Oppo Camp The non North football discussion thread II

[TooUglyForFugly]

Joel Selwood signs 4-year extension at Geelong.

 

[Devington]

Joel Selwood signs 4-year extension at Geelong.

Good for them, they needed to get that done ASAP so they know how much money they have left to play with. Danger, Joel, and Hawkins would be taking up a damn big chunk each.

 

[TennisPlayerAndy]

Damien Cavka forced to retire. Degenerative foot injury.

 

[Heaps of fun]

Jarryd Roughead out for half the year with a PCL.

 

[TennisPlayerAndy]

Massive loss.

 

[Harris 10]

Jarryd Roughead out for half the year with a PCL.

The pricks have won 3 in a row but geez it sucks when you lose players before the season even starts.

On the back of Lake, Hale and now Roughy being out it will be a tough first half for the Hawks.

 

[utility]

He's a big loss but their system is what has made them successful.

 

[TennisPlayerAndy]

He's a big loss but their system is what has made them successful.

No Hale, Lake and now Roughead for half a year.

They will struggle to make top 4.

 

[Hojuman]

Somehow l think they'll find a way to cover him.

 

[Donkey Chop]

It's probably the last player they could afford to lose

 

[muttley45]

A Hawk supporting mate assures me Schoenmaker can step up to cover Roughy

 

[Dan]

They'll adapt.

 

[Pykie]

Knightmares Top 50 draftee's of the last 5 years, laughable really:

1. Jesse Hogan
2. Jeremy Cameron
3. Marcus Bontempelli
4. Oliver Wines
5. Patrick Cripps
6. Dyson Heppell
7. Jacob Hopper
8. Clayton Oliver
9. Tom Lynch (GC)
10. Joe Daniher
11. Brodie Grundy
12. Jake Stringer
13. Darcy Moore
14. Jordan De Goey
15. Isaac Heeney
16. Luke Parker
17. Tom Liberatore
18. Brad Crouch
19. Angus Brayshaw
20. Callum Mills
21. Chad Wingard
22. Jack Darling
23. Jacob Weitering
24. Tom McDonald
25. Dylan Shiel
26. Adam Treloar
27. Harley Bennell
28. Andrew Gaff
29. Dion Prestia
30. Jackson Macrae
31. Jake Lever
32. Harris Andrews
33. Jack Martin
34. Stephen Coniglio
35. Tom Mitchell
36. Luke Dahlhaus
37. Lachie Neale
38. Jeremy McGovern
39. Elliott Yeo
40. Bradley Hill
41. Cameron McCarthy
42. Tom Boyd
43. Paddy McCartin
44. Christian Petracca
45. Jack Billings
46. Jamie Elliott
47. Brodie Smith
48. Marley Williams
49. Jaeger O'Meara
50. Taylor Adams


Although no surprise he managed to "slip" 6 Collingwood players in there, I mean Marley Williams? Wingard at 21, Oliver @ 8 and under the same guidelines puts Petracca at 44? Brodie Grundy @ 11, rofl.

Isaac Smith should realistically be in the top 10

 

[Pykie]

Before anyone jumps down my thoat, this would be mine:

1. Jeremy Cameron
2. Marcus Bontempelli
3. Jesse Hogan
4. Chad Wingard
5. Luke Parker
6. Adam Treloar
7. Jake Stringer
8. Dyson Heppell
9. Olly Wines
10. Dion Prestia
11. Dylan Shiel
12. Harley Bennell
13. Isaac Smith
14. Tom Lynch
15. Andrew Gaff
16. Brodie Smith
17. Jeremy McGovern
18. Patrick Cripps
19. Lachie Neale
20. Brad Hill
21. Steven May
22. Jack Macrae
23. Luke Dalhaus
24. Josh Caddy
25. Jack Darling
26. Will Langford
27. Elliot Yeo
28. Tom McDonald
29. Jamie Elliott
30. Dom Tyson
31. Kade Kolodjashnij
32. Jack Hombsch
33. David Swallow
34. Tom Liberatore
35. Jared Polec
36. Toby Greene
37. Jack Viney
38. Zach Merrett
39. Mitch Wallis
40. Cam Guthrie
41. Lachie Whitfield
42. Shaun Atley
43. Brandon Ellis
44. Luke Dunstan
45. Rory Laird
46. Stephen Coniglio
47. Billy Longer
48. Trent McKenzie
49. Joe Danniher
50. Ben Brown

 

[Harris 10]

Before anyone jumps down my thoat, this would be mine:

1. Jeremy Cameron
2. Marcus Bontempelli
3. Luke Parker
4. Adam Treloar
5. Jake Stringer
6. Olly Wines
7. Dion Prestia
8. Dylan Shiel
9. Harley Bennell
10. Isaac Smith
11. Tom Lynch
12. Andrew Gaff
13. Brodie Smith
14. Jeremy McGovern
15. Patrick Cripps
16. Lachie Neale
17. Brad Hill
18. Steven May
19. Jack Macrae
20. Luke Dalhaus
21. Josh Caddy
22. Jack Darling
23. Will Langford
24. Tom McDonald
25. Jamie Elliott
26. Dom Tyson
27. Kade Kolodjashnij
28. Jack Hombsch
29. David Swallow
30. Tom Liberatore
31. Jared Polec
32. Toby Greene
33. Jack Viney
34. Zach Merrett
35. Mitch Wallis
36. Cam Guthrie
37. Lachie Whitfield
38. Shaun Atley
39. Brandon Ellis
40. Luke Dunstan
41. Rory Laird
42. Stephen Coniglio
43. Billy Longer
44. Trent McKenzie
45. Jamie Cripps
46. Joe Danniher
47. Ben Brown
48. Dom Sheed
49. Elliot Yeo
50. Jack Crisp

Basically he rated Oliver a best 22 chance in his draft year then changed it to a top 5 after seeing others phantoms. Then rates him at 8 in the last 5 years off the back of nothing.

 

[Twinkletoes]

They'll adapt.

I read that as "They'll adopt." and thought "they bloody well will too, the sneaky pricks."

 

[KangaFan35]

Knightmares Top 50 draftee's of the last 5 years, laughable really:

1. Jesse Hogan
2. Jeremy Cameron
3. Marcus Bontempelli
4. Oliver Wines
5. Patrick Cripps
6. Dyson Heppell
7. Jacob Hopper
8. Clayton Oliver
9. Tom Lynch (GC)
10. Joe Daniher
11. Brodie Grundy
12. Jake Stringer
13. Darcy Moore
14. Jordan De Goey
15. Isaac Heeney
16. Luke Parker
17. Tom Liberatore
18. Brad Crouch
19. Angus Brayshaw
20. Callum Mills
21. Chad Wingard
22. Jack Darling
23. Jacob Weitering
24. Tom McDonald
25. Dylan Shiel
26. Adam Treloar
27. Harley Bennell
28. Andrew Gaff
29. Dion Prestia
30. Jackson Macrae
31. Jake Lever
32. Harris Andrews
33. Jack Martin
34. Stephen Coniglio
35. Tom Mitchell
36. Luke Dahlhaus
37. Lachie Neale
38. Jeremy McGovern
39. Elliott Yeo
40. Bradley Hill
41. Cameron McCarthy
42. Tom Boyd
43. Paddy McCartin
44. Christian Petracca
45. Jack Billings
46. Jamie Elliott
47. Brodie Smith
48. Marley Williams
49. Jaeger O'Meara
50. Taylor Adams


Although no surprise he managed to "slip" 6 Collingwood players in there, I mean Marley Williams? Wingard at 21, Oliver @ 8 and under the same guidelines puts Petracca at 44? Brodie Grundy @ 11, rofl.

Isaac Smith should realistically be in the top 10

I stopped reading when I saw Brodie Grundy at number 11

 

[TooUglyForFugly]

I didn't read any of it aside from what I can see in un-extended quotes.

 

[NMFCARSENAL98]

Before anyone jumps down my thoat, this would be mine:

1. Jeremy Cameron
2. Marcus Bontempelli
3. Jesse Hogan
4. Chad Wingard
5. Luke Parker
6. Adam Treloar
7. Jake Stringer
8. Dyson Heppell
9. Olly Wines
10. Dion Prestia
11. Dylan Shiel
12. Harley Bennell
13. Isaac Smith
14. Tom Lynch
15. Andrew Gaff
16. Brodie Smith
17. Jeremy McGovern
18. Patrick Cripps
19. Lachie Neale
20. Brad Hill
21. Steven May
22. Jack Macrae
23. Luke Dalhaus
24. Josh Caddy
25. Jack Darling
26. Will Langford
27. Elliot Yeo
28. Tom McDonald
29. Jamie Elliott
30. Dom Tyson
31. Kade Kolodjashnij
32. Jack Hombsch
33. David Swallow
34. Tom Liberatore
35. Jared Polec
36. Toby Greene
37. Jack Viney
38. Zach Merrett
39. Mitch Wallis
40. Cam Guthrie
41. Lachie Whitfield
42. Shaun Atley
43. Brandon Ellis
44. Luke Dunstan
45. Rory Laird
46. Stephen Coniglio
47. Billy Longer
48. Trent McKenzie
49. Joe Danniher
50. Ben Brown

Generally good, but I reckon Zach Merret deserves a lot more than 38. He has been awesome.

 

[jess_1804]

Before anyone jumps down my thoat, this would be mine:

1. Jeremy Cameron
2. Marcus Bontempelli
3. Jesse Hogan
4. Chad Wingard
5. Luke Parker
6. Adam Treloar
7. Jake Stringer
8. Dyson Heppell
9. Olly Wines
10. Dion Prestia
11. Dylan Shiel
12. Harley Bennell
13. Isaac Smith
14. Tom Lynch
15. Andrew Gaff
16. Brodie Smith
17. Jeremy McGovern
18. Patrick Cripps
19. Lachie Neale
20. Brad Hill
21. Steven May
22. Jack Macrae
23. Luke Dalhaus
24. Josh Caddy
25. Jack Darling
26. Will Langford
27. Elliot Yeo
28. Tom McDonald
29. Jamie Elliott
30. Dom Tyson
31. Kade Kolodjashnij
32. Jack Hombsch
33. David Swallow
34. Tom Liberatore
35. Jared Polec
36. Toby Greene
37. Jack Viney
38. Zach Merrett
39. Mitch Wallis
40. Cam Guthrie
41. Lachie Whitfield
42. Shaun Atley
43. Brandon Ellis
44. Luke Dunstan
45. Rory Laird
46. Stephen Coniglio
47. Billy Longer
48. Trent McKenzie
49. Joe Danniher
50. Ben Brown

Very nice list, much better than Knightmare's (and slightly less bias). I also enjoy that BBB is number 50.

 

[ThePezDispenser]

Isaac Smith should realistically be in the top 10

13. Isaac Smith

Hmmmmm :sternlook

 

[Arden]

Knightmares Top 50 draftee's of the last 5 years, laughable really:

1. Jesse Hogan
2. Jeremy Cameron
3. Marcus Bontempelli
4. Oliver Wines
5. Patrick Cripps
6. Dyson Heppell
7. Jacob Hopper
8. Clayton Oliver
9. Tom Lynch (GC)
10. Joe Daniher
11. Brodie Grundy
12. Jake Stringer
13. Darcy Moore
14. Jordan De Goey
15. Isaac Heeney
16. Luke Parker
17. Tom Liberatore
18. Brad Crouch
19. Angus Brayshaw
20. Callum Mills
21. Chad Wingard
22. Jack Darling
23. Jacob Weitering
24. Tom McDonald
25. Dylan Shiel
26. Adam Treloar
27. Harley Bennell
28. Andrew Gaff
29. Dion Prestia
30. Jackson Macrae
31. Jake Lever
32. Harris Andrews
33. Jack Martin
34. Stephen Coniglio
35. Tom Mitchell
36. Luke Dahlhaus
37. Lachie Neale
38. Jeremy McGovern
39. Elliott Yeo
40. Bradley Hill
41. Cameron McCarthy
42. Tom Boyd
43. Paddy McCartin
44. Christian Petracca
45. Jack Billings
46. Jamie Elliott
47. Brodie Smith
48. Marley Williams
49. Jaeger O'Meara
50. Taylor Adams


Although no surprise he managed to "slip" 6 Collingwood players in there, I mean Marley Williams? Wingard at 21, Oliver @ 8 and under the same guidelines puts Petracca at 44? Brodie Grundy @ 11, rofl.

Isaac Smith should realistically be in the top 10

2 x All-Australian Chad Wingard, 10 places behind Brodie Grundy.

That guy is a douchecanoe.

 

[DarkPhoenix]

Reckon yours shat all over KM's Pykie.

 

[Ohhh Errol]

 

[Jay-Z]