Resource Eagles Player Ratings 2024

[BeornJ]

I will be updating this table throughout the season.

I use the website wheeloratings.com to get the rankings, and then colour co-ordinate to demonstrate players who are ranked elite, above-average, average, and below-average in their positions.

All players

View attachment 1974420


Players 24 and under ranking for their age group.

View attachment 1974421

 

[BeornJ]

Round One:

Elite: 0
Above Average: 5
Average: 8
Below Average: 10

Notes:

• Ginbey is being ranked as a midfielder even though it is clear he didn't play a lot of midfield minutes in round one.
• Jamieson is being ranked as a key forward when it should have been Key Defender, or Ruck
• Chesser ranked quite high considering he only played a half
• Reid is already ranked as above average for a midfielder, and is currently the second highest first year player (not counting mature recruits)
• Our KPPs stunk in round one, hopefully we see a quick improvement.

 

[BeornJ]

Round Two:

Elite: 1
Above Average: 5
Average: 7
Below Average: 13

Notes:

• McGovern is our first elite player, hurray! Barrass is close behind him.

 

[BeornJ]

I am also going to keep track of our young players development by tracking players 24 and under and ranking them against other players their age.

 

[BeornJ]

Round Three
Elite: 1
Above Average: 5
Average: 6
Below Average: 15

View attachment 1946140

 

[BeornJ]

Round Four

Elite: 0
Above Average: 7
Average: 5
Below Average: 17

 

[BeornJ]

Round Five

Elite: 2
Above Average: 5
Average: 5
Below Average: 17


Notes:

• Waterman and Yeo are our two elite players after round 5.
• Reid is far and away the best ranked player for his year group. His average ranking points is 11.58, the next best is Will Graham with 9.10 (however, Graham has only played 2 games). He is also the 2nd ranked teenager (behind Sheezel). Ginbey is the fifth ranked teenager.

 

[BeornJ]

Round Six

Elite: 2
Above Average: 6
Average: 6
Below Average: 16


Notes:

• Sheed is ranked as below average but this is after 10 or so minutes of play, so
• Reid is the 28th ranked midfielder, and with an average ranking points of 14 he is nearly double the next best player of his year group (Will Graham at 8.63)
• Ginbey is flying under the radar but is the 4th best rated player in his age group, and is averaging the most contested possessions in his age group.

Players 24 and under

 

[free2play]

Round Six

Elite: 2
Above Average: 6
Average: 6
Below Average: 16


Notes:

• Sheed is ranked as below average but this is after 10 or so minutes of play, so
• Reid is the 28th ranked midfielder, and with an average ranking points of 14 he is nearly double the next best player of his year group (Will Graham at 8.63)
• Ginbey is flying under the radar but is the 4th best rated player in his age group, and is averaging the most contested possessions in his age group.

View attachment 1966975


Players 24 and under

View attachment 1966976

Thanks BeornJ is there any reason why Hough is so low. I think that most people on this site would have really rated his season so far?

 

[BeornJ]

Thanks BeornJ is there any reason why Hough is so low. I think that most people on this site would have really rated his season so far?

Sheppard used to be rated really lowly as well.

The main reason is that it is hard to quantify 'shut-down' roles.

Stats don't reflect taggers keeping oppo players to career low numbers, or defenders keeping their opponents quiet/goal-less.

 

[BeornJ]

Thanks BeornJ is there any reason why Hough is so low. I think that most people on this site would have really rated his season so far?

Also, just to be clear, this resource is not my personal rating of players, it is simply organising data of 'player ratings' of eagles players after each round.

According to AFL, this is how players get points towards their ratings:

'
Which acts a player makes on the field contribute to his score?
Every time a player is involved in a passage of play he will have the chance to accrue points. But rather than his score being a simple tally of his possessions, marks, tackles, hit-outs, free-kicks and scores, his performance will be measured using a system called Equity Ratings. The system determines where and how a player influences a contest and whether the player's effort then results in a positive result for his team. Equity Ratings includes what coaches love to describe as "pressure acts". As a result, players are rewarded for interrupting opposition passages of play as well as setting up scores for their own team.



So as you can see. Taggers and lock down defenders are a real flaw of this rating system but to be fair, it would be very difficult to quantify it.

 

[BeornJ]

Round Seven:

Elite: 3
Above Average: 6
Average: 7
Below Average: 16

Notes:

• Harry Edwards becomes our third elite player
• Ryan is bizarrely listed as a medium defender
• Duggan is continuing his strong 2024, ranked as the 20th best medium defender in the comp.

Players 24 and Under

 

[Trouto]

How is H. Edwards elite and 6th best key def with all players, but only 8th for under 24???

Its a very good come back for Harry though

Its great we have the 1st and 4th ranked mids for youngster

 

[BeornJ]

How is H. Edwards elite and 6th best key def with all players, but only 8th for under 24???

Its a very good come back for Harry though

Its great we have the 1st and 4th ranked mids for youngster

Good pick up!

The 24 and under table ranks all players of an age group regardless of position. In H Edwards' age group there are a lot of midfielders with more ranking points than him.

So Ginbey is the 4th ranked player in his age group, not just 4th ranked midfielder.


It is more a pet project of mine, the 'elite' etc. groupings mean less in that table.

 

[eaglevision]

Good pick up!

The 24 and under table ranks all players of an age group regardless of position. In H Edwards' age group there are a lot of midfielders with more ranking points than him.

So Ginbey is the 4th ranked player in his age group, not just 4th ranked midfielder.


It is more a pet project of mine, the 'elite' etc. groupings mean less in that table.

Be interested to see who rounds out the under 25 top 10 after Harley if that data is readily accessible within your metadata matrix algorithm.

 

[BeornJ]

Be interested to see who rounds out the under 25 top 10 after Harley if that data is readily accessible within your metadata matrix algorithm.

Here is the top 20 for players who will be 25 or under by the end of the year (4 games minimum)

1. Matt Rowell (GC) 21.21
2. Nick Daicos (Coll) 18.46
3. Caleb Serong (Frem) 17.86
4. Tom Green (GWS) 16.39
5. Zak Butters (Port) 16.27
6. Nick Blakey (Syd) 16.03
7. Izak Rankine (Adel)
8. Chad Warner (Syd) 14.71
9. Luke Jackson (Frem) 14.61
10. Errol Gulden (Syd) 14.43
11. Max Holmes (Geel) 14.29
12. Noah Anderson (GC) 14.17
13. Tom Powell (NM) 14.04
14. Harley Reid (WC) 14.00
15. Connor Rozee (Port) 13.87
16. Jai Newcombe (Haw) 13.23
17. Finn Callaghan (GWS) 12.90
18. Harry Sheezel (NM) 12.69
19. George Wardlaw (NM) 12.63
20. Sam Durham (Ess) 12.57

 

[Trouto]

Here is the top 20 for players who will be 25 or under by the end of the year (4 games minimum)

1. Matt Rowell (GC) 21.21
2. Nick Daicos (Coll) 18.46
3. Caleb Strong (Frem) 17.86
4. Tom Green (GWS) 16.39
5. Zak Butters (Port) 16.27
6. Nick Blakey (Syd) 16.03
7. Izak Rankine (Adel)
8. Chad Warner (Syd) 14.71
9. Luke Jackson (Frem) 14.61
10. Errol Gulden (Syd) 14.43
11. Max Holmes (Geel) 14.29
12. Noah Anderson (GC) 14.17
13. Tom Powell (NM) 14.04
14. Harley Reid (WC) 14.00
15. Connor Rozee (Port) 13.87
16. Jai Newcombe (Haw) 13.23
17. Finn Callaghan (GWS) 12.90
18. Harry Sheezel (NM) 12.69
19. George Wardlaw (NM) 12.63
20. Sam Durham (Ess) 12.57

is this from your stats or the AFL stats?

 

[BeornJ]

is this from your stats or the AFL stats?

AFL Stats. It is their Player Rating System.

I just collect the data from here https://www.wheeloratings.com/afl_stats.html?year=2024

 

[flyinghi64]

Wow Sheezel 18th.
Just goes to show, possessions aren't everything.

 

[Trouto]

AFL Stats. It is their Player Rating System.

I just collect the data from here https://www.wheeloratings.com/afl_stats.html?year=2024

yeah so they say all 20 of these players are better than Jason H-F? the guy's a gun

 

[BeornJ]

yeah so they say all 20 of these players are better than Jason H-F? the guy's a gun

JHF is just outside that group with average ranking points of 12.4.

Agree, great player. He probably 'suffers' in the ranking sense of a bunch of similar elite players in his team taking points from him.

 

[Trouto]

JHF is just outside that group with average ranking points of 12.4.

Agree, great player. He probably 'suffers' in the ranking sense of a bunch of similar elite players in his team taking points from him.

yeah true, Port have got an enviable trio of young players there...