Henneman, Reynolds and a draft pick should let us get this immensely talented player who we really need to bolster our weakening backline. Or he could be used in bursts on the ball. If we really wanted him,we could him, so lets trade for Joel SMith.
Lets get joel Smith
- Thread starter Bomaz_Magic
- Start date
- Tagged users None
We are crap, but not stupid (much).bomaz said:
Smith is tradable, but not if Henneman is included.
- Thread starter
- #4
What about Winderlich, Reynolds and or a pick for Smith.
If SMith's out of contract we have pleeeeenty of room thanks to Sean nottaWellman.
If SMith's out of contract we have pleeeeenty of room thanks to Sean nottaWellman.
- Thread starter
- #6
What if we chuck in Hille?
- Thread starter
- #8
Solomon > Smith.
Look you already took Jacobs and Beaumont, whhy not Henners, he's well re: by Sheeds.
If not:
Smith
Murphy, Hille (to back up Spida) and or a draft pick/Nathan Lovett Murray.
Look you already took Jacobs and Beaumont, whhy not Henners, he's well re: by Sheeds.
If not:
Smith
Murphy, Hille (to back up Spida) and or a draft pick/Nathan Lovett Murray.
bomaz said:
Na, IMO id pass on that. Dont rate Hille or Lov Murray, plus got Williams so dont need him. Murphy i rate at the moment, but he has been around for a while and has been up and down over the years. And Henneman, mate every bombers supporter has bagged the ******** outta him all year, why would we want him. Soloman, simular player, age not that much diff, win win. thats if Smith wants out, Id rather Smith.
- Thread starter
- #10
If I said Henners was an excellent player would it changed your mind?
- Thread starter
- #12
But he really is.
wizardofoz18
Draftee
- Jun 8, 2004
- 19
- 0
- Other Teams
- bombers
by the sounds of it you have an alterior motive to get smith to windy hill....are you secretly in love with him or something dude??
if you think henno is leaving the club b4 he gets bald and rinkly you gots another thing comming....i still stand my my trade strong feeling
sammy hunt straight swap for david spriggs...(even tho i luv sammy, he not gonna get a go with us, and spriggs will be great for us)
if you think henno is leaving the club b4 he gets bald and rinkly you gots another thing comming....i still stand my my trade strong feeling
sammy hunt straight swap for david spriggs...(even tho i luv sammy, he not gonna get a go with us, and spriggs will be great for us)
W's Machines
Debutant
- Aug 26, 2004
- 63
- 0
- Other Teams
- Hawthorn
bomaz said:
How about you give us Laycock and maybe Teddy Richards and a draft pick for him. Heneman is not even worth Holland.
- Thread starter
- #15
I know about that trade but I want SMith almost as much as I don't want Bolton and Reynolds, plus SMiths out of contract and wanting to leave and we need Smithy.
- Thread starter
- #17
W's Machines said:
Hows about no.
However, chuck in Everitt and remove Laycock and you've got a deal W.
Oh god... this thread is like a bad dream that keeps getting worse.
Henno? Do you really think Henno is tradable? He should just be delisted. True he has had some good and average games, but how many? Of the games he's played how many good ones has he had? Maybe one in 10 or 20? And should that keep him on the books... nope!
Someone said the other day that Henno got a game almost every week in the 2001 team, which was a preety hard team to get into!!! Perhaps true, and perhaps he was playing better footy then. The thing is, if he's been playing crap ever since why do we still have him? 2001 was 3 seasons ago and he's done nothing since. That's 1/3 of a good career.
Henno? Do you really think Henno is tradable? He should just be delisted. True he has had some good and average games, but how many? Of the games he's played how many good ones has he had? Maybe one in 10 or 20? And should that keep him on the books... nope!
Someone said the other day that Henno got a game almost every week in the 2001 team, which was a preety hard team to get into!!! Perhaps true, and perhaps he was playing better footy then. The thing is, if he's been playing crap ever since why do we still have him? 2001 was 3 seasons ago and he's done nothing since. That's 1/3 of a good career.
hird is a champ
Senior List
Dont want Smith specially if reynolds is in the trade. He had a hard year this year but the kid can play expect him to be good next season.
Ps. tipping early henno to be essendons next fullback
Ps. tipping early henno to be essendons next fullback
Bartholin Juice
Club Legend
Why would we want smith? We've got Welsh, McVeigh, Solomon, McPhee, Bolton, M. Johnson, Hunt... We've already got plenty of running defenders.
Would like to hang on to Reynolds. Just needs a decent run with injury, he's got plenty of talent.
Would like to hang on to Reynolds. Just needs a decent run with injury, he's got plenty of talent.
- Thread starter
- #23
We'll give you J. Nash and 2nd rnd pick+ or Winderlich.
Also, Henneman = Dud < Bolton
Also, Henneman = Dud < Bolton
Bartholin Juice
Club Legend
bomaz said:
Why would you want to trade Nash or Winderlich for Smith? Those two are part of the future of the club. What will Smith give us? Not much.
marcuz
Norm Smith Medallist
bomaz said:
No thanks, we need decent tall defenders not flankers. Plus he is 28 at the start of next year and we arent a joel smith away from a flag.
Stick with the kids, enough with the band-aid solutions.
Similar threads
