie Edwards
Adelaide
Sandringham Dragons, 191cm midfielderThe big bolter of bunch. The kid with serious wheels got a wriggle on in the final two months of the season to surge up draft boards.
Why?
No invite to Vic Metro or draft camp, no worries for Edwards. He is in such hot demand that the Crows might just pull the trigger here.
20
Wil Dawson
North Melbourne
Gippsland Power, 200cm DefenderRaw 200cm defender has grown 20cm in the past two years. Shows promise marking overhead and switching into the ruck.
Why?
North has to take a tall key defender to future proof the back line following Ben McKay’s departure.
21
Riley Hardeman
GWS
Swan Districts, 188cm midfielderCaptained Western Australia’s U18s as a creating halfback interceptor with a dash of attacking flair.
Why?
Hardeman would flow nicely through the Orange Tsunami. But Essendon is also a fan and could trade back from its first pick to land Hardeman first.
22
Lance Collard
North Melbourne
Subiaco, 180cm forwardOne of the most exciting prospects, Collard is a Bobby Hill-type who shone with consecutive hauls of five goals to close the season.
Why?
The Roos have delisted Phoenix Spicer and would love another livewire. But concerns over homesickness has some clubs wary.
23
Arie Schoenmaker
North Melbourne
Tasmania, 194cm defenderBanished from Tassie Devils for 10 weeks for an alcohol indiscretion on a training camp. Superboot bounced back to solidify his first-round prospects as a Grant Birchall type.
Why?
The Roos are light-on for stoppers with Ben McKay gone and Griffin Logue injured. Plenty think Schoenmaker will be a Kangaroo.
24
Will Graham
Gold Coast (matching Collingwood bid)
Gold Coast Academy, 186cm midfielderExplosive ball winner who also showed signs of life behind the ball.
Why?
Four academy gifts for the Suns, who may just win the draft. Dimma’s got some new toys.
25
Archer Reid
Collingwood
Gippsland Power, 203cm forwardBrother of Essendon’s Zach Reid had a so-so season but is a super ball user by foot.
Why?
Will Kelly is on the outer, Nathan Murphy’s future is clouded and swingman Jeremy Howe is 33. But could Collard creep through to the Pies?
26
Taylor Goad
Adelaide
South Adelaide, 206cm ruckmanEx-basketballer has toe and is largely untapped after only one SANFL season. Grew up idolising Sam Jacobs as a Crows fan.
Why?
Reilly O’Brien is 28 and Riley Thilthorpe is unlikely to become a full-time ruckman. So it is time for the Crows to up-skill an understudy.
27
Harry De Mattia
St Kilda
Dandenong Stingrays, 184cm utilityRun and gun utility who also passes the character test in flying colours.
Why?
Lyon lamented the Saints’ lack of leg speed and this lad has some serious toe.
28
Matt Carroll
Carlton
Sandringham Dragons, 188cm defenderCarroll has been low on fanfare but crept his way up draft boards as the season wore on. Splash of speed surging out of the backline.
Why?
Blues like this kid who might be an upgrade on delisted wingman Lochie O’Brien.
Inside 50 Newslette
Would be okay with this haul. Dawson can also play forward and adds the pressure forward in Collard. Would still be going for Curtin instead of dursmaa then use he shoenmsker pick on a ruck but okay with itRead Today's PaperTributes
7:20am Saturday, November 18th, 2023
Rewards
Melbourne
11 °/ 20 °
Hi, Peter
AFL Phantom Draft 2023: Jay Clark and Sam Landsberger reveal how the first round could play out
Days out from this year's AFL Draft, there are still major questions about how the first round will play out. We reveal who your club is likely to land in our definitive Phantom Draft.
Jay Clark and Sam Landsberger
less than 2 min read
November 17, 2023 - 10:08PM
News Corp Australia Sports Newsroom
4 comments
AFL: The AFL draft is just a few days away, with the league's talent ambassador Kevin Sheehan having high hopes for Zane Duursma.
Will the Eagles blink and trade Harley Reid away? Who gets the draft’s best tall Dan Curtin? Who will be the bolters and the first round’s biggest sliders? Jay Clark and Sam Landsberger reveal all in their definitive Phantom Draft.
Scroll down to see who your club will land.
DRAFT INSIDER: THE PLAYERS LINKED TO EVERY CLUB
FINAL PHantom draft
Harley Reid
West Coast
Bendigo Pioneers, 187cm midfielder
Powerful, confident, country kid certain to go No.1. Sound like anyone? Luke Hodge, perhaps? Except ‘Hodgey’ was never this famous as a teenager.
Why?
Unless the Roos fold and fork over picks No.2 and 3 for Reid then he will be the centrepiece of the Eagles’ rebuild. Does Ben Cousins’ No.9 jumper await?
2
Jed Walter
Gold Coast (matching North Melbourne's bid)
Gold Coast academy, 194cm key forward
Freakishly athletic key forward the first of three academy gifts for Dimma’s Suns. Plenty
of Charlie Curnow in this kid.
Why?
Surely North Melbourne, like most clubs, has Walter ranked a clear No.2 on its talent board and bids here. Questions will be asked if not.
3
Colby McKercher
North Melbourne
Launceston, 182cm midfielder
Rates his work in the kitchen, but it is his class and precision on the grass that has him a lock to land at Arden St.
Why?
It’s simple. He is the best midfielder behind Reid, and arriving 12 months after Sheezel and Wardlaw arms Alastair Clarkson with three bankable beauties to
transform this club.
4
Zane Duursma
North Melbourne
Gippsland Power, 189cm midfielder/forward
Brother of Essendon recruit Xavier Duursma is deadlier than a bow and arrow in front of goals.
Why?
Going small again because Duursma is too damn good. Will target talls at picks 15, 17 and 18. Suspect Duursma for Ben McKay (this was the compensation selection) will wind up looking OK for the Roos.
5
Nick Watson
Hawthorn
Eastern Ranges, 170cm forward
‘The Wizard’ weaved through 70 goals this year. Yes, 70. Remarkably agile, speedy and downright devastating in front of the sticks.
Why?
The Hawks need a key defender and they just picked up a small forward in Jack Ginnivan. But Watson’s magic will be irresistible and you wonder whether the struggles of Denver Grainger-Barrass (No.6 pick in 2020) might spook them from taking Curtin.
6
Ryley Sanders
Western Bulldogs
Sandringham Dragons, 188cm midfielder
Has looked like he was ready to rock at AFL level for two years now. The Tasmanian (he boards at Melbourne Grammar) is a tough onballer with ticker.
Why?
Did the Dogs trade up to this pick to secure Watson? Probably. But they won’t be too disappointed because Sanders is a safe bet and they suddenly need to replenish what has become an ageing midfield.
7
Caleb Windsor
Melbourne
Eastern Ranges, 184cm Wingman
Classy outside ball user could blossom like Hugh McCluggage. Speed and agility in spades.
Why?
Melbourne need to sharpen the sword going inside 50m and Windsor is an outside weapon.
8
Daniel Curtin
West Coast (via GWS trade)
Claremont, 197cm defender
Intercepting defender can dominate in all parts of the ground with his strong aerial game and slick disposal.
Why?
Looks like West Coast will swoop, offering its future first-round pick to GWS for the rights to Curtin at pick seven.
9
Nate Caddy
Geelong
Northern Knights, 193cm forward
Star goal kicker has been likened to Charlie Curnow for his marking strength and burst power.
Why?
Natural replacement for Tom Hawkins. But Cats will consider trading back for multiple picks in the teens.
10
Connor O’Sullivan
Essendon
Murray Bushrangers, 197cm key defender
Gun defender has a huge tank and nice close-out speed. Gets in the right spots to spoil or mark and is rated by some as a better forward.
Why?
Defence has been a problem area for Bombers for years, but Bombers could yet trade back for multiple picks. Riley Hardeman on radar.
11
James Leake
Adelaide
Launceston, 187cm utility
Star half back drew comparisons to Geelong’s Tom Stewart before firing in a new forward role late in season. Mr Fix it.
Why?
Crows need to bolster back half and Leake can be the next Tom Doedee. GWS a chance at seven if they don’t trade with Eagles.
12
Koltyn Tholstrup
Melbourne
Subiaco, 188cm forward
Dynamite goal kicker is ready to go. Loves to be physical and aggressive in his ball use. X-factor.
Why?
The Demons love the tough ballwinners and the popular Tholstrup can do special things. Would shine alongside Kysaiah Pickett.
13
Ethan Read
Gold Coast (matching Sydney's bid)
Gold Coast academy, 202cm ruckman
Plays like a 200cm midfielder who can take a grab as a resting forward. Handy combo.
Why?
‘Dimma’ must be laughing. Read is rated as a top-10 talent and helps plan for life after Jarrod Wits.
14
Jordan Croft
Western Bulldogs (matching Sydney's bid)
Calder Cannons, 201cm key forward
Patience required. Athletic marking forward who will take time.
Why?
Bevo probably wishes Croft was 185cm – with Darcy, Jamarra, Naughton and English there are already a few big boys to choose from – but another bargain pick up for the Dogs
15
Jake Rogers
Gold Coast (matching Sydney’s bid)
Gold Coast Academy, 170cm midfielder
Pocket rocket onballer works hard in the clinches like Daniel Kerr or Touk Miller. Gun worker bee.
Why?
Bid may come earlier but no way it’s later than the Swans. Killer draft haul for GC.
16
Will Green
Sydney
Northern Knights, 204cm ruck
Athletic ruckman has shown he has clean hands and a big motor to roam the ground. Steadily improved.
Why?
Swans will consider trading back to grab Green later down the order. North Melbourne also circling at this mark.
17
Darcy Wilson
St Kilda
Murray Bushrangers, 186cm midfielder
The Wangaratta midfielder runs rings around most of this year’s crop aerobically and seizes his chances in front of the sticks.
Why?
Ross Lyon requested more run and Wilson’s work covering the ground is phenomenal. Not sure the Saints are in love with this draft though. Could they trade their pick?
18
Will McCabe (matching Adelaide's bid)
Hawthorn
Central District, 197cm defender
Intercepting defender was one of the stand-out prospects in South Australia this year with his ability to blunt the opposition. Son of Luke.
Why?
Hawks will match a father-son bid from Crows. Hawks desperately need to fill key defensive holes.
19
Charlie Edwards
Adelaide
Sandringham Dragons, 191cm midfielder
The big bolter of bunch. The kid with serious wheels got a wriggle on in the final two months of the season to surge up draft boards.
Why?
No invite to Vic Metro or draft camp, no worries for Edwards. He is in such hot demand that the Crows might just pull the trigger here.
20
Wil Dawson
North Melbourne
Gippsland Power, 200cm Defender
Raw 200cm defender has grown 20cm in the past two years. Shows promise marking overhead and switching into the ruck.
Why?
North has to take a tall key defender to future proof the back line following Ben McKay’s departure.
21
Riley Hardeman
GWS
Swan Districts, 188cm midfielder
Captained Western Australia’s U18s as a creating halfback interceptor with a dash of attacking flair.
Why?
Hardeman would flow nicely through the Orange Tsunami. But Essendon is also a fan and could trade back from its first pick to land Hardeman first.
22
Lance Collard
North Melbourne
Subiaco, 180cm forward
One of the most exciting prospects, Collard is a Bobby Hill-type who shone with consecutive hauls of five goals to close the season.
Why?
The Roos have delisted Phoenix Spicer and would love another livewire. But concerns over homesickness has some clubs wary.
23
Arie Schoenmaker
North Melbourne
Tasmania, 194cm defender
Banished from Tassie Devils for 10 weeks for an alcohol indiscretion on a training camp. Superboot bounced back to solidify his first-round prospects as a Grant Birchall type.
Why?
The Roos are light-on for stoppers with Ben McKay gone and Griffin Logue injured. Plenty think Schoenmaker will be a Kangaroo.
24
Will Graham
Gold Coast (matching Collingwood bid)
Gold Coast Academy, 186cm midfielder
Explosive ball winner who also showed signs of life behind the ball.
Why?
Four academy gifts for the Suns, who may just win the draft. Dimma’s got some new toys.
25
Archer Reid
Collingwood
Gippsland Power, 203cm forward
Brother of Essendon’s Zach Reid had a so-so season but is a super ball user by foot.
Why?
Will Kelly is on the outer, Nathan Murphy’s future is clouded and swingman Jeremy Howe is 33. But could Collard creep through to the Pies?
26
Taylor Goad
Adelaide
South Adelaide, 206cm ruckman
Ex-basketballer has toe and is largely untapped after only one SANFL season. Grew up idolising Sam Jacobs as a Crows fan.
Why?
Reilly O’Brien is 28 and Riley Thilthorpe is unlikely to become a full-time ruckman. So it is time for the Crows to up-skill an understudy.
27
Harry De Mattia
St Kilda
Dandenong Stingrays, 184cm utility
Run and gun utility who also passes the character test in flying colours.
Why?
Lyon lamented the Saints’ lack of leg speed and this lad has some serious toe.
28
Matt Carroll
Carlton
Sandringham Dragons, 188cm defender
Carroll has been low on fanfare but crept his way up draft boards as the season wore on. Splash of speed surging out of the backline.
Why?
Blues like this kid who might be an upgrade on delisted wingman Lochie O’Brien.
Inside 50 Newslette
- Aug 6, 2021
- 8,631
- 23,449
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
I’d replace Schoenmaker with Archer Reid (or Ollie Murphy), and ideally Duursma with Curtin, but having said all that, I don’t mind this.Read Today's PaperTributes
7:20am Saturday, November 18th, 2023
Rewards
Melbourne
11 °/ 20 °
Hi, Peter
AFL Phantom Draft 2023: Jay Clark and Sam Landsberger reveal how the first round could play out
Days out from this year's AFL Draft, there are still major questions about how the first round will play out. We reveal who your club is likely to land in our definitive Phantom Draft.
Jay Clark and Sam Landsberger
less than 2 min read
November 17, 2023 - 10:08PM
News Corp Australia Sports Newsroom
4 comments
AFL: The AFL draft is just a few days away, with the league's talent ambassador Kevin Sheehan having high hopes for Zane Duursma.
Will the Eagles blink and trade Harley Reid away? Who gets the draft’s best tall Dan Curtin? Who will be the bolters and the first round’s biggest sliders? Jay Clark and Sam Landsberger reveal all in their definitive Phantom Draft.
Scroll down to see who your club will land.
DRAFT INSIDER: THE PLAYERS LINKED TO EVERY CLUB
FINAL PHantom draft
Harley Reid
West Coast
Bendigo Pioneers, 187cm midfielder
Powerful, confident, country kid certain to go No.1. Sound like anyone? Luke Hodge, perhaps? Except ‘Hodgey’ was never this famous as a teenager.
Why?
Unless the Roos fold and fork over picks No.2 and 3 for Reid then he will be the centrepiece of the Eagles’ rebuild. Does Ben Cousins’ No.9 jumper await?
2
Jed Walter
Gold Coast (matching North Melbourne's bid)
Gold Coast academy, 194cm key forward
Freakishly athletic key forward the first of three academy gifts for Dimma’s Suns. Plenty
of Charlie Curnow in this kid.
Why?
Surely North Melbourne, like most clubs, has Walter ranked a clear No.2 on its talent board and bids here. Questions will be asked if not.
3
Colby McKercher
North Melbourne
Launceston, 182cm midfielder
Rates his work in the kitchen, but it is his class and precision on the grass that has him a lock to land at Arden St.
Why?
It’s simple. He is the best midfielder behind Reid, and arriving 12 months after Sheezel and Wardlaw arms Alastair Clarkson with three bankable beauties to
transform this club.
4
Zane Duursma
North Melbourne
Gippsland Power, 189cm midfielder/forward
Brother of Essendon recruit Xavier Duursma is deadlier than a bow and arrow in front of goals.
Why?
Going small again because Duursma is too damn good. Will target talls at picks 15, 17 and 18. Suspect Duursma for Ben McKay (this was the compensation selection) will wind up looking OK for the Roos.
5
Nick Watson
Hawthorn
Eastern Ranges, 170cm forward
‘The Wizard’ weaved through 70 goals this year. Yes, 70. Remarkably agile, speedy and downright devastating in front of the sticks.
Why?
The Hawks need a key defender and they just picked up a small forward in Jack Ginnivan. But Watson’s magic will be irresistible and you wonder whether the struggles of Denver Grainger-Barrass (No.6 pick in 2020) might spook them from taking Curtin.
6
Ryley Sanders
Western Bulldogs
Sandringham Dragons, 188cm midfielder
Has looked like he was ready to rock at AFL level for two years now. The Tasmanian (he boards at Melbourne Grammar) is a tough onballer with ticker.
Why?
Did the Dogs trade up to this pick to secure Watson? Probably. But they won’t be too disappointed because Sanders is a safe bet and they suddenly need to replenish what has become an ageing midfield.
7
Caleb Windsor
Melbourne
Eastern Ranges, 184cm Wingman
Classy outside ball user could blossom like Hugh McCluggage. Speed and agility in spades.
Why?
Melbourne need to sharpen the sword going inside 50m and Windsor is an outside weapon.
8
Daniel Curtin
West Coast (via GWS trade)
Claremont, 197cm defender
Intercepting defender can dominate in all parts of the ground with his strong aerial game and slick disposal.
Why?
Looks like West Coast will swoop, offering its future first-round pick to GWS for the rights to Curtin at pick seven.
9
Nate Caddy
Geelong
Northern Knights, 193cm forward
Star goal kicker has been likened to Charlie Curnow for his marking strength and burst power.
Why?
Natural replacement for Tom Hawkins. But Cats will consider trading back for multiple picks in the teens.
10
Connor O’Sullivan
Essendon
Murray Bushrangers, 197cm key defender
Gun defender has a huge tank and nice close-out speed. Gets in the right spots to spoil or mark and is rated by some as a better forward.
Why?
Defence has been a problem area for Bombers for years, but Bombers could yet trade back for multiple picks. Riley Hardeman on radar.
11
James Leake
Adelaide
Launceston, 187cm utility
Star half back drew comparisons to Geelong’s Tom Stewart before firing in a new forward role late in season. Mr Fix it.
Why?
Crows need to bolster back half and Leake can be the next Tom Doedee. GWS a chance at seven if they don’t trade with Eagles.
12
Koltyn Tholstrup
Melbourne
Subiaco, 188cm forward
Dynamite goal kicker is ready to go. Loves to be physical and aggressive in his ball use. X-factor.
Why?
The Demons love the tough ballwinners and the popular Tholstrup can do special things. Would shine alongside Kysaiah Pickett.
13
Ethan Read
Gold Coast (matching Sydney's bid)
Gold Coast academy, 202cm ruckman
Plays like a 200cm midfielder who can take a grab as a resting forward. Handy combo.
Why?
‘Dimma’ must be laughing. Read is rated as a top-10 talent and helps plan for life after Jarrod Wits.
14
Jordan Croft
Western Bulldogs (matching Sydney's bid)
Calder Cannons, 201cm key forward
Patience required. Athletic marking forward who will take time.
Why?
Bevo probably wishes Croft was 185cm – with Darcy, Jamarra, Naughton and English there are already a few big boys to choose from – but another bargain pick up for the Dogs
15
Jake Rogers
Gold Coast (matching Sydney’s bid)
Gold Coast Academy, 170cm midfielder
Pocket rocket onballer works hard in the clinches like Daniel Kerr or Touk Miller. Gun worker bee.
Why?
Bid may come earlier but no way it’s later than the Swans. Killer draft haul for GC.
16
Will Green
Sydney
Northern Knights, 204cm ruck
Athletic ruckman has shown he has clean hands and a big motor to roam the ground. Steadily improved.
Why?
Swans will consider trading back to grab Green later down the order. North Melbourne also circling at this mark.
17
Darcy Wilson
St Kilda
Murray Bushrangers, 186cm midfielder
The Wangaratta midfielder runs rings around most of this year’s crop aerobically and seizes his chances in front of the sticks.
Why?
Ross Lyon requested more run and Wilson’s work covering the ground is phenomenal. Not sure the Saints are in love with this draft though. Could they trade their pick?
18
Will McCabe (matching Adelaide's bid)
Hawthorn
Central District, 197cm defender
Intercepting defender was one of the stand-out prospects in South Australia this year with his ability to blunt the opposition. Son of Luke.
Why?
Hawks will match a father-son bid from Crows. Hawks desperately need to fill key defensive holes.
19
Charlie Edwards
Adelaide
Sandringham Dragons, 191cm midfielder
The big bolter of bunch. The kid with serious wheels got a wriggle on in the final two months of the season to surge up draft boards.
Why?
No invite to Vic Metro or draft camp, no worries for Edwards. He is in such hot demand that the Crows might just pull the trigger here.
20
Wil Dawson
North Melbourne
Gippsland Power, 200cm Defender
Raw 200cm defender has grown 20cm in the past two years. Shows promise marking overhead and switching into the ruck.
Why?
North has to take a tall key defender to future proof the back line following Ben McKay’s departure.
21
Riley Hardeman
GWS
Swan Districts, 188cm midfielder
Captained Western Australia’s U18s as a creating halfback interceptor with a dash of attacking flair.
Why?
Hardeman would flow nicely through the Orange Tsunami. But Essendon is also a fan and could trade back from its first pick to land Hardeman first.
22
Lance Collard
North Melbourne
Subiaco, 180cm forward
One of the most exciting prospects, Collard is a Bobby Hill-type who shone with consecutive hauls of five goals to close the season.
Why?
The Roos have delisted Phoenix Spicer and would love another livewire. But concerns over homesickness has some clubs wary.
23
Arie Schoenmaker
North Melbourne
Tasmania, 194cm defender
Banished from Tassie Devils for 10 weeks for an alcohol indiscretion on a training camp. Superboot bounced back to solidify his first-round prospects as a Grant Birchall type.
Why?
The Roos are light-on for stoppers with Ben McKay gone and Griffin Logue injured. Plenty think Schoenmaker will be a Kangaroo.
24
Will Graham
Gold Coast (matching Collingwood bid)
Gold Coast Academy, 186cm midfielder
Explosive ball winner who also showed signs of life behind the ball.
Why?
Four academy gifts for the Suns, who may just win the draft. Dimma’s got some new toys.
25
Archer Reid
Collingwood
Gippsland Power, 203cm forward
Brother of Essendon’s Zach Reid had a so-so season but is a super ball user by foot.
Why?
Will Kelly is on the outer, Nathan Murphy’s future is clouded and swingman Jeremy Howe is 33. But could Collard creep through to the Pies?
26
Taylor Goad
Adelaide
South Adelaide, 206cm ruckman
Ex-basketballer has toe and is largely untapped after only one SANFL season. Grew up idolising Sam Jacobs as a Crows fan.
Why?
Reilly O’Brien is 28 and Riley Thilthorpe is unlikely to become a full-time ruckman. So it is time for the Crows to up-skill an understudy.
27
Harry De Mattia
St Kilda
Dandenong Stingrays, 184cm utility
Run and gun utility who also passes the character test in flying colours.
Why?
Lyon lamented the Saints’ lack of leg speed and this lad has some serious toe.
28
Matt Carroll
Carlton
Sandringham Dragons, 188cm defender
Carroll has been low on fanfare but crept his way up draft boards as the season wore on. Splash of speed surging out of the backline.
Why?
Blues like this kid who might be an upgrade on delisted wingman Lochie O’Brien.
Inside 50 Newslette
- Jun 7, 2019
- 5,361
- 18,478
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
I think while we're still building the group and it's culture, they won't take the risk with Schoenmaker. He needs an established no-nonsense group to straighten him up, something like Sydney
Now that wet toast want pick #7 for Curtin, I really want pick #6 for him!!
While normally I'd be completely against trading out a top #3 pick, it makes so much sense from a list management perspective.
Something like #3+#18 for #6+#11+future 1st
Pick 2 - mckercher
Pick 6 - curtin/caddy/O'Sullivan
Pick 11- whoever is left of leake/Windsor/Wilson
Pick 15 - collard or trade with freo for port future 1st + #34
Pick 17 - whoever is left of goad/medwards/green
While normally I'd be completely against trading out a top #3 pick, it makes so much sense from a list management perspective.
Something like #3+#18 for #6+#11+future 1st
Pick 2 - mckercher
Pick 6 - curtin/caddy/O'Sullivan
Pick 11- whoever is left of leake/Windsor/Wilson
Pick 15 - collard or trade with freo for port future 1st + #34
Pick 17 - whoever is left of goad/medwards/green
Luke72
Premium Platinum
North Melbourne - 2024 Hugh Greenwood Player Sponsor
Veteran
North Melbourne - 2023 Ailish Considine and Bella Eddy Player Sponsor
North Melbourne - Bella Eddey and Vicki Wall Player Sponsor - Season 7
North Melbourne - 2023 Aaron Hall and Flynn Perez Player Sponsor
North Melbourne - 2022 Aaron Hall and Flynn Perez Player Sponsor
North Melbourne - 2022 Kaitlyn Ashmore and Aileen Gilroy Player Sponsor
North Melbourne AFLW - 2021 Aileen Gilroy and Kaitlyn Ashmore Player Sponsor
- Aug 21, 2012
- 6,796
- 15,963
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
I don’t know about all of this, but if we end up with Ports future first again that would be fantastic. The death ride is dead, long live the death ride.
Outside of Sheezel we still don’t have any half backs that can accumulate the footy, provide run and provide long kicking. Hardeman ticks all those boxes
Disco Dew
Premiership Player
- Mar 21, 2022
- 4,624
- 20,215
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Chicago Bulls
They aren’t going to do it if curtin is already off the table
ToxicMegaPunts
Senior List
- Sep 2, 2022
- 252
- 1,177
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
They would only live trade with GWS at 7 if Curtin was still on the board, makes no sense otherwise.
Yeah had thought the same thing. That would be outrageous.
Yeah but as Czero said they are effectively trading likely pick 1 or 2 for pick 7
You need more than 2 players that can do it.
We should always look to field 2 teams. Afl and vfl.
- Apr 17, 2007
- 25,090
- 43,884
- AFL Club
- North Melbourne
- Other Teams
- hellas,liverpool,storm,au
Rather A.Reid or Goad than schonenmakerRead Today's PaperTributes
7:20am Saturday, November 18th, 2023
Rewards
Melbourne
11 °/ 20 °
Hi, Peter
AFL Phantom Draft 2023: Jay Clark and Sam Landsberger reveal how the first round could play out
Days out from this year's AFL Draft, there are still major questions about how the first round will play out. We reveal who your club is likely to land in our definitive Phantom Draft.
Jay Clark and Sam Landsberger
less than 2 min read
November 17, 2023 - 10:08PM
News Corp Australia Sports Newsroom
4 comments
AFL: The AFL draft is just a few days away, with the league's talent ambassador Kevin Sheehan having high hopes for Zane Duursma.
Will the Eagles blink and trade Harley Reid away? Who gets the draft’s best tall Dan Curtin? Who will be the bolters and the first round’s biggest sliders? Jay Clark and Sam Landsberger reveal all in their definitive Phantom Draft.
Scroll down to see who your club will land.
DRAFT INSIDER: THE PLAYERS LINKED TO EVERY CLUB
FINAL PHantom draft
Harley Reid
West Coast
Bendigo Pioneers, 187cm midfielder
Powerful, confident, country kid certain to go No.1. Sound like anyone? Luke Hodge, perhaps? Except ‘Hodgey’ was never this famous as a teenager.
Why?
Unless the Roos fold and fork over picks No.2 and 3 for Reid then he will be the centrepiece of the Eagles’ rebuild. Does Ben Cousins’ No.9 jumper await?
2
Jed Walter
Gold Coast (matching North Melbourne's bid)
Gold Coast academy, 194cm key forward
Freakishly athletic key forward the first of three academy gifts for Dimma’s Suns. Plenty
of Charlie Curnow in this kid.
Why?
Surely North Melbourne, like most clubs, has Walter ranked a clear No.2 on its talent board and bids here. Questions will be asked if not.
3
Colby McKercher
North Melbourne
Launceston, 182cm midfielder
Rates his work in the kitchen, but it is his class and precision on the grass that has him a lock to land at Arden St.
Why?
It’s simple. He is the best midfielder behind Reid, and arriving 12 months after Sheezel and Wardlaw arms Alastair Clarkson with three bankable beauties to
transform this club.
4
Zane Duursma
North Melbourne
Gippsland Power, 189cm midfielder/forward
Brother of Essendon recruit Xavier Duursma is deadlier than a bow and arrow in front of goals.
Why?
Going small again because Duursma is too damn good. Will target talls at picks 15, 17 and 18. Suspect Duursma for Ben McKay (this was the compensation selection) will wind up looking OK for the Roos.
5
Nick Watson
Hawthorn
Eastern Ranges, 170cm forward
‘The Wizard’ weaved through 70 goals this year. Yes, 70. Remarkably agile, speedy and downright devastating in front of the sticks.
Why?
The Hawks need a key defender and they just picked up a small forward in Jack Ginnivan. But Watson’s magic will be irresistible and you wonder whether the struggles of Denver Grainger-Barrass (No.6 pick in 2020) might spook them from taking Curtin.
6
Ryley Sanders
Western Bulldogs
Sandringham Dragons, 188cm midfielder
Has looked like he was ready to rock at AFL level for two years now. The Tasmanian (he boards at Melbourne Grammar) is a tough onballer with ticker.
Why?
Did the Dogs trade up to this pick to secure Watson? Probably. But they won’t be too disappointed because Sanders is a safe bet and they suddenly need to replenish what has become an ageing midfield.
7
Caleb Windsor
Melbourne
Eastern Ranges, 184cm Wingman
Classy outside ball user could blossom like Hugh McCluggage. Speed and agility in spades.
Why?
Melbourne need to sharpen the sword going inside 50m and Windsor is an outside weapon.
8
Daniel Curtin
West Coast (via GWS trade)
Claremont, 197cm defender
Intercepting defender can dominate in all parts of the ground with his strong aerial game and slick disposal.
Why?
Looks like West Coast will swoop, offering its future first-round pick to GWS for the rights to Curtin at pick seven.
9
Nate Caddy
Geelong
Northern Knights, 193cm forward
Star goal kicker has been likened to Charlie Curnow for his marking strength and burst power.
Why?
Natural replacement for Tom Hawkins. But Cats will consider trading back for multiple picks in the teens.
10
Connor O’Sullivan
Essendon
Murray Bushrangers, 197cm key defender
Gun defender has a huge tank and nice close-out speed. Gets in the right spots to spoil or mark and is rated by some as a better forward.
Why?
Defence has been a problem area for Bombers for years, but Bombers could yet trade back for multiple picks. Riley Hardeman on radar.
11
James Leake
Adelaide
Launceston, 187cm utility
Star half back drew comparisons to Geelong’s Tom Stewart before firing in a new forward role late in season. Mr Fix it.
Why?
Crows need to bolster back half and Leake can be the next Tom Doedee. GWS a chance at seven if they don’t trade with Eagles.
12
Koltyn Tholstrup
Melbourne
Subiaco, 188cm forward
Dynamite goal kicker is ready to go. Loves to be physical and aggressive in his ball use. X-factor.
Why?
The Demons love the tough ballwinners and the popular Tholstrup can do special things. Would shine alongside Kysaiah Pickett.
13
Ethan Read
Gold Coast (matching Sydney's bid)
Gold Coast academy, 202cm ruckman
Plays like a 200cm midfielder who can take a grab as a resting forward. Handy combo.
Why?
‘Dimma’ must be laughing. Read is rated as a top-10 talent and helps plan for life after Jarrod Wits.
14
Jordan Croft
Western Bulldogs (matching Sydney's bid)
Calder Cannons, 201cm key forward
Patience required. Athletic marking forward who will take time.
Why?
Bevo probably wishes Croft was 185cm – with Darcy, Jamarra, Naughton and English there are already a few big boys to choose from – but another bargain pick up for the Dogs
15
Jake Rogers
Gold Coast (matching Sydney’s bid)
Gold Coast Academy, 170cm midfielder
Pocket rocket onballer works hard in the clinches like Daniel Kerr or Touk Miller. Gun worker bee.
Why?
Bid may come earlier but no way it’s later than the Swans. Killer draft haul for GC.
16
Will Green
Sydney
Northern Knights, 204cm ruck
Athletic ruckman has shown he has clean hands and a big motor to roam the ground. Steadily improved.
Why?
Swans will consider trading back to grab Green later down the order. North Melbourne also circling at this mark.
17
Darcy Wilson
St Kilda
Murray Bushrangers, 186cm midfielder
The Wangaratta midfielder runs rings around most of this year’s crop aerobically and seizes his chances in front of the sticks.
Why?
Ross Lyon requested more run and Wilson’s work covering the ground is phenomenal. Not sure the Saints are in love with this draft though. Could they trade their pick?
18
Will McCabe (matching Adelaide's bid)
Hawthorn
Central District, 197cm defender
Intercepting defender was one of the stand-out prospects in South Australia this year with his ability to blunt the opposition. Son of Luke.
Why?
Hawks will match a father-son bid from Crows. Hawks desperately need to fill key defensive holes.
19
Charlie Edwards
Adelaide
Sandringham Dragons, 191cm midfielder
The big bolter of bunch. The kid with serious wheels got a wriggle on in the final two months of the season to surge up draft boards.
Why?
No invite to Vic Metro or draft camp, no worries for Edwards. He is in such hot demand that the Crows might just pull the trigger here.
20
Wil Dawson
North Melbourne
Gippsland Power, 200cm Defender
Raw 200cm defender has grown 20cm in the past two years. Shows promise marking overhead and switching into the ruck.
Why?
North has to take a tall key defender to future proof the back line following Ben McKay’s departure.
21
Riley Hardeman
GWS
Swan Districts, 188cm midfielder
Captained Western Australia’s U18s as a creating halfback interceptor with a dash of attacking flair.
Why?
Hardeman would flow nicely through the Orange Tsunami. But Essendon is also a fan and could trade back from its first pick to land Hardeman first.
22
Lance Collard
North Melbourne
Subiaco, 180cm forward
One of the most exciting prospects, Collard is a Bobby Hill-type who shone with consecutive hauls of five goals to close the season.
Why?
The Roos have delisted Phoenix Spicer and would love another livewire. But concerns over homesickness has some clubs wary.
23
Arie Schoenmaker
North Melbourne
Tasmania, 194cm defender
Banished from Tassie Devils for 10 weeks for an alcohol indiscretion on a training camp. Superboot bounced back to solidify his first-round prospects as a Grant Birchall type.
Why?
The Roos are light-on for stoppers with Ben McKay gone and Griffin Logue injured. Plenty think Schoenmaker will be a Kangaroo.
24
Will Graham
Gold Coast (matching Collingwood bid)
Gold Coast Academy, 186cm midfielder
Explosive ball winner who also showed signs of life behind the ball.
Why?
Four academy gifts for the Suns, who may just win the draft. Dimma’s got some new toys.
25
Archer Reid
Collingwood
Gippsland Power, 203cm forward
Brother of Essendon’s Zach Reid had a so-so season but is a super ball user by foot.
Why?
Will Kelly is on the outer, Nathan Murphy’s future is clouded and swingman Jeremy Howe is 33. But could Collard creep through to the Pies?
26
Taylor Goad
Adelaide
South Adelaide, 206cm ruckman
Ex-basketballer has toe and is largely untapped after only one SANFL season. Grew up idolising Sam Jacobs as a Crows fan.
Why?
Reilly O’Brien is 28 and Riley Thilthorpe is unlikely to become a full-time ruckman. So it is time for the Crows to up-skill an understudy.
27
Harry De Mattia
St Kilda
Dandenong Stingrays, 184cm utility
Run and gun utility who also passes the character test in flying colours.
Why?
Lyon lamented the Saints’ lack of leg speed and this lad has some serious toe.
28
Matt Carroll
Carlton
Sandringham Dragons, 188cm defender
Carroll has been low on fanfare but crept his way up draft boards as the season wore on. Splash of speed surging out of the backline.
Why?
Blues like this kid who might be an upgrade on delisted wingman Lochie O’Brien.
Inside 50 Newslette
Most of all because the first two names are easier to spell
AFL phantom draft: Shock calls and a live trade as top 28 picks predicted by our expert — FOX SPORTS Australia
Foxfooty.com.au predicts how the first round of the draft will pan out, including six rival bids, plus the inside word on which prospects your club could take across the two-night event.
If WC have a healthy list next year they won't finish last. Home ground advantage is huge. Not much has to go right for them to win 5+ games.
Similar threads
