-
LIVE: Port Adelaide v Carlton - 7:30PM Thu
Squiggle tips Port at 63% chance -- What's your tip? -- Team line-ups »
Preview First Preliminary Final – Collingwood vs GWS Giants, Saturday 21st September 2019, MCG, 4.35pm
- Thread starter Land of the Giants
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
- Apr 12, 2012
- 46,592
- 42,566
- AFL Club
- GWS
Jeaz the universe is really against the Giants in this one. Sheesh.
Where do you start....
He’s out, and so are we.
Cursed.
Cursed.
Land of the Giants
Premiership Player
- Thread starter
- #160
Well said.Character building as a club, we’re gonna have a red hot go on Saturday with or without tobes, lachie and cogs. I’m backing the team that runs out on Saturday afternoon
We win as a team, we lose as a team, c’mon Giants!!!
F#*K
Is this confirmed though ? Or is he in hospital getting a check up or something ? And the media run with it.
Not even anything on the AFL site
However usually where there is smoke there is fire
On SM-N960F using BigFooty.com mobile app
Not even anything on the AFL site
However usually where there is smoke there is fire
On SM-N960F using BigFooty.com mobile app
Boris the Contradiction
Cancelled
Hey guys, I come in peace.
Unlucky about Whitfield. The guy is an absolute gun who I'd love in my team. Hopefully his health is ok.
On Greene, I know that priority number 1 is to get him out there because he's one of your best and is a point of difference, but I'm interested to know your feelings towards the player this week? The footage looked pretty sketchy to me, even if it was obvious he didn't get Neale's nose as was testified. Rightly or wrongly, I think the players try to help each other out, but either way I think it was a stretch to suspend him this week. There was something there, but probably nothing conclusive enough for the charge.
However, the consensus of most footy fans seems to be that he should have been suspended last week and I think that's probably right, with the Tribunal having contrived the fine to ensure he was out there. He was very fortunate to play your first final and the Tribunal were never going to be happy with him this week, regardless of the stuff about past history being irrelevant.
Given that you just fell over the line by 3 points despite being outplayed for long periods and that Toby was probably best on ground, despite being lucky to be out there at all, are you guys furious at him for putting himself in that position just one week later? I know I would be if this happened with one of our stars, even if they don't have Greene's checkered Tribunal/MRP history.
He just keeps stuffing up this bloke, which is a shame because he's a jet and is great to watch. What do you guys think it is? White line fever, just a violent and cynical guy, ********, mental instability, idoit....all of the above?
Last year it was kicking blokes, this year it's scratching blokes, there was the stamp on Dalhause when he was at the Dogs. Is it time the club turns the blow torch on Toby and forces him to change, perhaps using behavioural clauses in his contract to fine him for his behaviour, or do they threaten to trade him, or something else? Is this sort of thing already happening?
Again - this has nothing to do with the game on the weekend - I'm just an admirer of his football and am genuinely curious. Because he's simply too good and is probably on too much coin to be missing so much footy for non health reasons.
Unlucky about Whitfield. The guy is an absolute gun who I'd love in my team. Hopefully his health is ok.
On Greene, I know that priority number 1 is to get him out there because he's one of your best and is a point of difference, but I'm interested to know your feelings towards the player this week? The footage looked pretty sketchy to me, even if it was obvious he didn't get Neale's nose as was testified. Rightly or wrongly, I think the players try to help each other out, but either way I think it was a stretch to suspend him this week. There was something there, but probably nothing conclusive enough for the charge.
However, the consensus of most footy fans seems to be that he should have been suspended last week and I think that's probably right, with the Tribunal having contrived the fine to ensure he was out there. He was very fortunate to play your first final and the Tribunal were never going to be happy with him this week, regardless of the stuff about past history being irrelevant.
Given that you just fell over the line by 3 points despite being outplayed for long periods and that Toby was probably best on ground, despite being lucky to be out there at all, are you guys furious at him for putting himself in that position just one week later? I know I would be if this happened with one of our stars, even if they don't have Greene's checkered Tribunal/MRP history.
He just keeps stuffing up this bloke, which is a shame because he's a jet and is great to watch. What do you guys think it is? White line fever, just a violent and cynical guy, ********, mental instability, idoit....all of the above?
Last year it was kicking blokes, this year it's scratching blokes, there was the stamp on Dalhause when he was at the Dogs. Is it time the club turns the blow torch on Toby and forces him to change, perhaps using behavioural clauses in his contract to fine him for his behaviour, or do they threaten to trade him, or something else? Is this sort of thing already happening?
Again - this has nothing to do with the game on the weekend - I'm just an admirer of his football and am genuinely curious. Because he's simply too good and is probably on too much coin to be missing so much footy for non health reasons.
Will be tough but not completely impossible. Williams to spend more time midfield as he did last time against the Pies. Cumming comes in for Whitfield and Hill for Toby.
Shaw Davis Kennedy
Corr Taylor Haynes
Williams Hopper Kelly
TOJ Cameron Daniels
Lloyd HH Hill
Mumford De Boer Taranto
Perryman Cumming Keefe Reid
Shaw Davis Kennedy
Corr Taylor Haynes
Williams Hopper Kelly
TOJ Cameron Daniels
Lloyd HH Hill
Mumford De Boer Taranto
Perryman Cumming Keefe Reid
Land of the Giants
Premiership Player
- Thread starter
- #167
Lachie's out of the prelim.
- Apr 12, 2012
- 46,592
- 42,566
- AFL Club
- GWS
You can start with not going with the bullshit outrage and making shit up.
Either that or just **** off.
KevDawg
EFC & GWS
Hately looks a chance to play on the wing in front of a huge finals crowd...
Whitfield out hurts. Greene and Coniglio not playing makes this tough.
hopper, Taranto, Kelly, Davis, Cameron, Finlayson, Haynes, Williams, Himmelburg need to raise their games.
Grundy, Pendlebury, Adams, Treloar, Sidebottom, Phillips, Howe, Crisp will Be hard to stop.
Handy 3 ins for GWS though for the GF if they win.
hopper, Taranto, Kelly, Davis, Cameron, Finlayson, Haynes, Williams, Himmelburg need to raise their games.
Grundy, Pendlebury, Adams, Treloar, Sidebottom, Phillips, Howe, Crisp will Be hard to stop.
Handy 3 ins for GWS though for the GF if they win.
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked
- Locked
